Chapter 19: Professional Conduct, Independence and Quality Management
Structure of the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct
Section 0: Introductory Materials and Principles
Contains Table 19-1 overview material.
Establishes the core Principles of Professional Conduct that govern professional behavior and ethical responsibilities.
Section 1: Rules of Professional Conduct for Members in Public Practice
Applies specifically to CPAs and accounting professionals performing public accounting services.
ET 1.100s: Integrity and Objectivity standards.
ET 1.200s: Independence standards and requirements.
ET 1.300s through ET 1.800s: Rules covering general performance standards, client relationships, fees, and operational practices.
Section 2: Rules of Professional Conduct for Members in Business
Governs members employed in executive, managerial, or operational roles within private or public corporations, governmental bodies, or educational institutions.
Section 3: Rules of Professional Conduct for Other Members
Applies to all remaining AICPA members, including those with other forms of employment, retired members, and unemployed members.
Section 1 Rules: ET 1.200s Independence Standards
Core Independence Requirement
A member in public practice must remain independent in the performance of professional services as required by standards promulgated by bodies designated by the AICPA Council.
Independence is mandatory for specific professional engagement types, particularly attest services.
Framework and Reference Sources
Table 19-3 (p. 643) and Table 19-4 (p. 647) detail specific independence standards and applications.
Covered Members and Applicability
Determination of who qualifies as a "covered member" subject to the strict standard of independence rules.
Impairments to Independence
Financial Relationships: Direct or material indirect financial interests, investments, or financial ties with an attest client.
Loans and Credit Facilities: Specific types of loans to or from attest clients, including debtor/creditor balances that impair objectivity.
Association with Attest Clients: Directorships, officer positions, employment ties, or key decision-making management roles within client organizations.
Litigation: Actual or threatened legal action between the accounting firm and the attest client that creates an adversarial relationship.
Nonaudit Services (NAS): Performance of specific nonaudit services or management functions for attest clients that compromise auditor objectivity or audit independence.
Immediate Family and Close Relative Independence Rules
Immediate Family Members of Covered Members
Definition: Spouses, spousal equivalents, and dependents.
Scope of Restrictions: Subject to almost identical independence restrictions as the covered member.
Restrictions: Prohibited from holding direct financial interests, key employment positions, or business arrangements with attest clients of the firm.
Close Relatives of Engagement Team Members
Definition: Parents, siblings, and nondependent children.
Scope of Restrictions: Subject to specific independence limitations designed to eliminate conflicts of interest.
Restrictions: Prohibited from holding key positions at an audit client or having financial interests that are material to the relative and known to the audit team member.
SEC and PCAOB Independence Regulations
Enhanced Nonaudit Service (NAS) Restrictions
Stricter limitations on nonaudit services offered to public company (issuer) audit clients compared to AICPA standards.
Complete prohibition of services such as bookkeeping, financial information system design, appraisal/valuation services, actuarial services, internal audit outsourcing, and legal or expert services.
Partner Rotation and Compensation Rules
Audit partner rotation mandates requiring lead and concurring partners to rotate off an engagement after a set period.
Compensation restrictions prohibiting partners from receiving compensation based on selling nonaudit services to their audit clients.
Cooling-Off Period Requirements
Mandatory mandatory cooling-off period required when an audit engagement team member leaves the audit firm to take a key financial reporting role (e.g., CEO, CFO, Controller) at an attest client before the firm can begin an audit.
Audit Committee Communication Rules
Required formal communications between independent auditors and the client's audit committee regarding independence matters, pre-approval of nonaudit services, and accounting discussions.
Additional Section 1 Rules for Members in Public Practice
ET 1.100s: Integrity and Objectivity
Members must maintain integrity, remain free of conflicts of interest, and not knowingly misrepresent facts or subordinate judgment to others.
ET 1.300s: General Standards and Accounting Principles
Professional competence, due professional care, planning and supervision, and sufficient relevant data.
Compliance with accounting principles established by designated bodies.
ET 1.400s: Acts Discreditable
Prohibits committing acts that bring discredit to the accounting profession (e.g., failure to file tax returns, retention of client records, discrimination, or negligence in financial statement preparation).
ET 1.510s: Contingent Fees
Prohibits performing professional services for a contingent fee for attest clients, or preparing original or amended tax returns for contingent fees.
ET 1.520s: Commissions and Referral Fees
Prohibits accepting commissions or referral fees for recommending products/services to attest clients.
Requires disclosure to clients when commissions or referral fees are permitted and received for non-attest clients.
ET 1.600s: Advertising and Other Forms of Solicitation
Prohibits seeking clients through advertising or solicitations that are false, misleading, deceptive, coercive, or overreaching.
ET 1.700s: Confidential Client Information
Prohibits disclosing confidential client information without the specific consent of the client, except under defined legal or regulatory exceptions.
ET 1.800s: Form of Organization and Name
Members may practice public accounting only in a form of organization permitted by law or regulation.
Prohibits practicing under a firm name that is misleading.
Quality Management and Oversight Systems
AICPA Statement on Quality Management Standards
Implementation of SQMS 1 (text page 659), establishing a proactive, risk-based system of quality management for audit and attest practices.
Peer Reviews vs. PCAOB Inspections
Public Company Issuer Audits: Firms performing audits of issuers are subject to periodic inspections conducted directly by the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB).
Private Nonissuer Audits: Firms performing audits exclusively for nonissuers are governed by the AICPA Peer Review Program.
Non-Audit Accounting Firms: Accounting firms that perform no audit engagements and focus strictly on other accounting services (such as compilations or reviews) remain subject to appropriate peer review compliance tailored to non-attest/review practice scopes.