Impact of the Media
Key Terms
Digital Optimism: The belief that new media facilitates a form of liberation.
Digital Pessimism: The belief that new media creates negative consequences.
Digital Divide: The gap between those who have access to modern information technology and those who do not.
Digital Natives: Individuals who were born into the digital world and have grown up using technology.
Privacy: Protection of personal information in the digital age.
Surveillance: The monitoring of individuals' activities online.
Piracy: The illegal copying of copyrighted material.
Wikinomics: Collaborative economics leveraged through new media.
Identity: The conception of oneself in relation to society.
Interpersonal relationships: Relationships facilitated or altered by new media.
Cybercrime/Cyberbullying: Criminal activities conducted online.
Impact on Privacy
Personal Privacy Concerns: Personal information is commodified by companies like Facebook, which use data from users' online activities to offer targeted advertising. Users often sacrifice privacy for 'free' services.
Data Gathering: Corporations gather extensive personal information including ethnicity, IQ, and political views based on user interactions (Socha & Eber-Schmid, 2012).
Surveillance: Increased capability for both corporate and state surveillance, leading to monitoring of user activities (who they contact, websites visited).
Persistent Data Issues: Once shared online, data is difficult to retract, with potential implications for personal privacy and security.
Digital Stalking and Bullying: Increased openness to new forms of harassment due to the constant sharing of information online.
Globalisation and New Media
Global Reach: Unlike traditional media which is often constrained to local consumption, new media allows for the creation of global connections and interactions.
Interconnectedness: New media connects text, images, sound, and video across a global network, exemplified by platforms like Wikipedia.
Cultural Exchange: The sharing of diverse cultures becomes more accessible, leading to a potential blending of global identities.
Challenges to Power Structures
Digital Piracy: The ease of copying and distributing content leads to challenges for media industries, which are adversely affected by digital piracy.
Economic Models: Emergence of freemium models where basic services are free, but profitability is derived from premium features. Examples include popular online games (Tapscott & Williams, 2008).
Hacking Issues: Governments and individuals engage in unauthorized access of networks, raising cybersecurity risks and issues of digital warfare.
Debate: Digital Optimism vs. Digital Pessimism
Digital Optimism
Liberation Concept: Negroponte (1995) claims that new media can decentralise power, empower ordinary citizens, and strengthen global cooperation.
Economic Impact: Development of new collaborative models for creativity and production (Wikinomics).
Political Empowerment: Global flow of information enhances access to knowledge and reduces state control over individuals.
Cultural Behavior: New media supports participatory cultures, leading to enhanced individuality in collective environments.
Digital Pessimism
Centralisation of Power: While decentralizing can occur, globalisation via new media can also consolidate economic and ideological control (Schecter, 2000).
Exploitation of Free Labor: Business models often utilize user-generated content without fair compensation.
Risks to Quality and Privacy: Concerns that free online models compromise quality and exploit user data rights.
Social Isolation and Negative Behavior: Spending more time online may reduce real-life interactions, exacerbating issues like cyberbullying and trolling (Sittichai & Smith, 2015).
Social Identities and Interpersonal Relationships
Fluidity of Identity: Postmodernists argue that identities are less fixed and allow for greater individual expression online.
Opportunities for Diverse Identities: Virtual worlds enable users to explore and express multiple identities, especially for those in marginalized communities (Rajendran, 2018).
Interpersonal Relationship Dynamics: New media facilitates continuous connection, impacting relationships and community links. Examples include migrant communities maintaining ties with home countries, albeit sometimes leading to complications and feelings of surveillance.
Tolerance and Exposure: Digital optimists suggest that increased exposure to diverse views can foster open-mindedness, while pessimists argue that networks may reinforce intolerance among like-minded individuals.
References
Socha, K. & Eber-Schmid, J. (2012). The Impact of Digital Media.
Tapscott, D. & Williams, A. D. (2008). Wikinomics: How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything.
Sittichai, R. & Smith, P. K. (2015). Cyberbullying in different cultures.
Negroponte, N. (1995). Being Digital.
Schecter, C. (2000). Media Ownership and Diversity.
Evidence of Social Identity
Declining Trust in Authority Figures
There is a notable long-term trend of decreasing trust in authority figures such as politicians and police in the UK.
For instance, the percentage of people who respond ‘Almost never’ to the question of trusting governments has risen from 11.8% in 1986 to 33.5% in 2011.
This decline may be tied to an overall decrease in political engagement and shifts in citizens' roles.
Impact on Citizenship and State Relationship
Over the next decade, there may be a redefined relationship between citizens and the state, particularly around aspects like welfare, health, and education.
Governments might transfer responsibilities to individuals, potentially fostering trust within communities characterised by strong social networks.
However, marginalised groups may find it challenging to cope with reduced state support and lack of trust in authority.
Voter Engagement and Political Fragmentation
Recent years have seen a decline in voter turnout during general elections, indicating diminished political participation.
There is less affiliation with dominant political parties, which may in part be due to perceptions of similarity among them.
The rise of minor parties signifies a diversification in voter support, influenced by different socio-economic backgrounds.
Surveillance Culture and Identity
As surveillance and personal data collection by state and private entities increase, relationships of trust between citizens and authorities might deteriorate.
While some surveillance methods are accepted by the public, concerns about privacy and data misuse arise, complicating social identities in the digital age.
Postmodernist Perspective
From a postmodernist standpoint, these trends reflect a fragmented society where individual identities are fluid and constructed through personal experiences and interactions with media.
The decline in the concept of a singular ‘British’ identity highlights the multiplicity of identities as people navigate diverse cultural landscapes, informed by globalisation and technological advancements.
Younger generations display a more libertarian viewpoint compared to older cohorts, reflecting adapted norms and values shaped by media exposure and social connectivity rather than authoritative influence.
Changing Notions of Identity
The transformation of national identity may manifest as younger individuals increasingly identify outside of traditional constructs, such as ‘Britishness’.
These identity shifts, deeply influenced by media portrayals, highlight a postmodern reality where belonging is negotiated through varied social contexts and interconnections.