CLC Lecture 6

Lewin's Planned Change Model (Page 17)

  • Ensures that employees are ready for change

  • Executes intended change

  • Ensures that the change becomes permanent

Unfreeze stage (Page 18)

  • People experience emotions such as denial, impatience, uncertainty, and doubt

  • Managers must communicate the need for change and why it is being implemented

  • Clear communication helps employees accept the new change and let go of old customs

  • Involving employees in this stage promotes a positive approach to the change process

Change stage (Page 19)

  • Change should be implemented within a short time

  • Longer change processes increase the likelihood of employees reverting to old habits

  • Implementing change quickly helps employees understand its importance sooner

Freeze stage (Page 20)

  • Solidify the change

  • Employees tend to revert to old habits after the change is implemented

  • Interim evaluations, monitoring, and adjustments are necessary to stabilize the new situation

  • Employees need to understand that there is no turning back and act in accordance with the new situation

Kotter's 8-Step Change Model (Page 22)

  1. Establishing a sense of urgency

  2. Creating the guiding coalition

  3. Developing a vision and strategy

  4. Communicating the change vision

  5. Empowering broad-based action

  6. Generating short-term wins

  7. Consolidating gains and producing more change

  8. Anchoring new approaches in the culture

  • Emphasizes the importance of communicating the need for change and the vision of what the change will accomplish

  • Highlights the role of the leader in creating a feeling of urgency and necessity for change

Comparison of Lewin's and Kotter's Change Models (Page 23)

  • Lewin's Planned Change Model

  • Kotter's 8-Step Change Model

The Action Research Model (Page 25)

  • Focuses on planned change as a cyclical and iterative process of collaboration between "co-learners"

  • Involves organization members in the change process

  • Also referred to as "participatory action research," "action learning," "action science," or "self-design"

The Positive Model (Page 27)

  • Focuses on the organization's strengths and capabilities

  • Members understand the organization's best practices and build on them to achieve higher performance

  • Applied through appreciative inquiry, a positive way of looking at challenges

Comparison of Planned Change Models (Page 28)

  • Similarities:

    • Change preceded by diagnosis or preparation

    • Apply behavioral science knowledge

    • Stress involvement of organization members

    • Recognize the role of a consultant

  • Differences:

    • General vs. specific activities

    • Centrality of consultant role

    • Problem-solving vs. social constructionism

General Model of Planned Change (Page 29)

  • A general framework for planned change suggested by the four previous models

Different Types of Planned Change (Page 31)

  • Magnitude of Change:

    • Incremental (limited scope) vs. Fundamental/Quantum (more complex, extensive, long-term)

  • Degree of Organization:

    • Overorganized (mechanistic, bureaucratic, rigid) vs. Underorganized (needs a different model for planned change with a clearly defined role from the consultant side)

  • Domestic vs. International Settings:

    • Includes culture, equality, inclusion, time horizons

Critique of Planned Change (Page 32)

  • Conceptualization:

    • Change is not linear

    • Change is not rational nor a controlled process

    • The relationship between change and performance is unclear

    • Uncertainty about when the change process will be over

  • Practice:

    • Lack of comprehensive information, especially in the diagnosis process

    • Limited consulting skills and focus

    • Tendency towards quick fixes rather than development approaches

    • Partial (non-holistic) approaches

    • Abstract