Freeman (2002)

Cognitive Mapping in Literary Analysis

Introduction to Literary Analysis

  • Literary analysis encompasses various forms depending on the critical approach employed.

  • There are three components of literature:

    • The Writer: Focused on the biographical and psychoanalytical approaches.

    • The Reader: Emphasized in Reader Response theories.

    • The Text: Highlighted in formalist and structuralist approaches.

  • Critical theories range from those concentrating almost solely on the text to others focusing on the writer or reader, with many falling in between (historical, cultural, etc.).

Cognitive Linguistic Approach

  • Cognitive linguistics offers a method to reconcile insights from different literary theories.

  • It is concerned with how the embodied mind processes experiences, making it relevant from all three perspectives (writer, reader, text).

  • This approach reveals that the imaginative capabilities involved in creating and comprehending literary works mirror fundamental mental processes.

  • A key question:

    • Claiborne Rice posits whether textual production and reception depend on similar cognitive integration networks.

  • Research by Joseph Grady suggests common cognitive structures exist among speakers and listeners, supporting the idea of shared cognitive networks as proposed by Fauconnier and Turner.

  • Norman Holland connects reader and writer cognitive processes in his analysis of Robert Frost's poetry.

Focused Analysis on Emily Dickinson

  • This paper specifically examines the cognitive strategies used in the poetry of Emily Dickinson, demonstrating that these are consistent and significant in shaping conceptual reasoning.

  • Core assertion: Poets' thinking aligns with the cognitive processes of readers.

The Nature of Analogical Mapping

  • Understanding a speaker's sentence transcends mere word comprehension; context within knowledge domains or idealized cognitive models (ICMs) is crucial.

  • Cultural Determinism of Knowledge Domains:

    • Dickinson's references to “God” and “Heaven” are rooted in a Protestant, nineteenth-century Puritan New England context.

    • ICMs inform how thoughts and language are articulated through dynamic and contextual mental spaces.

  • As noted by Fauconnier, mappings across mental spaces are essential for semantic understanding and interpretation.

Types of Cognitive Skills in Analogical Mapping

  • Attribute Mapping:

    • Recognizing similarities between objects.

    • Example: Identifying elements describing the same concept or individual across different contexts.

  • Relational Mapping:

    • Tracking relationships rather than objects solely, noting different similarities and differences.

    • Example: Dickinson’s comparisons in a poem, like sifting snow as akin to powdered flour.

  • Systems Mapping:

    • More abstract, recognizing patterns and generalizations across structures which are utilized in critical analyses.

Examples of Cognitive Mapping in Poetry

  • Attribute Mapping Example: Dickinson’s use of metaphors, such as “the clouds-like listless Elephants,” illustrates base cognitive skills.

  • Relational Mapping Example: Comparisons of different entities, like describing a dog as “the noblest work of Art.”

  • Systems Mapping Example: Analyzing multiple elements and how they interrelate in broader structures to derive meaning in literary interpretation.

Conceptual Projection and Integration

  • This section ties cognitive projections from concrete ideas into abstract cognition.

  • It highlights the grammatically constructed markers that label shifts within mental spaces conducive to creating complex concepts.

  • Example Analysis: Dickinson’s poem about the flower and mistletoe illustrates multiple mental spaces and identity exchanges in metaphorical expressions.

Conceptual Metaphor Theory (CMT)

  • CMT posits that metaphor is a cognitive operation fundamental to human thought rather than merely a linguistic figure.

  • Metaphors facilitate understanding abstract thoughts through concrete experiences.

  • Common metaphors emerge in Dickinson’s work across various themes (e.g., life as a journey, physical states as containers).

  • Container Metaphor: Seen in Dickinson’s use of body imagery as a foundational element of her association with life and existence.

Blending Theory and Its Application

  • Blending builds on previous theories, establishing multiple dynamic spaces that create new meanings through compressive relations.

  • Dickinson’s letter where she entwines her identity with Judith and the nuances of metaphor showcases the complex layering and blending process.

Cognitive Strategies in Literary Interpretations

  • A discussion of interpretations from Dickinson’s poetry illustrates variances in readers' cognitive mapping diversity.

  • Each reader relies on their own knowledge, cultural context, and cognitive strategies for interpretations, leading to varying yet plausible readings of the text.

    • Example Analysis: Comments analyzing a poem’s themes of Heaven, happiness, and sin demonstrate diverse interpretations based on individual readers’ mappings.

Conclusion

  • The cognitive approach to literary analysis strengthens the bond between literature and human cognitive processes, enhancing creativity and interpretations.

  • It facilitates a broadened understanding of how multiple readings can exist, correlating closely with a poet's overarching world view and the further implications of literary cognitive mapping strategies.