Impact of the Media

Key Terms

  • Digital Optimism: The belief that new media facilitates a form of liberation.

  • Digital Pessimism: The belief that new media creates negative consequences.

  • Digital Divide: The gap between those who have access to modern information technology and those who do not.

  • Digital Natives: Individuals who were born into the digital world and have grown up using technology.

  • Privacy: Protection of personal information in the digital age.

  • Surveillance: The monitoring of individuals' activities online.

  • Piracy: The illegal copying of copyrighted material.

  • Wikinomics: Collaborative economics leveraged through new media.

  • Identity: The conception of oneself in relation to society.

  • Interpersonal relationships: Relationships facilitated or altered by new media.

  • Cybercrime/Cyberbullying: Criminal activities conducted online.

Impact on Privacy

  • Personal Privacy Concerns: Personal information is commodified by companies like Facebook, which use data from users' online activities to offer targeted advertising. Users often sacrifice privacy for 'free' services.

  • Data Gathering: Corporations gather extensive personal information including ethnicity, IQ, and political views based on user interactions (Socha & Eber-Schmid, 2012).

  • Surveillance: Increased capability for both corporate and state surveillance, leading to monitoring of user activities (who they contact, websites visited).

  • Persistent Data Issues: Once shared online, data is difficult to retract, with potential implications for personal privacy and security.

  • Digital Stalking and Bullying: Increased openness to new forms of harassment due to the constant sharing of information online.

Globalisation and New Media

  • Global Reach: Unlike traditional media which is often constrained to local consumption, new media allows for the creation of global connections and interactions.

  • Interconnectedness: New media connects text, images, sound, and video across a global network, exemplified by platforms like Wikipedia.

  • Cultural Exchange: The sharing of diverse cultures becomes more accessible, leading to a potential blending of global identities.

Challenges to Power Structures

  • Digital Piracy: The ease of copying and distributing content leads to challenges for media industries, which are adversely affected by digital piracy.

  • Economic Models: Emergence of freemium models where basic services are free, but profitability is derived from premium features. Examples include popular online games (Tapscott & Williams, 2008).

  • Hacking Issues: Governments and individuals engage in unauthorized access of networks, raising cybersecurity risks and issues of digital warfare.

Debate: Digital Optimism vs. Digital Pessimism

Digital Optimism

  • Liberation Concept: Negroponte (1995) claims that new media can decentralise power, empower ordinary citizens, and strengthen global cooperation.

  • Economic Impact: Development of new collaborative models for creativity and production (Wikinomics).

  • Political Empowerment: Global flow of information enhances access to knowledge and reduces state control over individuals.

  • Cultural Behavior: New media supports participatory cultures, leading to enhanced individuality in collective environments.

Digital Pessimism

  • Centralisation of Power: While decentralizing can occur, globalisation via new media can also consolidate economic and ideological control (Schecter, 2000).

  • Exploitation of Free Labor: Business models often utilize user-generated content without fair compensation.

  • Risks to Quality and Privacy: Concerns that free online models compromise quality and exploit user data rights.

  • Social Isolation and Negative Behavior: Spending more time online may reduce real-life interactions, exacerbating issues like cyberbullying and trolling (Sittichai & Smith, 2015).

Social Identities and Interpersonal Relationships

  • Fluidity of Identity: Postmodernists argue that identities are less fixed and allow for greater individual expression online.

  • Opportunities for Diverse Identities: Virtual worlds enable users to explore and express multiple identities, especially for those in marginalized communities (Rajendran, 2018).

  • Interpersonal Relationship Dynamics: New media facilitates continuous connection, impacting relationships and community links. Examples include migrant communities maintaining ties with home countries, albeit sometimes leading to complications and feelings of surveillance.

  • Tolerance and Exposure: Digital optimists suggest that increased exposure to diverse views can foster open-mindedness, while pessimists argue that networks may reinforce intolerance among like-minded individuals.

References

  • Socha, K. & Eber-Schmid, J. (2012). The Impact of Digital Media.

  • Tapscott, D. & Williams, A. D. (2008). Wikinomics: How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything.

  • Sittichai, R. & Smith, P. K. (2015). Cyberbullying in different cultures.

  • Negroponte, N. (1995). Being Digital.

  • Schecter, C. (2000). Media Ownership and Diversity.

Evidence of Social Identity

Declining Trust in Authority Figures

  • There is a notable long-term trend of decreasing trust in authority figures such as politicians and police in the UK.

    • For instance, the percentage of people who respond ‘Almost never’ to the question of trusting governments has risen from 11.8% in 1986 to 33.5% in 2011.

    • This decline may be tied to an overall decrease in political engagement and shifts in citizens' roles.

Impact on Citizenship and State Relationship

  • Over the next decade, there may be a redefined relationship between citizens and the state, particularly around aspects like welfare, health, and education.

    • Governments might transfer responsibilities to individuals, potentially fostering trust within communities characterised by strong social networks.

    • However, marginalised groups may find it challenging to cope with reduced state support and lack of trust in authority.

Voter Engagement and Political Fragmentation

  • Recent years have seen a decline in voter turnout during general elections, indicating diminished political participation.

    • There is less affiliation with dominant political parties, which may in part be due to perceptions of similarity among them.

    • The rise of minor parties signifies a diversification in voter support, influenced by different socio-economic backgrounds.

Surveillance Culture and Identity

  • As surveillance and personal data collection by state and private entities increase, relationships of trust between citizens and authorities might deteriorate.

    • While some surveillance methods are accepted by the public, concerns about privacy and data misuse arise, complicating social identities in the digital age.

Postmodernist Perspective

  • From a postmodernist standpoint, these trends reflect a fragmented society where individual identities are fluid and constructed through personal experiences and interactions with media.

    • The decline in the concept of a singular ‘British’ identity highlights the multiplicity of identities as people navigate diverse cultural landscapes, informed by globalisation and technological advancements.

    • Younger generations display a more libertarian viewpoint compared to older cohorts, reflecting adapted norms and values shaped by media exposure and social connectivity rather than authoritative influence.

Changing Notions of Identity

  • The transformation of national identity may manifest as younger individuals increasingly identify outside of traditional constructs, such as ‘Britishness’.

    • These identity shifts, deeply influenced by media portrayals, highlight a postmodern reality where belonging is negotiated through varied social contexts and interconnections.