Correlation and Diversification (4:46)
Investment Assets and Performance Metrics
The following example explores the interaction between expected return, standard deviation, and correlation using two primary investment vehicles:
A debt-oriented mutual fund (bond fund).
An equity fund.
Data Metrics for Debt and Equity Funds (referenced from Chapter 7 of the Bodie Kane and Marcus textbook):
Debt Fund Expected Return ():
Equity Fund Expected Return ():
Debt Fund Volatility ():
Equity Fund Volatility ():
Trade-off Relationship:
The debt fund provides a lower return but exhibits lower volatility.
The equity fund provides a higher expected return but exhibits higher volatility.
The Role of Correlation in Asset Allocation
The trade-off between risk and reward is a fundamental function of expected return, standard deviation, and correlation ().
Correlation Range: Values range between () and ().
The impact of varying correlations on the choice between debt and equity funds determines the effectiveness of the mean-variance trade-off.
Reward and Risk Space: Investments are plotted in a specification space where volatility (standard deviation) is on the x-axis and expected return is on the y-axis.
Scenarios of Correlation: Perfect Positive Correlation ()
When correlation () equals (perfect positive correlation), there is no beneficial trade-off from a diversification standpoint.
Investment Behavior:
A pure debt fund investor earns with expected volatility.
If an investor requires a higher expected return (e.g., ) to "combat the laws of physics faced in the world," they must increase their allocation to equities.
Movement in the risk-reward space is strictly linear between the debt fund and the equity fund.
Increasing the return to the required level as the only choice simultaneously increases risk in a straight line; there is no overt benefit to combining the assets beyond shifting the weighted average.
Modern Portfolio Theory and Declining Correlation
As correlations move from perfect positive () toward lower values (such as or ), the benefits of diversification become apparent.
Core Principle of Modern Portfolio Theory:
For any given level of expected return, it is possible to achieve that return with a lower level of volatility.
Alternatively, for the same level of volatility, an investor can potentially achieve a higher expected return.
Improvement of the Reward-to-Risk Ratio: As correlations decrease, the trade-off between debt and equity funds for a given percentage allocation becomes increasingly beneficial.
Geographical Metaphor for Portfolio Optimization:
If the reward-risk plot were a map of the United States, investors would seek to move toward the "Northwest" (high return, low risk).
While one might enjoy "drinking coffee in Miami" (representing a less optimal risk-reward position), the goal is to reach "Seattle's finest" in the Northwest quadrant.
Lower correlations allow investors to trade off risk and reward more efficiently, shifting the portfolio position toward the Northwest.
Extremes of Diversification: Perfect Negative Correlation ()
An "amazing occurrence" in financial theory occurs when correlation is set to .
Zero Risk Combinations: By combining two investments that both have positive variance (risky investments), it is possible to achieve a zero-risk combination.
Hedge Portfolio: This result is referred to as an essential hedge portfolio because the negative correlation allows for the complete neutralization of risk.
The Backward Bending Frontier:
The mean-variance frontier exhibits a backward-bending nature when assets are less than perfectly positively correlated.
It is possible to start with a debt investment and add the risk of equity, and yet the overall portfolio risk actually goes down.
This phenomenon is the direct result of diversification: adding a risky asset can paradoxically decrease the total risk of the investment portfolio.