Perspectives on Mental Health and Illness

Administrative Items

  • Second written assignment due this week during tutorials.

  • Next two weeks of tutorials canceled:

    • Week 7 (October 13 and 17) is canceled due to Thanksgiving long weekend.

    • Week 8 (October 20 and 24) is canceled for study break.

  • Next Thursday, October 16, a “review” lecture will be held online.

  • Midterm exam scheduled for in-class on Tuesday, October 21.

  • No lecture on Thursday, October 23.

Midterm Exam Details

  • The midterm exam will occur in 1.5 weeks on Tuesday, October 21, during class.

  • Content will cover Weeks 1 to 7, including Chapters 1 to 10.

  • Students will have 1 hour and 40 minutes to complete the exam.

  • Exam structure:

    • 40 multiple choice or true/false questions (40 points total).

    • 3 short answer questions (6 points total).

  • Students using CAL must book with them at least 7 days before the midterm, and 14 days prior to the final exam.

Chapter Reflections

  • Topic focuses on examining key developments that led to the emergence of ADHD as a recognized disorder.

  • Social Trajectory Defined: Refers to how a disorder emerges, becomes recognized, and is considered treatable.

Key Historical Developments for ADHD

  • World War II: Increased importance of psychiatry to maintain soldiers' mental health, leading to greater prestige in the field and the establishment of the National Institute of Mental Health.

  • Rise of Biological and Social Psychology: Introduction of new drugs that focus on biology and brain-related aspects of mental health; 1961 marked the launch of Ritalin, initially developed for chronic fatigue and later used for ADHD.

  • Education Reform: Post-Sputnik fears of falling behind in science and technology resulted in a push for traditional educational methods, impacting perceptions of children's learning capabilities.

  • GI Bill: Supported veterans' education, fostering belief in the necessity of postsecondary education for success.

  • National Defense Education Act: Funded to improve education to compete globally, shifting learning environments to more structured classrooms and supporting guidance counselors in detecting struggling students.

Explanations for ADHD

  • ADHD is often described as a “general neurological deficit,” with attempts to pinpoint a causative gene being inconclusive.

  • The term “deficit” could be replaced with “difference.”

  • Initial views in the 1950s held hyperactivity, impulsivity, and inattention as normal developmental traits.

  • The late 20th century saw food allergies, particularly linked to the Feingold diet from the 1970s, being considered potential causes of ADHD.

  • Faulty parenting, especially the “mother blame” phenomenon, has been scrutinized, pushing for neurological and genetic explanations instead.

  • Genetics also play a role; parents with ADHD may face struggles in their parenting roles.

  • Sleep disruptions and changes in discipline methods (e.g., banning corporal punishment) are linked to rising stimulant prescriptions.

  • A critique notes ADHD could be a social construct due to aggressive pharmaceutical marketing; the disparities in diagnosis among different gender and racial groups raises concerns about surveillance and control.

  • Stimulant medications, initially aimed at adults, found a market among children during the 1960s.

Explanations for Autism

  • Causes of autism ignite significant debates; while it's acknowledged as a brain disorder, genetic or environmental causation remains uncertain.

  • Various theories (psychoanalytic, behavioral, genetic, dietary) have been proposed across decades.

  • Historical views from the 1940s placed blame on “cold” parenting, which has since been discredited for lacking credible research.

  • Claims about food allergies lack sufficient evidence yet remain popular.

  • The controversial association of MMR vaccines with autism emerged from debunked research, influencing vaccine hesitancy today.

  • The absence of a clear cause for autism, with some links to genetic conditions like Down syndrome, pose challenges for genetic testing.

Treatment Debates for ADHD

  • Stimulant drugs, notably Ritalin, are primary treatments for ADHD, with origins in 1950s treatments for adults, raising ethical concerns about dependency and misuse.

  • Side effects associated with ADHD medications include:

    • Insomnia

    • Growth stunting

    • Anorexia

    • Other psychological issues like irritability or hallucinations.

  • Ethical considerations loom over prescribing powerful stimulants, especially given the frequency of treatment interruptions recommended for children.

  • The pharmaceutical industry's role in funding research presents potential conflicts of interest regarding the negative effects of medications.

  • Evidence on stimulant effects on brain development is lacking despite their widespread use in children.

  • Alternative treatment strategies advocated include dietary changes, educational interventions, and various therapeutic approaches, emphasizing that drug use should be a last resort.

Neurodiversity Movement

  • The movement positions autism and similar conditions as normal variations in human behavior rather than pathologies.

  • Proponents argue for adapting society to accommodate neurodivergent individuals rather than seeking cures.

  • Critiques of the movement highlight its assumption of autism as solely a neurological issue and the risk of oversimplifying diverse experiences among the autistic population.

  • Challenges arise from the movement's focus on individuals considered high-functioning, potentially neglecting those with more severe challenges.

  • Neurodiversity draws attention to societal conditions related to mental health rather than solely focusing on individual pathology.

Chapter Reflections Questions

  • Define “pathologization”: The process of behaviors previously seen as normal being classified as symptoms of dysfunction; preferred view considers these behaviors as differences.

  • ADHD symptoms often overlap with typical child behaviors, which may obscure diagnoses.

  • A definition of normalcy in the context of autism needs to consider a spectrum rather than a binary approach.

Importance of ADHD and Autism Focus
  1. Commonality: ADHD and autism are among the most prevalent developmental disorders.

  2. Complexity: Both exhibit a range of symptoms, complicating diagnosis and treatment.

  3. Timing: Their rising awareness happened concurrently, influenced by educational restructuring and changing societal attitudes.

Additional Reflections on Treatment and Media Representation

  • Controversies over ADHD medication effectiveness and side effects dominate discussions.

  • Mainstream media portrayals often perpetuate stereotypes, but some representations challenge stigma and provide a more accurate view of ADHD and autism experiences.

  • Individuals' unique perspectives, as discussed in videos from those with ADHD or autism, continue to call for acceptance of neurodiversity and advocacy for better support systems in society.