Transformation of Active Structures with Reporting Verbs into Passive Voice

Passive Voice Transformation of Reporting Verbs

  • The passive voice can be applied to complex active structures involving reporting verbs to shift the perspective or formalize the statement.
  • This grammatical transformation typically involves sentences that follow a specific pattern:   - Active Structure: Subject (People\text{People}, We\text{We}, They\text{They}, Somebody\text{Somebody}, etc.) + Reporting Verb (think\text{think}, believe\text{believe}, hope\text{hope}, say\text{say}, etc.) + Second Clause (introduced by "that").
  • There are two primary methods to convert these active structures into the passive voice.

Method 1: The "It" Construction (Impersonal Passive)

  • This method uses the dummy subject "It" to represent the general opinion or report.
  • The passive transformation for this method follows a specific sequence:   - Formula: It+be-verb+V3+that+Second Clause\text{It} + \text{be-verb} + V_3 + \text{that} + \text{Second Clause}
  • In this construction, the "be-verb" must agree with the tense of the reporting verb in the original active sentence.
  • The "V3V_3" refers to the past participle of the reporting verb (e.g., "said", "thought", "believed").
  • The second clause (the "that" clause) remains entirely unchanged from its original active form.
  • Example:   - Active: "People say that he is a doctor."   - Passive (Method 1): "It is said that he is a doctor."
  • Example:   - Active: "People think that the old man lives in a hut."   - Passive (Method 1): "It is thought that the old man lives in a hut."

Method 2: The Personal Subject Construction (Direct Passive)

  • This method moves the subject of the subordinate (second) clause to the beginning of the sentence to become the grammatical subject of the passive sentence.
  • There are two distinct tense-based sub-rules for this method:
Scenario A: Identical Tenses
  • This rule is applied if both the main clause (the reporting verb) and the second clause are in the same tense (e.g., both are Present or both are Past).
  • Formula: Subject of 2nd Clause+be-verb+V3+to+V1\text{Subject of 2nd Clause} + \text{be-verb} + V_3 + \text{to} + V_1
  • Example:   - Active: "People say that he is a doctor."   - Passive (Method 2): "He is said to be a doctor."     - Here, "He" (subject of 2nd clause) is moved to the front.     - "Is" (be-verb) matches the present tense of "say".     - "Said" (V3V_3) is the past participle of "say".     - "To be" (to+V1\text{to} + V_1) replaces the verb from the second clause.
Scenario B: Mixed Tenses (Present to Past)
  • This rule is applied if the first clause (the reporting verb) is in the Present tense and the second clause is in the Past tense.
  • Formula: Subject of 2nd Clause+be-verb+V3+to+have+V3\text{Subject of 2nd Clause} + \text{be-verb} + V_3 + \text{to} + \text{have} + V_3
  • This structure indicates that the action in the dependent clause happened prior to the reporting of the action.
  • Example based on recorded notes:   - Active: "People think that the old man lived in a hut."   - Passive (Hybrid/Method 2): "It is thought that that old man have lived in a hut."   - Note: In the personal construction specifically, this would traditionally become: "The old man is thought to have lived in a hut."

Comparative Examples and Tense Analysis

  • Case Studie 1: Direct reporting of a current state   - Active: "People say that He is a doctor."   - Passive 1: "It is said that He is a doctor."   - Passive 2: "He is said to be a doctor."

  • Case Studie 2: Reporting a current belief about a current state   - Active: "People think that the old man lives in a hut."   - Passive 1: "It is thought that the old man lives in a hut."

  • Case Studie 3: Reporting a past belief about a past state   - Active: "People thought that that old man lived in a hut."   - Analysis: Since both clauses are in the past, Method 2 Scenario A applies (to+V1\text{to} + V_1).

  • Case Studie 4: Reporting a current belief about a past state   - Active: "People think that the old man lived in a hut."   - Passive Transformation: "It is thought that that old man have lived in a hut."   - Explanation: Uses the "to have + V3V_3" logic to show the shift from present thinking to a past living situation.