Untitled

POLI112 Study Unit Outcomes

  • Upon completion of this study unit, students should be able to:

    • Analyze how public opinions shape voter choice.

    • Discuss the determinants of voter turnout.

    • Comment on the electoral process and campaign money.

    • Identify different electoral systems.

Introduction to Elections

  • Elections serve as the cornerstone of democracy.

    • They enable the masses to control their government.

    • Citizens can endorse or reject parties and their policies through elections.

    • Elected officials are theoretically held accountable to voters.

    • If officials fail to be responsive, they may be voted out.

    • Elections act as tools for voters to hold representatives accountable.

  • There are various electoral systems utilized in different contexts.

Representation

  • Representation involves the translation of the people's will into government systems.

    • Ancient Athens practiced direct democracy, which included active participation of citizens in governance.

    • However, direct democracy is becoming increasingly impractical due to population growth and urbanization.

    • This has led to the development of representative democracy.

  • Theories of representation:

    • Trusteeship

    • Delegation

    • Mandate

    • Resemblance

Trustee Model

  • A trustee is someone who acts on behalf of others.

    • They use their superior knowledge, education, or experience to make informed decisions.

  • Representation involves serving constituents through mature judgment and an enlightened conscience.

  • The model implies elitism, suggesting that knowledge is unevenly distributed in society.

    • Consequently, not all citizens may know what is best for them.

Delegate Model

  • A delegate acts as a conduit, expressing the views of others without significant personal judgment.

    • Examples of delegates include ambassadors and trade representatives.

  • Supporters of this model advocate for politicians to closely align with the views of their constituents.

  • Mechanisms that uphold this model:

    • Referendum

    • Recall

    • Popular sovereignty

  • This approach aims to limit the scope of leadership and ensure leaders are accountable to their constituents.

Mandate Model

  • A party receiving a popular mandate is authorized to implement policies it campaigned on during elections.

  • This model ensures party unity and discipline, obligating members to adhere to a unified party agenda.

  • Potential issues with the mandate model include:

    • Questions regarding voting behavior.

    • Policy commitments.

    • The model can impose constraints on political leaders.

Resemblance Model

  • In this model, representation is based on resemblance among constituents, such as class, gender, and age.

    • Concepts of equality and justice are central to this representation.

  • It postulates that only members of a minority group can adequately represent the interests of that group.

    • For instance, it emphasizes that men may not effectively represent women's interests.

  • Related concept: Descriptive representation.

Elections and Their Functions

  • Elections serve multiple essential functions in governance:

    • Legitimization: Elections legitimize the regime. Even despotic governments may hold elections.

    • Recruitment: Elections help in recruiting party candidates for political positions.

    • Government Formation: Elections determine the makeup of governments.

    • Policy Influence: Elections dissuade governments from adopting radical policies that are unpopular.

    • Voter Education: Election campaigns provide the electorate with extensive information about candidates and issues.

    • Legitimacy Building: Elections contribute to building the legitimacy of the governing bodies.

    • Elite Strengthening: Elections can also be manipulated by elites to control the masses.

Electoral Systems

  • Single-Member Plurality (SMP) System

    • Type: Majoritarian

    • Examples: USA, Canada, UK

    • Features:

    • Constituents vote for single candidates.

    • Winning candidate requires only a plurality of votes.

    • Advantages: Establishes a direct link between representatives and constituents.

    • Disadvantages: Leads to wasted votes for losing candidates.

  • Second-Ballot System

    • Type: Majoritarian

    • Examples: Russia, Iran, and some African nations

    • Features:

    • Single candidate constituencies with single-choice voting.

    • If no candidate wins a majority in the first round, a runoff is held between the top two candidates.

    • Advantages: Offers a broader range of electoral choices.

    • Disadvantages: Often compels candidates to adopt popularist positions.

  • Alternative Vote (AV) System

    • Type: Majoritarian

    • Examples: Australia, Papua New Guinea

    • Features:

    • Single-member constituencies with preferential voting where voters rank candidates.

    • Candidates must secure 50% of votes to win.

    • Advantages: Reduces wasted votes compared to SMP.

    • Disadvantages: Not significantly more proportional than SMP.

  • Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP) System

    • Type: Proportional

    • Examples: Germany, Italy, New Zealand

    • Features:

    • Some seats filled by SMP, others by party-list proportional representation.

    • Voters cast two votes—one for a candidate and another for a party.

    • Advantages: Strikes a balance between constituency representation and electoral fairness.

    • Disadvantages: The reliance on single-member constituencies limits overall proportionality.

  • Single-Transferable Vote (STV) System

    • Type: Proportional

    • Examples: Ireland, Northern Ireland

    • Features:

    • Multimember constituencies where parties may nominate as many candidates as there are seats.

    • Voters express preferences, and candidates are elected based on a quota.

    • Advantages: Capable of producing highly proportional outcomes.

    • Disadvantages: The degree of proportionality can vary greatly.

  • Party-List Proportional Representation (List-PR) System

    • Type: Proportional

    • Examples: Countries in Africa, Spain, Israel

    • Features:

    • Voters select parties instead of individual candidates in either a single constituency or regional party lists.

    • Parties are allocated seats based on the total votes received.

    • Some systems may impose thresholds for smaller parties.

    • Advantages: A potentially fair system of proportional representation.

    • Disadvantages: Small parties can create weak and unstable governments.

Voting Behavior and Theories of Voting

  • Factors affecting voting patterns:

    • Party-Identification Model

    • Describes psychological attachments individuals form with political parties.

    • Sociological Model

    • Links voting behavior to group affiliations, where voters adopt patterns reflecting their group's economic and social conditions.

    • Rational-Choice Model

    • Proposes that voters act rationally, basing their decisions on personal self-interest.

    • Dominant-Ideology Model

    • Suggests individual choices are influenced by a broader ideological manipulation and control process.

Questions and Answers

  • Any Questions?

  • Thank You!