Topic 5.10 - Reconstruction (1865-1877)

The Foundation and Challenges of Reconstruction

In the aftermath of the Civil War, the United States faced profound questions regarding the restoration of the Union and the social status of former slaves. Thaddeus Stevens, in a speech on September 66, 18651865, articulated the Radical Republican perspective: "The whole fabric of Southern society must be changed, and never can it be done if this opportunity is lost. Without this, this government can never be, as it never has been, a true republic."

Key Questions of the Era:

  • Rebuilding the South: How would the shattered society and economy of the South be restored after four years of conflict?

  • The Status of Freedpeople: What would be the social and political place of the 4 million4 \text{ million} freed Black Americans?

  • Federal Responsibility: To what extent was the federal government responsible for helping former slaves adjust to their new freedom?

  • Legal Status of the Confederacy: Should the former Confederate states be treated as if they had never left the Union (President Abraham Lincoln's position) or as conquered territories under military occupation?

  • Readmission: Under what conditions would these states be accepted as equal partners in the Union?

  • Authority: Who held the power to decide Reconstruction policy—the President or Congress?

Postwar Conditions in the South

As slavery crumbled, African Americans escaped to Union-controlled territories. The last individuals to learn of their liberation lived in Texas; the date of their announcement, June 1919, became the holiday known as Juneteenth. Most freedpeople began their lives without money, land, or formal education.

Land and Resources:

  • General William Sherman issued an order near the end of the war granting some freedpeople in South Carolina and Georgia "40 acres and a mule40 \text{ acres and a mule}."

  • This order was subsequently cancelled by President Andrew Johnson, and the land was returned to its original owners.

Economic Devastation:

  • The South lost approximately 13\frac{1}{3} of its horses, cattle, and hogs.

  • Infrastructure including roads, bridges, railroad tracks, and fencing was largely destroyed.

  • Chronic food shortages led to poor health and the spread of epidemic diseases, particularly among African Americans.

Conflicting Interests and Beliefs:

  • Northern Republicans sought to maintain the wartime industrial and economic progress.

  • Southern aristocrats desired a low-cost labor force for their plantations.

  • Freedpeople hoped for independence and equal rights.

  • Traditional beliefs in limited government and states' rights prevented bold national action; many Americans believed individuals had the sole responsibility to care for themselves.

Reconstruction Plans of Abraham Lincoln

Lincoln maintained that the Southern states could not constitutionally leave the Union, viewing the Confederates as a disloyal minority. His primary goal was a swift political reconstruction.

Proclamation of Amnesty and Reconstruction (18631863): Lincoln's "10% plan10\% \text{ plan} " included the following provisions:

  • Full presidential pardons for Confederates who took an oath of allegiance to the Union and the U.S. Constitution and accepted the emancipation of slaves.

  • A state government could be reestablished once at least 10%10\% of the voters in that state (as of the 18601860 election) took the loyalty oath.

  • State constitutions had to be rewritten to abolish slavery.

The Wade-Davis Bill (18641864): Congress, fearing the 10% plan10\% \text{ plan} would allow secessionists to dominate the new governments, passed a more stringent bill requiring:

  • 50%50\% of voters to take a loyalty oath.

  • Only non-Confederates were permitted to vote for a new state constitution.

  • Lincoln pocket-vetoed this bill.

The Freedmen's Bureau

In March 18651865, Congress established the Bureau of Refugees, Freedmen, and Abandoned Lands.

Functions and Outcomes:

  • Acts as a welfare agency providing food, shelter, and medical aid to both Black and White Americans destitute after the war.

  • Authority to resettle freedpeople on confiscated lands was revoked when President Johnson pardoned the original Confederate owners.

  • Education Success: Under General Oliver O. Howard, the Bureau established nearly 3,000 schools3,000 \text{ schools} for freedpeople, including several colleges. Before federal funding ceased in 18701870, approximately 200,000200,000 African Americans were taught to read.

Andrew Johnson and Presidential Reconstruction

Andrew Johnson, a Southern Democrat from Tennessee, was the only senator from a Confederate state to remain loyal to the Union. He was added to the 18641864 Republican ticket to appeal to pro-Union Democrats. However, as a White supremacist, he frequently clashed with Congressional Republicans.

Johnson's Reconstruction Policy (May 18651865):

  • Disenfranchisement (loss of the right to vote and hold office) for former Confederate leaders and those with more than 20,00020,000 in taxable property.

  • Presidential Pardons: Johnson used an "escape clause" to grant individual pardons to wealthy planters. Consequently, many former Confederate leaders returned to office by the fall of 18651865.

The Power of the Veto:

  • Previous presidents had vetoed a total of 23 bills23 \text{ bills}. Johnson vetoed 29 bills29 \text{ bills} in a single term.

  • Vetoed a bill to increase the services of the Freedmen's Bureau and the Civil Rights Act of 18661866.

  • During this first phase of Reconstruction, Southern states began passing "Black Codes" to restrict the rights of former slaves.

Congressional Reconstruction and the Radical Republicans

By early 18661866, Congress took control of Reconstruction, moving toward harsher policies for Southern Whites and greater protection for African Americans.

The Radical Republicans:

  • Led by Senator Charles Sumner (Massachusetts) and Representative Thaddeus Stevens (Pennsylvania).

  • Sought to revolutionize Southern society via military rule.

  • Advocated for African American civil rights, federal schools, and land redistribution.

  • Supported various liberal causes: women's suffrage, labor union rights, and Northern African American civil rights.

  • Concerned about the South's increased power in Congress because the old "35 rule\frac{3}{5} \text{ rule} " no longer applied; every person now counted as a whole person for representation purposes.

The Thirteenth Amendment (18651865): Lincoln played a central role in securing the votes for this amendment, which textually states: "Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction."

The Fourteenth Amendment (Ratified 18681868):

  • Declared all persons born or naturalized in the U.S. as citizens.

  • Obligated states to provide "equal protection of the laws" and "due process of law."

  • Disqualified former Confederate leaders from state or federal office.

  • Repudiated Confederate debts.

  • Penalized states that restricted voting rights by reducing their proportional representation in Congress and the Electoral College.

Civil Rights Act of 18661866:

  • Pronounced all African Americans as U.S. citizens (nullifying the Dred Scott decision).

  • Provided a legal shield against Black Codes.

The Impeachment and the Rise of Grant

The Reconstruction Acts of 18671867:

  • Divided the South into 5 military districts5 \text{ military districts} under Union army control.

  • Required states to ratify the 14th Amendment14\text{th Amendment} and grant the franchise to all adult males regardless of race for readmission.

Impeachment:

  • Congress passed the Tenure of Office Act (18671867) to protect Radical Republicans like Secretary of War Edwin Stanton.

  • Johnson dismissed Stanton, leading the House to impeach him for "11 high crimes and misdemeanors11 \text{ high crimes and misdemeanors}."

  • In 18681868, the Senate trial fell 1 vote1 \text{ vote} short of the 23\frac{2}{3} majority needed for removal.

The Election of 18681868 and the Fifteenth Amendment:

  • Ulysses S. Grant (Republican) won the presidency. His popular vote margin was only 300,000300,000, with 500,000 Black men500,000 \text{ Black men} providing the winning votes.

  • 15th Amendment15\text{th Amendment} (Ratified 18701870): Prohibited states from denying a citizen's right to vote based on "race, color, or previous condition of servitude."

Reconstruction in the South

Republican-controlled governments dominated the South from 18671867 until conservative Democrats (Redeemers) regained control, varying from one year in Tennessee to nine years in Florida.

Political Composition:

  • Scalawags: Southern Whites (often former Whigs) who supported Republican governments and economic development.

  • Carpetbaggers: Northerners who moved south to invest, provide humanitarian aid, or plunder.

  • African American Legislators: Most were educated property holders with moderate views. Notable figures included Blanche K. Bruce and Hiram Revels, the latter taking the Senate seat once held by Jefferson Davis.

African American Autonomy and Social Impact

Freedom allowed African Americans to achieve independence from White control through several means:

  • Churches: Formation of independent Negro Baptist and African Methodist Episcopal (AME) churches.

  • Education: Founding of colleges like Howard, Atlanta, Fisk, and Morehouse.

  • Migration: Many migrated to cities or frontier states like Kansas.

School Enrollment Percentage (18501850–18801880):

Year

White Students (\%)

African American Students (\%)

18501850

5656

22

18601860

6060

22

18701870

5454

1010

18801880

6262

3434

Corruption and Economic Crises in the North

During the Grant administration, the focus shifted from civil rights to material interests.

The Spoilsmen: Leadership moved to political manipulators like Roscoe Conkling and James Blaine, masters of patronage. Key Scandals:

  • Jay Gould and James Fisk (18691869): A scheme to corner the gold market with the help of Grant’s brother-in-law.

  • Cr dit Mobilier: Insiders gave stock to Congress members to hide profits (up to 348%348\%) from transcontinental railroad subsidies.

  • Whiskey Ring: Federal agents and the liquor industry conspired to defraud the government of tax revenue.

  • Boss Tweed: William Tweed in New York City stole approximately 200 million200 \text{ million} from taxpayers until exposed by The New York Times and cartoonist Thomas Nast.

Panic of 18731873:

  • Caused by overspeculation and overbuilding.

  • The resulting depression diverted Northern attention away from Reconstruction.

Women's Suffrage Movement

Women took on expanded roles during the war as nurses, factory workers, and farm managers. The exclusion of women from the 14th14\text{th} and 15th15\text{th} Amendments—the first time "sex" was mentioned in the Constitution to limit rights—frustrated suffragists.

  • In 18691869, Wyoming Territory became the first to grant women full suffrage.

  • The goal of national suffrage would remain unfulfilled until the 19th Amendment19\text{th Amendment} after World War I.