52. Bryan D. Palmer, 'New Left Liberations' - Canada's 1960s

Title: Canada's 1960s: The Ironies of Identity in a Rebellious Era

Chapter Eight: New Left Liberations

  • Exploration of the New Left in Canada during the 1960s.

  • The era has often been dismissed as the 'most forgettable generation.'

  • Notably, Peter Desbarats' view reflects a broader skepticism about youth radicalism during this time.

  • Key events were characterized by disillusionment and a decline in radical fervor by late 1969.

Criticism of Youth Culture

  • Desbarats, a journalist, criticized the apathy of the youth at McGill University, depicting them as exhausted and uninspired.

  • He saw their cultural symbols (long hair, loose behavior) as mere parodies of deeper revolutionary ideals.

  • He anticipated that the 'silent shapes' of the 1960s era would fade into obscurity.

Cultural Shifts and Disillusionment

  • By late 1969, many former centers of youthful resistance, like Yorkville, appeared diminished.

  • Notable works, like Kerouac's On the Road and Ginsberg's Howl, capture this cultural despair and revolutionary spirit of the prior decade.

  • There was a growing sense that radicalism and revolutionary fervor were being replaced by a return to older leftist perspectives, based in the working class.

New Left's Internal Conflict

  • The New Left faced a decline in radical youth engagement, as many youth began to 'burn out.'

  • Movement figures, such as Irwin Silber, emphasized a return to traditional class-based revolutionary ideals.

  • Media narratives depicted youth culture as a mere semblance of rebellion, lacking substantial political will.

Reaction to Decline

  • Myrna Kostash, a notable figure from the New Left, offers a nuanced reflection on her experiences.

  • She rejected narratives of failure and instead embraced the successes and impactful moments of activism from the decade.

  • Kostash acknowledged the harsh realities faced by activists, including police harassment and internal disillusionment, but valued the transformative potential of their activism.

Radical Youth and Their Legacy

  • The New Left in Canada was influenced strongly by American ideologies, but sought to carve out its unique identity.

  • Integrating various intellectual traditions, including British socialism and existentialism, new radicals aimed to create a distinctly Canadian New Left.

  • Key influences noted included peace marches, student organizations, and anti-colonial thought.

Major Publications and Influences

  • The Guardian and Ramparts were pivotal in shaping radical thought, offering news and perspectives that informed Canadian leftists.

  • Marxist theory, particularly the younger Marx’s concepts, gained traction among activists even as it was often critiqued.

Praxis and Philosophy of Change

  • Herbert Marcuse's vision of revolutionary change emphasized a blend of theoretical understanding and active engagement in social problems.

  • The New Left aimed to engage meaningfully with existing structures while advocating for expansive social change.

  • Mario Savio and others highlighted the importance of voice and dissent in the face of bureaucratic constraints on freedom.

Student Activism and Community Engagement

  • Organizations like the Student Union for Peace Action (SUPA) emerged, focusing on participatory democracy and student syndicalism.

  • Their initiatives reflected struggles at the grassroots level, emphasizing decolonization and anti-imperialist efforts.

Demise and Fragmentation of the New Left

  • The decline of SUPA and New Left organizations was marked by ongoing debates regarding identity, direction, and the validity of radical ideas.

  • Influences of anti-Vietnam war sentiment and coalition-building characterized the activism of the time, but many in the New Left struggled to find a coherent identity amidst changes.

  • In the later years, struggles for women’s rights and engagement with indigenous issues began to redefine political landscapes.

Conclusion: The Legacy of the 1960s in Canada

  • The radical spirit of the 1960s transformed attitudes towards identity and activism in Canada.

  • Reflecting on the legacies of the New Left reveals both successes and failures, while suggesting areas for future activism.

  • Canada’s youth during the 1960s helped to redefine notions of Canadian identity, marking a significant societal shift.

  • The 1960s ultimately betokened a moment of profound change, setting the stage for subsequent movements, including women's liberation and indigenous rights.