Homicide Victimization Notes

Defining Homicide

  • Homicide: General term referring to “the killing of one human being by another.”
  • Three types of homicide:
    • Excusable
    • Justifiable
    • Criminal homicide/murder

Excusable Homicide

  • Defined as accidental or unintentional killings.
  • No guilt is involved.

Justifiable Homicide

  • Occurs in defense of life or property.
  • FBI defines it as restricted to:
    • “The killing of a felon by a peace officer in the line of duty.”
    • “The killing (during the commission of a felony) of a felon by a private citizen.”
  • Examples include:
    • Stand your ground laws
    • Castle doctrine

Criminal Homicide

  • Defined as “the purposeful, knowing, reckless, or negligent killing of one human being by another.”
  • Four subtypes:
    • First-degree murder
    • Second-degree murder
    • Felony murder
    • Manslaughter

First-Degree Murder

  • Murder committed with deliberate premeditation and malice.
  • Three elements:
    • Premeditation: The act was considered beforehand.
    • Deliberation: The act was planned after careful thought (not on impulse).
    • Express malice: Actual malice.
    • Implied/constructive malice: When death occurs due to negligence rather than intent.
  • Example of implied malice:
    • Leaving a child alone due to unavailable childcare, and the child dies from an accident.

Second-Degree Murder

  • Murder committed with malice but without premeditation and deliberation.
  • The offender intended to cause harm, but the murder was not planned.
  • Example:
    • A husband comes home early and finds his wife having an affair.
    • The husband grabs a handgun from the closet and shoots and kills both.

Felony Murder

  • Often an unintentional killing during the commission of another felony.
  • Usually considered first-degree murder.
  • Example:
    • Hitting someone in the head during a robbery, and the person dies.

Manslaughter

  • An unlawful killing, but the degree of responsibility is less than for murder.
    • Voluntary manslaughter: Intentional infliction of injury that is likely to and actually does cause death.
      • Example: Using excessive force in self-defense.
    • Involuntary/negligent manslaughter: Death resulting from gross negligence.
      • Ignoring the possible danger or potential harm to other people.

Measurement and Extent of Homicide Victimization

  • In the United States, homicide victimization data are not collected through victimization surveys.
  • Three sources to collect homicide data:
    • Uniform Crime Reports (UCR)
    • Supplemental Homicide Reports (SHR)
    • National Center for Health Statistics

Uniform Crime Reports (UCR)

  • Includes both aggregate murder rates and clearance rates for murder.
  • In 2012, the rate of homicides was 4.74.7 per 100,000 people.
  • Murders constitute about 1% of all violent index crimes reported to the police.

Supplemental Homicide Reports (SHR)

  • Provide case-specific information for each murder reported in the UCR.
  • Includes demographic information of victims and offenders (if caught), weapon used, and situational information.
  • One of the few sources of official data that provide detailed information on crime victims.
    • Males, young, and intra-racial (same-race/ethnicity).

National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS)

  • Another source of nationwide mortality data collected since the early 1930s.
  • Data are collected from death certificates that are forwarded to the Vital Statistics Division of the NCHS by coroners and medical examiners.
  • While all types of deaths are reported, there are specific codes for homicides (justifiable vs. criminal homicides).
  • Vast majority of deaths (68%68\%) classified as homicides in 2010 involved a firearm.

Homicide Victimization Across the Globe

  • Homicide victimization is one of the few types of criminal victimization that can be compared across countries.
  • Source of International Homicide Victimization Data:
    • United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime
    • World Health Organization

Homicide Victimization Across the Globe

  • World Health Organization (WHO)
    • Mortality data are collected for 120 countries from individual death certificates and reported in aggregate form annually by the WHO.
    • There is no distinction made between intentional and unintentional homicides.
    • War-related casualties versus homicides make comparisons hard over time.

Risk Factors for and Characteristics of Homicide Victimization

  • Risk for homicide victimization is not evenly distributed among the population.
  • Your risk is dependent upon a number of characteristics
    • Sex.
    • Age.
    • Race.
    • Urbanity and socioeconomic status.

Risk Factors for and Characteristics of Homicide Victimization

  • Socio-Demographic Characteristics
    • Sex (males both as victims and offenders)
    • Age (between the ages of 18 through 24)
    • Race (overwhelmingly intra-racial event)
    • Urban (higher rate) and socioeconomic status (family income increase, victimization decrease)
    • Victim–offender relationship
      • Most homicides involve people who knew each other
      • One third of female homicides are killed by husband or boyfriend

Risk Factors for and Characteristics of Homicide Victimization

  • Incident Characteristics
    • Weapon usage
      • Used in about 71%71\% of homicides
      • Most common firearm used in homicides are handguns
    • Circumstance
      • 2 of 5 murders are because of arguments
      • 40%40\% circumstance is unknown
      • 1 of 4 murders during rape, robbery, or burglary

Risk Factors for and Characteristics of Homicide Victimization

  • Incident Characteristics
    • Location
      • Private dwellings
    • Substance use
      • Murderers and victim likely to have consumed alcohol, drugs, or both

Types of Homicide Victimization

  • Filicide: killing of a child by a parent or a caretaker
  • Infanticide: homicides in which the victim is under 1 year of age (type of filicide)
  • Parricide: murder of one’s parent--includes patricide and matricide
  • Eldercide: murder that involves a victim who is 65 years of age or older
  • Intimate partner homicide: homicide involving spouses, ex-spouses, persons in current or de facto relationships, boyfriends or girlfriends, or partners of same-sex relationships

Types of Homicide Victimization

  • Femicide: gender-based violence
    • Diana Russell
      • “The killing of females by males because they are female”
  • Honor killings: committed with the idea that the perpetrator is protecting or regaining his honor, or that of the family or community
    • The National Criminal Records Bureau of India
      • Sex, age, and motive

Types of Homicide Victimization

  • Homicides involving multiple victims
    • Serial murder
    • Mass murder (4 or more victims in one location, in one incident--Aurora, Colorado movie theater)
    • Spree murder (killing of multiple people at two or more locations with no break)

Victim Precipitation Theories

  • Explain how an individual’s behavior may contribute to his or her own victimization
  • Many homicides involve some degree of victim precipitation
    • The victim may have been the first person to use physical force or start the violence that eventually resulted in his or her own death

Indirect (Secondary) Victimization

  • Most often applies to close family and friends of the primary homicide victim
    • Witnessing the murder of your mother at the hands of her husband
  • Can also be applied to individuals who witness a homicide and professionals who, because of their occupation, deal with a homicide’s aftereffects
    • Law enforcement
    • Bereavement counselors

Consequences of Homicide

  • Bereavement: state of being sad after an individual you have cared for has passed
  • Additional stressors
    • Death or casualty notification
      • Family members of the deceased are notified of their loved one’s passing
    • Involvement in the criminal justice system