Untitled
POLI112 Study Unit Outcomes
Upon completion of this study unit, students should be able to:
Analyze how public opinions shape voter choice.
Discuss the determinants of voter turnout.
Comment on the electoral process and campaign money.
Identify different electoral systems.
Introduction to Elections
Elections serve as the cornerstone of democracy.
They enable the masses to control their government.
Citizens can endorse or reject parties and their policies through elections.
Elected officials are theoretically held accountable to voters.
If officials fail to be responsive, they may be voted out.
Elections act as tools for voters to hold representatives accountable.
There are various electoral systems utilized in different contexts.
Representation
Representation involves the translation of the people's will into government systems.
Ancient Athens practiced direct democracy, which included active participation of citizens in governance.
However, direct democracy is becoming increasingly impractical due to population growth and urbanization.
This has led to the development of representative democracy.
Theories of representation:
Trusteeship
Delegation
Mandate
Resemblance
Trustee Model
A trustee is someone who acts on behalf of others.
They use their superior knowledge, education, or experience to make informed decisions.
Representation involves serving constituents through mature judgment and an enlightened conscience.
The model implies elitism, suggesting that knowledge is unevenly distributed in society.
Consequently, not all citizens may know what is best for them.
Delegate Model
A delegate acts as a conduit, expressing the views of others without significant personal judgment.
Examples of delegates include ambassadors and trade representatives.
Supporters of this model advocate for politicians to closely align with the views of their constituents.
Mechanisms that uphold this model:
Referendum
Recall
Popular sovereignty
This approach aims to limit the scope of leadership and ensure leaders are accountable to their constituents.
Mandate Model
A party receiving a popular mandate is authorized to implement policies it campaigned on during elections.
This model ensures party unity and discipline, obligating members to adhere to a unified party agenda.
Potential issues with the mandate model include:
Questions regarding voting behavior.
Policy commitments.
The model can impose constraints on political leaders.
Resemblance Model
In this model, representation is based on resemblance among constituents, such as class, gender, and age.
Concepts of equality and justice are central to this representation.
It postulates that only members of a minority group can adequately represent the interests of that group.
For instance, it emphasizes that men may not effectively represent women's interests.
Related concept: Descriptive representation.
Elections and Their Functions
Elections serve multiple essential functions in governance:
Legitimization: Elections legitimize the regime. Even despotic governments may hold elections.
Recruitment: Elections help in recruiting party candidates for political positions.
Government Formation: Elections determine the makeup of governments.
Policy Influence: Elections dissuade governments from adopting radical policies that are unpopular.
Voter Education: Election campaigns provide the electorate with extensive information about candidates and issues.
Legitimacy Building: Elections contribute to building the legitimacy of the governing bodies.
Elite Strengthening: Elections can also be manipulated by elites to control the masses.
Electoral Systems
Single-Member Plurality (SMP) System
Type: Majoritarian
Examples: USA, Canada, UK
Features:
Constituents vote for single candidates.
Winning candidate requires only a plurality of votes.
Advantages: Establishes a direct link between representatives and constituents.
Disadvantages: Leads to wasted votes for losing candidates.
Second-Ballot System
Type: Majoritarian
Examples: Russia, Iran, and some African nations
Features:
Single candidate constituencies with single-choice voting.
If no candidate wins a majority in the first round, a runoff is held between the top two candidates.
Advantages: Offers a broader range of electoral choices.
Disadvantages: Often compels candidates to adopt popularist positions.
Alternative Vote (AV) System
Type: Majoritarian
Examples: Australia, Papua New Guinea
Features:
Single-member constituencies with preferential voting where voters rank candidates.
Candidates must secure 50% of votes to win.
Advantages: Reduces wasted votes compared to SMP.
Disadvantages: Not significantly more proportional than SMP.
Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP) System
Type: Proportional
Examples: Germany, Italy, New Zealand
Features:
Some seats filled by SMP, others by party-list proportional representation.
Voters cast two votes—one for a candidate and another for a party.
Advantages: Strikes a balance between constituency representation and electoral fairness.
Disadvantages: The reliance on single-member constituencies limits overall proportionality.
Single-Transferable Vote (STV) System
Type: Proportional
Examples: Ireland, Northern Ireland
Features:
Multimember constituencies where parties may nominate as many candidates as there are seats.
Voters express preferences, and candidates are elected based on a quota.
Advantages: Capable of producing highly proportional outcomes.
Disadvantages: The degree of proportionality can vary greatly.
Party-List Proportional Representation (List-PR) System
Type: Proportional
Examples: Countries in Africa, Spain, Israel
Features:
Voters select parties instead of individual candidates in either a single constituency or regional party lists.
Parties are allocated seats based on the total votes received.
Some systems may impose thresholds for smaller parties.
Advantages: A potentially fair system of proportional representation.
Disadvantages: Small parties can create weak and unstable governments.
Voting Behavior and Theories of Voting
Factors affecting voting patterns:
Party-Identification Model
Describes psychological attachments individuals form with political parties.
Sociological Model
Links voting behavior to group affiliations, where voters adopt patterns reflecting their group's economic and social conditions.
Rational-Choice Model
Proposes that voters act rationally, basing their decisions on personal self-interest.
Dominant-Ideology Model
Suggests individual choices are influenced by a broader ideological manipulation and control process.
Questions and Answers
Any Questions?
Thank You!