Chapter 6 Extrinsic Motivation (human motivation)

What is Intrinsic Motivation?

  • Definition: Intrinsic motivation refers to engaging in behavior because it is inherently enjoyable or satisfying, rather than for some separable outcome.

  • Results Of: It arises from internal satisfaction and involves a desire to engage in an activity for its own sake.

Benefits of Intrinsic Motivation

  • Engagement: Leads to increased participation in activities.

  • Creativity: Fosters creative thinking and problem-solving abilities.

  • Conceptual Understanding: Enhances understanding of concepts and material.

  • High-quality Learning: Results in deeper, more sustained learning outcomes.

  • Optimal Functioning and Well-being: Contributes to mental health and overall life satisfaction.

  • Enjoyment: Engaging in activities that individuals find enjoyable reinforces motivation.

  • Curiosity: Fuels a desire to learn and explore.

  • Autonomy: Satisfies the need for self-direction in one's actions.

    • Autonomy Need Satisfaction: Fulfilling the need for autonomy boosts intrinsic motivation.

  • Psychological Satisfaction: The satisfaction of competence needs is crucial for fostering intrinsic motivation.

  • Relatedness Need Satisfaction: Meeting social connections and belonging enhances intrinsic motivation.

Factors Influencing Intrinsic Motivation

  • Providing environmental conditions that satisfy psychological needs can significantly enhance intrinsic motivation across individuals.

Concept of Extrinsic Motivation

  • Definition: Extrinsic motivation involves undertaking an activity to achieve an external reward or avoid a punishment.

  • Comparison: Contrasts with intrinsic motivation, where actions are driven by inherent satisfaction.

  • Outcomes of Extrinsic Motivation: May include various forms of motivation such as rewards or punishments.

Types of Reinforcement

  • Positive Reinforcement: Adding a desirable stimulus to increase behavior.

    • Example: Giving praise or rewards for good performance (e.g., receiving a good grade for effort).

  • Negative Reinforcement: Removing an aversive stimulus to increase behavior.

    • Example: Allowing extra playtime if chores are completed.

  • Punishment: Aimed at decreasing a behavior.

    • Positive Punishment: Adding an aversive consequence (e.g., detention for misbehavior).

    • Negative Punishment: Removing a pleasant stimulus (e.g., no outings due to poor behavior).

Effects of Punishment on Behavior

  • Potential Negative Outcomes:

    • Build resentment amongst individuals leading to temporary compliance.

    • Can lead to negative emotionality and impaired relationships.

    • Potential for poorer mental health outcomes.

    • May provide poor modeling for behavior leading to negative patterns.

Benefits of Intrinsic Motivation

  • Reinforces emotional aspects, leading to increased happiness and well-being.

  • Can improve compliance without the negative effects associated with extrinsic rewards.

  • Potential for positive informational effects, enhancing competence through positive reinforcement.

When to Use Extrinsic Incentives?

  • Best utilized when there is a lack of intrinsic motivation.

  • Important to be mindful of the timing and context of extrinsic awards.

Interaction Between Extrinsic and Intrinsic Motivation

  • Effects of External Events on Motivation: Dependent on how the event is perceived in terms of control and competence.

    • Control Perception:

    • If seen as controlling, autonomy decreases and extrinsic motivation increases.

    • If perceived as informational about one’s competence, intrinsic motivation may increase.

Autonomy and Competence Framework

  • Classifying External Events:

    • If an external event is designed to control behavior:

    • Leads to decreased autonomy and possibly decreased intrinsic motivation.

    • If intended to provide information on competence:

    • A positive effect enhances competence and intrinsic motivation, a negative effect diminishes it.

Types of Motivation

  • Identifying Motivation:

    • Four main categories of extrinsic motivation can be identified, each influencing behavior differently.

  • Controlled vs Autonomous Motivation:

    • Controlled motivation lacks internal ownership, while autonomous motivation reflects internalization and personal endorsement of the activity.

  • Internalization Process: Involves managing the transition from external regulation to intrinsic motivation, where an externally-driven activity becomes an internally-endorsed one based on feelings of competence and autonomy.