Explanations for Conformity

Normative social influence

  • Conformity can be explained as stemming from two different motivations:

    • Normative social influence (NSI): the need to be liked/accepted by the group (fear of rejection)

    • Informational social influence (ISI): the need to know what to do (fear of social disapproval/humiliation)

  • NSI occurs when an individual is keen to adopt the social norms of a specific group, e.g.:

    • Going to church every week because that is what the group do

    • Wearing black all the time because that is what the group do

    • Professing to dislike a particular person because that is what the group do

  • Someone is more likely to be affected by NSI if they feel that their behaviour and attitudes do not align with those of the group, e.g.:

    • ‘I stopped going to church years ago but the group goes every week’

  • This lack of cohesion with the group may cause anxiety which in turn may lead to an adjustment in behaviour, e.g.:

    • ‘I’m going to start attending church with the group so that they feel that I am one of them’

  • NSI may involve an individual going against their inner beliefs, ideals or opinions in order not to be rejected by the group, e.g.:

    • Agreeing with the group that a new film is rubbish while secretly having enjoyed it

    • Ignoring a school friend because this is what everyone else in the group is doing but privately believing that this behaviour is cruel and wrong

  • NSI as an explanation of conformity is linked to compliance and identification

  • The essence of NSI is emotional as it is based on the need to be liked and accepted

Informational social influence

  • Informational social influence (ISI) tends to take place when the individual is unsure and/or lacks knowledge about what to do or how to behave in a specific situation, e.g.:

    • On someone’s first day at work they will look to others for cues as to how to behave in the office, where to go at lunchtime, the appropriate dress code, etc.

    • In a new university class, the professor sets a difficult equation to solve

      • someone unsure of the answer may listen to what other are saying and agree with their answer (even if their answer turns out to be incorrect)

  • ISI occurs when an individual looks to the group for guidance

  • ISI can occur quickly when there is a crisis and a decision needs to be made quickly

    • The assumption that follows is that the group knows what to do

    • If everyone in the group assumes that everyone else knows what to do, then this can result in faulty decision-making which could potentially be disastrous (e.g. mistaking in piloting a passenger plane to large-scale financial lending)

  • Someone is more likely to be affected by ISI if they are insecure about what is deemed ‘right/wrong’ behaviour, e.g.:

    • Someone collapses in the street but no one stops to help them, so the individual assumes that the situation is not serious, thus no help is given

  • ISI as an explanation of conformity is linked to internalisaton

  • The essence of ISI is cognitive as it is based on information processing

Evaluation of explanations for conformity

Strengths

  • There is good research support for ISI:

    • Jenness (1932) asked participants to individually estimate the number of beans contained in a jar

    • Participants then discussed their estimates in a group and then each participant made a second independent estimate

    • The findings showed that the second estimate moved closer to the group estimate, indicating ISI, thus the theory had validity

  • NSI has good application to real behaviour in real settings (high ecological validity):

    • Schultz et al. (2008) conducted a series of field experiments to test NSI

    • Guests were exposed to signs providing descriptive normative information (e.g. that most other guests reuse their towels)

    • The findings showed that guests who received normative messages were significantly more likely to reuse towels than those in control conditions (no sign)

    • This demonstrates that NSI can influence real behaviours in everyday settings

Limitations

  • Neither explanation for conformity explains why some people resist both NSI and ISI, e.g. freedom fighters, rebels, iconoclasts

    • The above observation means that both explanations for conformity cannot be generalised to everyone

      • to this extent they cannot account for individual differences

  • It is rare for both NSI and ISI to be tested in real conditions

    • Most research in this field is lab-based

    • Lab-based research is low in mundane realism which reduces the scope of its external validity