Manifest Destiny
Before learning about Manifest Destiny, I mostly understood westward expansion as part of how the United States grew into the country it is today. However, after going through the readings and lectures, I started realizing that there was much more behind it than simply expanding territory. Manifest Destiny was the belief that the United States had a God given right to expand across North America. Americans used ideas about religion, racial superiority, and progress to justify taking land from Indigenous people and Mexico. I don’t think this should be celebrated as something entirely positive because a lot of people suffered and lost what belonged to them. I believe progress should involve integrity and respect for others and I don’t think those values were demonstrated through the conquest of these territories.
One of the biggest ideas behind Manifest Destiny was the belief that Americans were chosen by God to expand westward. Many Anglo Protestant Americans believed they were spreading civilization, freedom, and democracy. However, this belief also came with the idea that their religion and culture were superior to those of other people. I think this is important because it shows how religion could be used to justify actions that were actually harmful to others. In the PBS reading The Power of an Idea, historian Miguel Ángel González Quiroga states, “It is dangerous to underestimate the power of an idea.” I think this quotation explains how Manifest Destiny became more than just a belief. It influenced the way people viewed territorial expansion and made taking land seem like something they were entitled to do. Instead of questioning whether their actions were fair, supporters of expansion could convince themselves that they were fulfilling a greater purpose.
Another major part of Manifest Destiny was racial superiority. Many white Americans believed they were more civilized and capable of governing than Mexican and Indigenous communities. These prejudices helped justify treating those populations as obstacles rather than people who already had their own homes, governments, traditions, and rights. What I find upsetting is that people were able to use these beliefs to make discrimination seem acceptable. In the PBS reading Expansionism and Imperialism, historian Thomas Hietala explains that expansionists “primarily sought land, markets, and ports for materialistic, not idealistic, ends.” This stood out to me because it shows that although expansion was presented as a religious or moral mission, economic interests were also extremely important. Americans wanted land, resources, and opportunities for trade, but Manifest Destiny helped make those ambitions appear honorable.
The consequences of these beliefs can be seen in Chicano history, especially after the U.S.-Mexican War of 1846–1848. When the United States gained control of California and other Mexican territories, Mexican communities experienced major changes in their lives. In Chapter 9 of En Aquel Entonces, Antonio Ríos-Bustamante explains that Mexicans were viewed as a “conquered race” (p. 73). I think this is a powerful description because it shows that even though Mexican families had already been living in these territories, they were treated as inferior after the United States took control. Their rights and opportunities became affected by racial prejudice and the growing power of Anglo Americans. This demonstrates that Manifest Destiny did not simply change the borders of the country. It also changed the position of Mexican people within society.
Ríos-Bustamante also describes the years following the war as a period when Mexican Californians experienced economic and political inequality. Many Mexican landowners lost their property, while others faced discrimination that limited their employment opportunities. The reading explains how Mexican communities increasingly became concentrated in barrios as Anglo Americans gained greater control over California. For example, the author describes how Los Angeles changed from a primarily Mexican community into one where Anglo Americans increasingly held economic and political power. I think this is significant because it shows how quickly a community’s position can change when another group takes control. Mexican Californians were not simply losing land. They were also losing opportunities and influence in places where their families had lived for generations.
Another example that stood out to me was the painting American Progress, which we discussed in the lecture materials. The painting presents westward expansion as something beautiful and positive, almost as though Americans were bringing light and civilization to the West. However, I don’t view it that way. When I look at the painting I think about the Indigenous communities who were displaced and the Mexican territory that was taken. I feel that portraying this history as something heroic ignores the suffering that came with it. It raises an important question about whose perspective we are learning from when we study American history. Something that benefited the United States did not necessarily benefit the people who were already living on that land.
I think Manifest Destiny is important to Chicano history because it helps explain how religious beliefs, racism, and economic interests contributed to the conquest of Mexican territories and the discrimination that followed. It also reminds us that history is not always presented from everyone’s perspective. Personally, I believe that taking land from people without respecting their rights should not be celebrated as progress. Understanding Manifest Destiny helps us recognize how powerful certain beliefs can become when they are used to justify treating others unfairly. I think learning about these events is important because we should be able to acknowledge the accomplishments of a country without ignoring the people who suffered along the way.