Memory and Amnesia

K.C. and Memory Loss

  • K.C.'s Mental Make-up:

    • Utter inability to remember any events, circumstances, or situations from his own life.

    • Total episodic amnesia from birth to the present.

    • Exception: can remember experiences from the last minute or two (Tulving, 2002, p. 14).

Learning Objectives

  • By the end of this section, you will be able to:

    • Compare and contrast the two types of amnesia.

    • Discuss the unreliability of eyewitness testimony.

    • Discuss encoding failure.

    • Discuss various memory errors.

    • Compare and contrast the two types of interference.

Amnesia

  • Definition: Loss of long-term memory due to disease, physical trauma, or psychological trauma.

  • Notable Case: K.C. studied by Endel Tulving (2002) who suffered severe amnesia after a motorcycle accident.

Types of Amnesia

Anterograde Amnesia
  • Definition: Inability to form new memories after the trauma, while retaining memories prior to the injury.

  • Causes: Commonly related to brain trauma (e.g., blow to the head).

  • Brain Structures Involved: Hippocampus usually affected; results in the inability to transfer information from short-term to long-term memory, preventing consolidation.

  • Memory Formation: New procedural memories can still be formed, but new episodic or semantic memories cannot (Bayley & Squire, 2002).

  • Example: H. M., who repeatedly read the same magazine without remembering it.

Retrograde Amnesia
  • Definition: Loss of memories for events prior to the trauma; cannot remember past events.

  • Example: A person waking up in a hospital post-accident, unable to recognize family.

  • Real-Life Case: Scott Bolzan, who lost 46 years of memories after a head injury.

Memory Construction and Reconstruction

  • Definition: The process of forming and retrieving memories can lead to alterations and inaccuracies.

  • Flexible Nature of Memories: During retrieval, memories can be influenced by new events and modified.

Suggestibility and Eyewitness Testimony

Suggestibility

  • Definition: The effect of misinformation from external sources leading to the creation of false memories.

  • Case Study: During the sniper attacks in Washington D.C. in 2002, eyewitness reports of a white van misled the investigation, as the suspects were using a blue sedan.

Eyewitness Misidentification

  • Impact: Faulty eyewitness testimony can lead to wrongful convictions. (Figure 8.11)

  • Case Study: Jennifer Thompson, who misidentified Ronald Cotton as her rapist, illustrating leading cues from police can reinforce false memories.

Misinformation Effect

  • Research by Elizabeth Loftus:

    • Eyewitness memories are flexible.

    • Experiment (Loftus & Palmer, 1974): Different verbs in questions about car accidents altered speed estimates and recollection of details (e.g., "smashed" vs. "contacted").

    • Memory inaccuracies can be increased by suggestion and leading questions.

Controversies of Repressed and Recovered Memories

False Memory Syndrome

  • Definition: Recall of autobiographical memories that are false or distorted.

  • Repressed Memories Debate: Some researchers argue that traumatic memories can be repressed and later recalled through therapeutic methods, while others, including Loftus, contest the accuracy of these recalled memories.

Reliability of Eyewitness Accounts

  • Changes in questioning practices to minimize suggestibility have been suggested, including using neutral language and blind photo lineups.

Forgetting

Definitions

  • Forgetting: Loss of information from long-term memory.

  • Encoding Failure: Not storing information correctly; for instance, details about everyday objects (like a penny).

Types of Forgetting

Transience
  • Definition: Decrease in memory accessibility over time.

  • Forgetting Curve: Ebbinghaus’ findings demonstrate loss of 50% of memorized information after 20 minutes, and 70% after 24 hours (Ebbinghaus, 1885/1964).

Absentmindedness
  • Definition: Memory errors caused by lapses in attention.

  • Example: Forgetting where you put your phone.

  • Blocking: Difficulty accessing stored information may occur, known as the tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon.

Seven Sins of Memory (Schacter, 2001)

  • Categories:

    • Forgetting

    • Distortion

    • Intrusion

Specific Memory Errors
  1. Misattribution: Confusion about the source of a memory (e.g., recalling a dream as a real memory).

  2. Suggestibility: False memories arise from external information.

  3. Bias: Memories are distorted by our beliefs and views of the world.

  4. Persistence: Involuntary recall of unwanted memories, especially traumatic ones.

  5. Proactive Interference: Old information hinders recall of new information.

  6. Retroactive Interference: New information inhibits recall of old information.

Conclusion

  • Memory is complex and inherently flawed due to processes like construction, suggestibility, and interference, impacting eyewitness reliability and personal recollections of events.