Minding the Motivational Mix
Minding the Motivational Mix
Overview
- Focus on the challenges faced by artist-entrepreneurs in business consulting.
- Emphasizes the unique relationship artists have with their work, impacting their views on entrepreneurship and income.
Artist-Entrepreneur Challenges
- Fear of Losing Control: Artist-entrepreneurs often fear losing artistic control during consulting.
- Identity Issues: Many struggle with the label of “entrepreneur,” despite some acceptance.
- Path Dependency: Artists may feel stuck in their ways, limiting their pursuit of diverse rewards.
Insights from Hans Abbing's Work
- Explores the motivations behind artists' choices and low-income levels:
- Myths of Artists: Misleading beliefs that lead to financial struggles.
- Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation:
- Artists are primarily driven by intrinsic rewards (e.g. passion for art, emotional connection) over monetary ones.
- Recognition and social validation often outweigh the desire for financial gain.
- Survival Constraint: Artists may lose interest in earning beyond a certain financial threshold.
Consultant's Role
- Identification of Challenges: Help artists articulate issues and prevent future problems through effective listening.
- Guidance Development: Aid in crafting and executing solutions that respect artists' control over their art.
- Key points to address:
- The time and energy required for product development.
- The importance of authenticity in art.
- The misconception that commercial success equates to inauthenticity.
- Awareness of the unique motivational mix of each artist.
Key Definitions in Arts Business Consulting (from Abbing)
- Habitus:
- A personal value system shaped by life experiences and rewards, guiding motivations and actions.
- Reward Orientation:
- The motivational mix behind artistic and professional choices, influenced by both external and internal factors.
- Motivational Mix:
- A distinct combination of product types, reward types, and sources that reflects individual preferences.
- Path Dependency:
- A tendency among artists to avoid embracing new products or revenue opportunities, limiting their potential.
Addressing Artist Resistance
- Understanding the paradox:
- Artists need income for sustainability yet may resist blending art with financial motivations.
- Explore new revenue streams that align with the artist’s motivational mix without compromising their artistic integrity.
Learning Outcomes for Students
- Consultation Approaches: Evaluate successful and unsuccessful business strategies used with musician-entrepreneurs.
- Motivational Mix Identification: Determine an artist's unique combination of desired rewards and product types.
- Connections to Economic Myths: Explore the impact of societal myths on artistic success and income.
- Revenue Stream Innovations: Use the Motivational Mix Matrix to propose creative revenue strategies based on the artist's motivations.
Lesson Plan Structure
- Prior Readings:
- Abbing, Chapter 4; case study preparation.
- Discussion Approach:
- Breakdown discussions into small group analyses based on the readings and Jason Harrod’s website.
- Application of Motivational Mix Matrix:
- Small groups to propose new revenue streams for the client based on identified motivational attributes and community engagement opportunities.
Employing the Motivational Mix Matrix
- Considerations:
- Explore existing revenue streams and the source of rewards.
- Assess the intrinsic and extrinsic rewards associated with the outlined product types and their appeal to artist objectives.
Examples of Potential Revenue Streams
- Merchandise creation, leveraging existing fan appreciation (e.g., T-shirts, album art).
- Alcohol-free house concerts, creating an inclusive environment (e.g., for those in recovery).
- Workshops or fundraisers in partnership with local faith-based organizations.
- Engaging fans through community-centric events to enhance connection and support.