elmer speciation 2024-25_upload

Page 1: Introduction to Speciation

  • Lecture theme: 'Radiations and Extinctions'

  • Presented by Dr. Kathryn Elmer

Page 2: Aims for Today

  • Define "speciation" and discuss its progression over time.

  • Examine geographic modes of speciation.

  • Explore genetic or causal modes of speciation.

Page 3: Early Inspiration in Biogeography

  • Inquiry into species distribution: Why are species located in certain areas?

  • Key points:

    • Similar climates do not guarantee the same species.

    • Physical barriers are crucial (e.g., mountains, marine areas).

    • Taxa in a given biogeographic region are often related.

  • Historical figures: Darwin, Wallace, Bates, Humboldt, and A.R. Wallace's work on animal distribution in evolution.

Page 4: Definition of a Species

  • Darwin defined species as a convenience term for closely resembling individuals.

    • 1859 quotes:

      • Species vs. Variety: species serves as an arbitrary label.

      • Defined species can be recognized without chaos of variation.

  • Modern additions include genetic differentiation and reproductive isolation.

Page 5: Introduction to Key Theorists

  • Highlighted theorists on genetics and species origin:

    • Theodosius Dobzhansky (Genetics, California Institute of Technology)

    • Ernst Mayr (Systematics and Zoology)

  • 1937 publication details.

Page 6: Biological Species Concept

  • Mayr's definition: Groups of interbreeding populations that cannot exchange genes with others in the same area.

  • Speciation as evolution of reproductive isolation in an ancestral species.

Page 7: Modes of Speciation

  • Classifications:

    • Geographic modes initiating reproductive isolation:

      • Allopatric (vicariant, peripatric)

      • Parapatric

      • Sympatric

    • Genetic and causal bases:

      1. Genetic divergence (including drift, selection, sexual selection)

      2. Cytoplasmic incompatibility

      3. Cytological divergence (polyploidy)

      4. Recombinational speciation

  • Reference: Textbook “Evolution” by Futuyma.

Page 8: Speciation Models

  • Overview of the frequency and types of modes:

    • Sympatric, parapatric, and allopatric modes indicated by environmental selection.

Page 9: Speciation Models Detail

  • Stages of four geographic speciation models:

    • (A) Allopatric speciation

    • (B) Peripatric speciation by vicariance

    • (C) Parapatric speciation

    • (D) Sympatric speciation

  • Example of genetic differences leading to reproductive isolation.

Page 10: Allopatric Speciation

  • Definition: Reproductive isolation due to an extrinsic geographic barrier.

  • Types:

    • Vicariance: large populations.

    • Peripatric: one small population.

  • Factors causing speciation: genetic drift, natural selection.

  • Examples: Water level fluctuations, tectonic movements, island colonization.

Page 11: Evidence for Allopatric Speciation

  • Case study: Salamanders in the Appalachian Mountains.

    • High species richness due to complex topography.

    • Divergence correlated with geographic distance and breeding behaviors.

Page 12: Evidence for Peripatric Speciation

  • Focus on Drosophila species:

    • Derived species on islands.

    • Isolated populations diversifying from an ancestral species due to genetic drift.

Page 13: Mechanisms of Allopatric Speciation

  • Natural selection causes genetic differences that lead to reproductive isolation.

  • Dobzhansky-Muller incompatibility as a common form of genetic incompatibility in divergent species.

Page 14: Summary of Speciation Modes

  • Recap of geographic and genetic modes of speciation with key drivers.

Page 15: Parapatric Speciation

  • Characteristics:

    • Restricted gene flow; environmental differences drive divergence.

    • Often difficult to demonstrate in nature due to secondary contact.

Page 16: Evidence for Parapatric Speciation

  • Case study: Tennessee cave salamanders and their speciation linked to gene flow dynamics.

Page 17: Recap of Speciation Modes

  • Modes of speciation reiterated, emphasizing geographic initiation and genetic divergence mechanisms.

Page 18: Sympatric Speciation Requirements

  • Key aspects:

    • Disruptive selection leading to reproductive isolation within the same environment.

    • Example: Cichlid fishes in Nicaraguan crater lakes.

    • Debate exists among scientists regarding the mechanisms of sympatric speciation.

Page 19: Sympatric Speciation Study

  • Reference: Study on Nicaraguan crater lake cichlids demonstrating examples of sympatric speciation.

Page 20: Evolution of Speciation Models

  • Transition from geographic-based models to ecology and selection-focused perspectives in speciation studies.

Page 21: Comprehensive Classifications of Speciation

  • Detailed classifications incorporating geography and various genetic mechanisms for reproductive isolation in speciation.

Page 22: Ecological Speciation Paradigm

  • Definition: Speciation driven by ecology-based divergent selection.

  • Contrast with non-ecological models relying on chance events (e.g., genetic drift, hybridization).

Page 23: Modes of Speciation Recap

  • Compilation of geographic and genetic modes divided into categories such as genetic divergence, cytoplasmic incompatibility, and chromosomal arrangements.

Page 24: Continuation of Modes of Speciation

  • Continued emphasis on geographic modes and genetic modes relevant to reproductive isolation.

Page 25: Cytological Divergence

  • Involves polyploidy and chromosomal arrangements; can lead to immediate speciation.

  • Common in plants, rarer in animals.

Page 26: Recombinational Speciation

  • Definition: Hybrid speciation characterized by high fitness hybrids (F1) being fertile.

  • Contextual significance in evolving environments.

Page 27: Case Study on Tree Frogs

  • Comparison of eastern grey treefrog and Cope’s grey treefrog illustrating polyploidy and overlapping distributions.

Page 28: Research on Tree Frog Hybridization

  • Reference: Speciation research in treefrog species discussing hybridization and genetic relationships.

Page 29: Video Resource

  • Link to a supplementary video resource on speciation.

Page 30: Homework Assignment

  • Task: Find additional examples of cytological speciation and hybrid speciation.

Page 31: Summary of Key Points

  1. Speciation involves the evolution of reproductive isolation, resulting in new species.

  2. Geographic modes of speciation driven by environmental selection and gene flow restrictions: Allopatric, Parapatric, Sympatric.

  3. Causal mechanisms, including ecological speciation, manifest as barriers to gene flow.

  4. Genetic modes encompass both slow and rapid processes, such as genetic drift and polyploidy.