strain thoery
A Few Things to Note
- No Class Next Week: Study Days. Next class on Tuesday, Feb 25.
- Group Work: Regular meetings with your group are essential. Any schedule changes must be unanimously agreed by the group. This impacts grades and workload.
- Research Logs: These will be collected soon for feedback. Pay attention to the "Empirical Research" section in the text chapters.
- Technical Issues: Log in with your VIU email address to avoid issues with Teams.
Strain Theories - CRIM 360: Advanced Criminological Theory
Objectives & Outline
- Discuss the theoretical origins and early “strain” theorists.
- Outline the basic tenets of Merton’s Strain Theory.
- Outline the basic tenets of Agnew’s General Strain Theory.
- Discuss the implications of strain theories.
Early Theorists
- Concern over increasing crime rates led to questioning the relationship between social structure and crime.
- August Comte: First to apply the scientific method for understanding social factors, emphasizing social determinism and rejecting free will.
- Adolphe Quetelet: Analyzed crime statistics and noted that specific demographics (young, poor, uneducated, unemployed men) were more likely to commit crimes.
- Relative Deprivation: Inequality between members of society is more crucial than absolute wealth.
- Areas with greater inequality exhibit higher crime rates.
- Noted that rapid economic changes correlated with increased crime.
- Crime is a product of social organization and can guide social reforms to address inequalities.
Durkheim & Anomie
- Developed a theory based on economic development and labor distribution transitioning from mechanical to organic societies.
- Mechanical Societies: Characterized by uniformity and shared functions; laws enforce conformity and reinforce collective conscience.
- Organic Societies: Exhibit specialized roles, leading to weakened collective conscience (anomie) and increased risk of antisocial behavior.
- Key Transitions:
- From simple to complex division of labor.
- From laws that enforce conformity to those regulating interactions.
Classic Strain Theories
- Early theorists influenced the development of strain theories emphasizing frustration as a key factor in criminal behavior, differing in causes and reactions to strain.
- Robert K. Merton: Noted the impact of the economy during the Great Depression on social factors, particularly crime.
- The American Dream: Emphasizes hard work leading to financial success, but highlights unrealistic expectations for achieving goals.
- Strain is seen as the negative emotions from failing to achieve goals through accepted means.
- Modes of adaptation include conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism, and rebellion.
Merton’s Strain Theory
- Modes of Adaptation:
- Conformity: Accepts goals and means (e.g., average citizens).
- Innovation: Accepts societal goals but rejects means (e.g., criminals seeking success through illegal means like theft).
- Ritualism: Rejects the goal of wealth but accepts means (e.g., individuals who continue to work without ambition).
- Retreatism: Rejects both goals and means (e.g., social dropouts, substance abusers).
- Rebellion: Substitutes new goals and means, often through disruptive actions (e.g., revolutionaries).
Agnew’s General Strain Theory
- Extends strain theories to all social classes and considers frustrations from a broader scope including both negative stimuli and loss of positive stimuli.
- Three Sources of Strain:
- Failure to achieve positively valued goals (e.g., income, status).
- Presence of noxious stimuli (e.g., abuse).
- Removal of positive stimuli (e.g., job loss).
- Negative emotional responses (anger/frustration) can lead to crime when healthy coping mechanisms are unavailable.
Implications of Strain Theories
- Strategies for reducing strain in society include:
- Improving educational and vocational opportunities: Making resources accessible reduces youth reoffending rates.
- Intervention programs: Pre-school initiatives and stress management programs to provide coping mechanisms.
- Addressing broad social issues: Tackling global deprivation, inequality, and poverty can mitigate crime.
Questions?
- Open to discussion and clarification on the covered topics.