University Study Notes: Occupiers' Liability Act 1984 and Non-Visitors

Definition and Conceptual Basis of Non-Visitors

  • Definition of a Trespasser: According to Vivien Harpwood in Modern Tort Law (7th edn, Cavendish Publishing 2009), a trespasser is defined as a person whose presence on land is unknown to the occupier or, if known, is objected to by the occupier in some practical way.
  • Category Identification: The Occupiers’ Liability Act (OLA) 1984 deals specifically with liability toward non-visitors, a group that predominantly includes trespassers.

Historical Evolution of the Duty of Care

  • Traditional Common Law View: Historically, occupiers owed no duty to trespassers other than to refrain from deliberately or recklessly inflicting damage or injury to trespassers known to be present on the land.
  • The Turning Point - British Railways Board v Herrington [1972] AC 877:     * As a result of this case involving a 6-year-old trespasser, the House of Lords formulated a new attitude toward trespassers.     * They established a duty of ‘common humanity’ toward trespassers.     * This required occupiers to act humanely even toward those on the land without permission.

Statutory Framework of the Occupiers’ Liability Act 1984

  • Section 1(1)(a) - Scope of Application: The Act determines whether any duty is owed by an occupier to a non-visitor in respect of any risk of injury by reason of any danger due to the state of the premises or to things done or omitted to be done on them.
  • Section 1(3) - The Threefold Test for the Existence of a Duty: A duty is only owed if the following three conditions are satisfied:     1. Section 1(3)(a): The occupier is aware of the danger or has reasonable grounds to believe it exists.     2. Section 1(3)(b): The occupier knows or has reasonable grounds to believe that the non-visitor is in the vicinity of the danger or may come into the vicinity of the danger.     3. Section 1(3)(c): The risk is one against which an occupier may reasonably be expected to offer some protection.
  • Section 1(4) - The Nature of the Duty: This section imposes a duty to take such care as is reasonable in all the circumstances of the case to see that the non-visitor does not suffer injury on the premises by reason of the danger concerned.

Comparative Analysis: OLA 1957 vs. OLA 1984

  • Duty to Visitors (OLA 1957, s 2(2)): The common duty of care is to take such care as in all the circumstances of the case is reasonable to see that the visitor will be reasonably safe in using the premises for the purposes for which they are invited or permitted to be there.
  • Duty to Non-Visitors (OLA 1984, s 1(4)): The duty is to take such care as is reasonable in all the circumstances of the case to see that the non-visitor does not suffer injury on the premises by reason of the danger concerned.
  • Types of Damage Recoverable:     * OLA 1957: Allows claims for both personal injury and damage to property.     * OLA 1984: Only allows claims for death or personal injury (Sections 1(8) and 1(9)). Claims for property damage are excluded.

Leading Case Study: Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council [2003] UKHL 47

  • Facts of the Case:     * The claimant was an 18-year-old visitor to a park.     * The claimant ignored warning signs and performed a shallow dive into a lake.     * He hit his head on the bottom, resulting in serious injuries.
  • Key Findings:     * An occupier of land owes no duty of care to a claimant who suffers injury from an activity that cannot be attributed to the state of the premises (under Section 1(1)).     * T's injury was attributed to his own activity (diving), not the state of the lake itself.     * The risk was not one against which the claimant was entitled to protection under Section 1(3)(c).
  • Determining Reasonable Care: Even for lawful visitors, where risks are attributable to the state of the premises, reasonable care assessment includes:     1. The likelihood of injury.     2. The seriousness of injury.     3. The social value of the activity.     4. The cost of preventative measures.
  • Judicial Opinions:     * Lord Hoffman: Stated that it would be "extremely rare" for a landowner to be under a duty to prevent people from taking risks inherent in activities they freely choose. He emphasized that if people choose to climb mountains or swim in lakes, "that is their affair" and cited the "important question of freedom at stake."     * Lord Hobhouse: Argued that it should not be the policy of the law to require the protection of the "foolhardy or reckless few" if it deprives the remainder of society of their liberties and amenities.     * Lord Scott: Noted that while accidents arise from the "joie de vivre of the young," this is no reason to impose a "grey and dull safety regime on everyone."

Case Law Analysis: Application of OLA 1984

  • General Non-Visitor Cases:     * Swain v Natui Ram Puri [1996] PIQR P442: Involved a 9-year-old boy who fell from a defendant's roof and was injured.     * Platt v Liverpool CC (1997) LTL 3 May: A group of boys entered derelict buildings; the structures collapsed, killing one and injuring another.     * Ratcliffe v McConnell [1999] 1 WLR 670: A student who had been drinking went for a swim in a college pool.     * Donoghue v Folkestone Properties [2003] EWCA Civ 231: A claimant dived into Folkestone harbour and was severely injured.     * Jamie Rhind v Astbury Water Park Ltd & Anr [2004] EWCA Civ 756: Similar to Tomlinson; the claimant dove into a shallow lake to retrieve a football and hit his head on a submerged fiberglass container. While physical injuries were due to the state of the premises (unlike Tomlinson), the claimant could not establish a duty of care under Section 1(3)(a) as the occupier was not aware of the danger.
  • Adult Trespassers:     * Higgs v WH Foster (T/A Avalon Coaches) [2004] EWCA Civ 843: A police officer in a surveillance position fell into an inspection pit at 2:00 a.m.     * Maloney v Torfaen County Borough Council [2005] EWCA Civ 1762: A drunk claimant took a shortcut to their flat at midnight, slipped, and fell.     * Siddorn v Patel [2007] EWHC 1248 (QB): A tenant at a party walked through waist-height windows onto a garage roof with skylights and fell through.
  • Child Trespassers:     * Young v Kent County Council [2005] EWHC 63 (QB): A 12-year-old climbed onto a roof using an extractor fan duct pipe and fell through a skylight.     * Keown v Coventry Healthcare NHS Trust [2006] EWCA Civ 39: An 11-year-old boy climbed the underside of a fire escape and fell.     * Mann v Northern Electric Distribution Ltd [2010] EWCA Civ 141: A 15-year-old climbed into a substation by scaling high walls and spiked wire, crossed a roof, slid down a mast, and was electrocuted on a transformer roof, leading to leg amputation.     * Buckett v Staffordshire CC (QBD) 13 April 2015: A 16-year-old climbed onto a roof and fell through a skylight.

Discharge of Duty, Exclusions, and Defences

  • Warnings (Section 1(5)): The duty may be discharged by giving appropriate warning of the danger or discouraging persons from incurring the risk. Example: Westwood v Post Office [1973] 1 All ER 184, where a sign stating ‘Only authorised attendant is permitted to enter’ was relevant.
  • Exclusion of Liability:     * The 1984 Act is generally silent on exclusion, suggesting it may represent a minimum standard.     * Section 2 of the 1984 Act allows exclusion when people enter business premises for educational or recreational purposes, unless access falls within the occupier's main business purpose (e.g., hikers crossing farmland). Reference is also made to the Consumer Rights Act 2015 s.66(4)(b).
  • Defences:     * Volenti (Section 1(6)): No duty is owed to any person in respect of risks willingly accepted as theirs by that person (e.g., Ratcliffe v McConnell).     * Contributory Negligence: This may apply to reduce damages (e.g., Young v Kent County Council).

Special Legislation: Countryside & Rights of Way Act 2000

  • Effect of Section 1A: Modifies OLA 1957 (s 1(4)) and OLA 1984 (s 1(6A)).
  • Right to Roam: Imposes express limits on liability toward someone exercising the "right to roam." It appears these individuals are owed a lesser duty of care than a standard trespasser.

Decision Tree for Liability under OLA 1984

  1. Section 1(1)(a): Did the trespasser suffer injury due to a danger related to the state of the premises or things done/omitted on them?     * If No: No duty.     * If Yes: Proceed to Section 1(3).
  2. Section 1(3)(a): Is the occupier aware of the danger or have reasonable grounds to believe it exists?     * If No: No duty.     * If Yes: Proceed.
  3. Section 1(3)(b): Does the occupier know or have reasonable grounds to believe the trespasser is in or may come into the vicinity of the danger?     * If No: No duty.     * If Yes: Proceed.
  4. Section 1(3)(c): Is the risk one against which the occupier may reasonably be expected to provide protection?     * If No: No duty.     * If Yes: The occupier owes a duty under Section 1(4).
  5. Section 1(4): Did the occupier take such care as is reasonable in all circumstances to ensure the trespasser did not suffer injury?     * If Yes: No liability.     * If No: Occupier is liable to the trespasser.