The Temperance Movement

The Temperance Movement and Prohibition

  • Definition and Core Mission:

    • The temperance movement was an organized social and political campaign designed to outlaw and ban the sale of alcoholic beverages across the United States.

    • Advocates asserted that alcohol consumption was a primary driver of social collapse, believing it tore apart homes and destroyed families.

  • The Women's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU):

    • Formed as a central organizational force in the temperance crusade.

    • Pursued a two-fold institutional strategy:

    • Educated the public about the physical, moral, and domestic evils attributed to alcohol consumption.

    • Lobbied legislators and fought actively to pass binding laws prohibiting the commercial sale of alcoholic beverages.

    • Popularized social pledges and rallying slogans, prominently displaying banners proclaiming: "Lips That Touch Liquor Shall Not Touch Ours."

  • Carrie Nation's Radical Activism:

    • Rose to prominence as a leading, militant crusader within the temperance movement.

    • Her activism was fueled by personal tragedy; her husband died from complications associated with heavy drinking.

    • Known for direct-action tactics: stormed into saloons brandishing a hatchet, violently smashing beer kegs and liquor bottles.


Carrie Nation holding a hatchet and a book
  • The 18th Amendment (1919):

    • Officially amended the United States Constitution to make the sale, manufacture, and transportation of alcoholic beverages illegal nationwide.

    • Ratification Milestones (reported in The American Issue, Westerville, Ohio, January 25, 1919):

    • Ratified on January 16, 1919, when Nebraska became the 36th state to approve the dry amendment, thereby meeting the necessary three-fourths constitutional threshold (36 out of 48 states).

    • Nebraska's House ratified the amendment by a vote of 98 to 0 at 10:15 a.m., edging out Missouri for the deciding 36th spot, with Wyoming, Wisconsin, and Minnesota ratifying shortly after.

    • Full ratification was accomplished in less than 13 months, well inside the seven-year window established by the congressional resolution.

    • Demonstrating rapid momentum, 23 state legislatures approved the measure within the first 16 days of January 1919, following 15 states in 1918 (9 of which occurred in special called sessions).

    • The cumulative legislative tally on the date of approval stood at 3,976 votes in favor of the measure versus 822 votes against.

    • The first 36 ratifying states represented an aggregate population of 62,033,638 citizens.


The American Issue announcing the ratification of the 18th Amendment

Origins and Organization of the Women's Suffrage Movement

  • Foundational Origins:

    • The organized women's rights movement formally began in 1848 at the Seneca Falls Convention held in Seneca Falls, New York.


Historical marker for the 1848 Seneca Falls Convention
  • Post-Civil War Leadership:

    • Following the American Civil War, Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony spearheaded a renewed national campaign focused on securing the vote for women alongside other civil reforms.

  • Formation of the National Women Suffrage Association (NWSA):

    • Founded in 1869 by Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony.

    • Defined Goal: Pass an amendment to the United States Constitution guaranteeing women the right to vote.


Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony
  • Suffragist Definition and Demographics:

    • A suffragist was defined as any individual who fought for women's right to vote.

    • The suffragist coalition was composed of both women and men working toward enfranchisement.

  • Anti-Suffrage Backlash and Arguments:

    • Opposition organized into groups such as the National Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage.

    • Anti-suffragists distributed propaganda and official referendum warning materials asserting that woman suffrage would "double the irresponsible vote."

    • Opponents characterized voting rights for women as a dangerous "menace to the home, men's employment, and to all business."


Anti-suffrage propaganda flyer highlighting perceived threats to home and business

Western Leadership in Women's Enfranchisement

  • Early Adoption in the American West:

    • Western states and territories granted women the right to vote decades before national adoption, led early on by Wyoming, Utah, Colorado, and Idaho.

    • Core catalysts for early western enfranchisement:

    • Frontier reality: Women worked alongside men to build western infrastructure, communities, and economies.

    • Western state governments and legislatures explicitly recognized women's vital contributions by codifying their right to vote.

  • Western Activism and Eastern Demands:

    • Western voting women leveraged their status to pressure the federal government and eastern states, marching under banners stating: "We Were Voters Out West! Why Deny Our Rights in the East?"


Suffragists holding banner advocating eastern suffrage based on western voting rights
  • State-by-State Suffrage Progression Prior to Federal Amendment:

    • States with Full Suffrage for Women (and enactment dates):

    • Wyoming (1890)

    • Colorado (1893)

    • Utah (1896)

    • Idaho (1896)

    • Washington (1910)

    • California (1911)

    • Oregon (1912)

    • Kansas (1912)

    • Arizona (1912)

    • Nevada (1914)

    • Montana (1914)

    • New York (1917)

    • Michigan (1918)

    • South Dakota (1918)

    • Oklahoma (1918)

    • States with Partial Suffrage for Women:

    • North Dakota, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Iowa, Illinois, Nebraska, Missouri, Indiana, Ohio, Kentucky, Tennessee, Arkansas, Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Florida, Maine, and Vermont.

    • States with No Statewide Suffrage for Women:

    • New Mexico, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina, South Carolina, Georgia, and Alabama.


Map of United States showing women's suffrage status and year of enactment by state

Twentieth-Century Suffrage Leaders and the 19th Amendment

  • Carrie Chapman Catt:

    • Professional background as a school principal who transitioned into a national suffrage strategist and leader.

    • Served as a key organizer and leader of the National Women Suffrage Association (NWSA), coordinating state-by-state political pressure alongside federal lobbying.


Carrie Chapman Catt and the National Association Opposed to Woman Suffrage headquarters
  • Alice Paul:

    • Radical suffrage strategist who utilized militant civil disobedience and direct action.

    • Organized mass protest marches and continuous pickets directly outside the White House, displaying provocative banners addressed to the administration, such as: "Mr. President How Long Must Women Wait for Liberty?"

    • Incarcerated for public demonstrations, where she staged high-profile hunger strikes in jail to draw national attention to the suffrage cause.


Suffragists picketing outside the White House
  • The 19th Amendment (1920):

    • Ratified in 1920, establishing constitutional protection ensuring that the right of citizens to vote could not be denied or abridged on account of sex.

    • Granted women full, nationwide voting rights across all federal, state, and local elections.

African American Struggles in the Post-Reconstruction Era

  • Systemic Discrimination and Jim Crow Laws:

    • Following the end of Reconstruction, African Americans faced pervasive institutional racism and legalized segregation codified through Jim Crow laws across the South.

  • Political Disenfranchisement and Economic Inequality:

    • Black citizens were largely stripped of political power and denied civic participation.

    • Confined largely to low-paying jobs through systemic employment discrimination and overt racial barriers (exemplified by public signage reading "Help Wanted White Only").


Jim Crow employment sign stating Help Wanted White Only
  • Racial Violence:

    • The Post-Reconstruction era in the American South was marked by extreme terror and violence, characterized by exceptionally high rates of lynchings targeting African Americans.

African American Leadership and Civil Rights Organizations

  • Booker T. Washington:

    • Renowned educator and national leader who advocated for racial harmony and mutual coexistence between Black and white Americans.

    • Emphasized vocational education, agricultural training, and economic self-sufficiency as pragmatic pathways to progress.

    • Helped found and lead the Tuskegee Institute, a historically Black college in Alabama.


Booker T. Washington seated with a book
  • W.E.B. Du Bois:

    • Prominent scholar, sociologist, and civil rights activist who rejected accommodationist models.

    • Urged African Americans to actively and aggressively fight for immediate civil, political, and social equality.

    • Demanded a much faster end to discrimination and disenfranchisement than more gradualist leaders proposed.

    • Played a foundational role in organizing and establishing the NAACP.


Portrait of W.E.B. Du Bois
  • National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP):

    • Founded in 1909.

    • Core Mission: Combat systemic racism by waging strategic legal battles in the courts to strike down discriminatory laws and secure constitutional equal rights for people of color.


Official seal of the NAACP founded in 1909
  • George Washington Carver:

    • Renowned agricultural scientist and researcher at the Tuskegee Institute.

    • Revolutionized Southern agriculture by researching and discovering diverse commercial and nutritional uses for alternative Southern crops to liberate farmers from dependence on cotton.

    • Specific scientific developments:

    • Discovered and formulated over 300 products derived from the peanut.

    • Developed 150 new commercial and domestic uses for the sweet potato.


Portrait of George Washington Carver