Religious Crisis and Reformation Notes

Church Crisis and Corruption

  • Vast numbers of people in Europe are unaware of the crises within the church.
  • Corruption exists within the church through:
    • Simony: Sale of church offices.
    • Pluralism: Holding multiple positions and receiving multiple salaries.
    • Absenteeism: Not showing up for the job while still getting paid.
    • Sale of Indulgences: A major issue that leads to Martin Luther's break from the church. The Catholic church was seen as flexible in its interpretation of scripture.

Interpretation of Scripture

  • Literal interpretation of the Bible can be difficult due to its age.
  • Priests often couldn't read Latin, leading to misinterpretations of scripture.
  • Protestantism emphasizes the literal interpretation of the Bible.
  • Northern humanists were seen as more religious than Catholics because they tried to adhere strictly to the Bible.
  • The Protestant Reformation was a conservative movement aimed at bringing the Catholic Church back to its roots.
  • The Bible is the sole authority for Protestants, who rejected the idea of priests, popes, or cardinals interpreting the faith.
  • Protestants emphasized personal communion with God, eliminating the need for a middleman.

Sale of Indulgences

  • Indulgences were sold as a way to get loved ones out of purgatory.

Church Leadership and Control

  • Examples of corruption: leaders having affairs and children out of wedlock while being supposed to be celibate.
  • The church controlled 30% of the land in Europe, making it a mega institution.

Critics of the Church

  • Luther was not the first critic; others included Erasmus, John Wycliffe, and John Huss.
  • John Huss was burned at the stake for his criticisms.
  • Erasmus wrote "In Praise of Folly," criticizing various aspects of European society and the church.
  • Northern humanism involved textual criticism and translations of the Bible into local vernacular languages.

Reformers

  • Ulrich Zwingli: Contemporary of Luther, trained as a humanist, used Erasmus's edition of the Greek New Testament.
  • John Calvin: His teachings were brought back by exiles to Geneva, leading to the spread of Calvinism.
    • John Knox: he brought Calvinism to Scotland

Calvinism's Influence

  • French Calvinists became Huguenots.
  • English Calvinists became Puritans.
  • Dutch Calvinists emerged.
  • Calvinism was more influential than Lutheranism, which remained isolated in Northern Germany, Denmark, Sweden, and Finland.
  • Calvinists were initially seen as religious extremists.

English Civil War and Religious Persecution

  • Puritan beliefs became more accepted in England during the English Civil War (1640s-1650s).
  • Oliver Cromwell, a Puritan, became the military dictator and expelled Presbyterians.
  • English people fled England due to religious persecution, particularly Puritans.

Colonization of America

  • Pilgrims, the most extremist Puritans, set up colonies in North America, such as Massachusetts Bay Colony.
    • Massachusetts Bay Colony was founded in 1618.
  • Anglicans set up plantation-style farms in the Chesapeake Bay Colony (Southern colonies).
  • Religious divisions existed among English settlers in America: Puritans in the North and Anglicans in the South.
  • The North focused on urban centers, while the South focused on plantations.
  • This division contributed to the sectional divide between the North and South, culminating in the Civil War.

Martin Luther and the Reformation

  • Martin Luther broke away from the church in 1517 due to his opposition to indulgences.
  • Johann Tetzel was known for selling indulgences: "As soon as a coin in the coffer rings, the soul from purgatory springs."
  • Luther allegedly nailed his 95 Theses to the door of Wittenberg Cathedral.
  • Charles V, the Holy Roman Emperor, promised Luther a fair trial.
  • Charles V aimed to maintain religious unity in Europe but faced challenges, including the Turks.
  • He eventually retired and divided his holdings into Spain and Austria.

Diet of Worms and Religious Wars

  • Luther was given a trial at the Diet of Worms and received protection.
  • Charles V tried to stamp out Protestantism in alliance with the Pope but was preoccupied with the Turks.
  • German peasants revolted.
  • Early religious wars occurred.
  • The League of Schmalkalden (1531) was formed by Lutheran princes to defend themselves against Charles V.
  • Francis I of France, a Catholic, sided with the League of Schmalkalden to undermine the Habsburgs.
  • The Habsburg-Valois wars involved five conflicts between France and the Habsburgs over Italy.
  • France aimed to keep the Germans divided, which contributed to the long-term political fragmentation of Germany.

Peace of Augsburg

  • The Peace of Augsburg in 1555 temporarily ended the struggle in Germany over Lutheranism, resulting in the permanent religious division of Germany.
  • New types of Protestantism emerged, including Anabaptists, Mennonites, and Calvinists.

John Calvin and Calvinism

  • Calvin was a Frenchman who studied law and embraced humanism.
  • His version of Protestantism centered on predestination: God knows before birth whether one will go to heaven or hell.
  • Calvin established a theocracy in Geneva.
  • Calvinism was the most militant and uncompromising of all the Protestant sects.
  • Calvinists believed in a Protestant work ethic, seeing financial success as a sign of God's favor.

Spread of Calvinism

  • Presbyterians in Scotland.
  • Dutch Reformed Church in the Netherlands.
  • Puritans in England.
  • Huguenots in France.
  • Calvinism did not spread to Ireland, Spain, or Italy due to their strong Catholic presence.

Henry VIII and the English Reformation

  • Henry VII initiated the path to political centralization in England after the War of the Roses.
  • Henry VIII broke away from the church to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn, who later bore him his second daughter Elizabeth.
  • Henry VIII had six wives.
  • He cracked down on monasteries, leading to the Pilgrimage of Grace, a revolt by northern English nobles that was suppressed.

Succession and Religious Shifts

  • Edward VI, Henry VIII's only son, was short-lived.
  • Mary I (Bloody Mary) tried to re-Catholicize England, leading to the death of many who had been loyal to her father.
  • Elizabeth I came to power in 1558-1559 and was the longest-reigning queen of England at the time.

Elizabeth I and the Politique Approach

  • Elizabeth I was a politique, navigating the Protestant Reformation by not being too strongly Catholic or Puritan.
  • Henry IV of France (Henry of Navarre) was another example of a politique, being Catholic when convenient and Calvinist when not.

Thirty Years' War

  • The Defenestration of Prague in 1618 marked the beginning of the Thirty Years' War (1618-1648), the last major religious war in Europe, ending with the Treaty of Westphalia.

French Wars of Religion

  • The story of the Three Henrys and the St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre, where Huguenots were brutally massacred.
  • Henry IV (Henry of Navarre) started the Bourbon dynasty.