1.3 Memory: Reconstructive Memory
1. Reconstructive Memory – Bartlett (1932)
Reconstructive memory: Memory is not an exact recording of events. Instead, we actively reconstruct memories using previously stored knowledge and experiences.
When recalling an event, we use stored information as a starting point and fill in gaps, reinterpret details or add information to create a coherent memory.
This can cause the original event to become distorted.
Bartlett's analogy: Memory is like a series of notes on a notepad. When recalling an event, we use existing knowledge to make sense of those notes.
2. Schema Theory
Schema: A mental framework of previously stored knowledge about a particular object, person or event.
Schemas develop through personal experiences and help us interpret and predict events.
When remembering, we use schemas to fill gaps and make information fit our existing expectations.
How schemas influence memory:
Stage | Influence of schemas |
|---|---|
I. Encoding (perception and storage) | We are more likely to store information that fits our existing schemas and may ignore or change unfamiliar information. |
II. Retrieval (recall) | We use schemas to fill gaps, reinterpret details and reconstruct memories. |
3. Wider Issues and Debates – Nature vs Nurture
Nature | Nurture |
|---|---|
Schemas are mental structures within the memory system. | The content of schemas develops through personal experiences, upbringing and culture. |
They may be considered part of the structural organisation of memory. | Different individuals and cultures develop different schemas and expectations. |
Conclusion: Schemas have a biological basis as mental structures, but their content is largely influenced by experience and therefore nurture.
4. Evaluation of Reconstructive Memory
Supporting research
Study | Method / findings | What it supports |
|---|---|---|
Bartlett (1932) – War of the Ghosts | British participants recalled an unfamiliar Native American folk tale. Their accounts became shorter, with unfamiliar details omitted or changed to fit their cultural expectations. | Supports reconstructive memory: schemas influence recall and distort unfamiliar information. |
Brewer & Treyens (1981) | Participants waited in an office and were later asked to recall its contents. They recalled expected office objects more often and sometimes remembered objects that were not actually there. | Supports schema theory: expectations can influence what people remember, even leading to false memories. |
Limitations and criticisms
Criticism / research | Explanation | What it challenges |
|---|---|---|
Steyvers & Hemmer (2012) | Argued that Bartlett's experimental conditions deliberately encouraged recall errors. In familiar, real-life contexts, memory can be very accurate. | Challenges the idea that memory is generally unreliable. |
Unpredictability of memory | Some memories are more resistant to distortion than others, depending on the individual and situation. | Makes it difficult to predict exactly how schemas will affect recall. |
Lack of real-life verification | Much research is laboratory-based, so it can be difficult to establish how accurately participants remember real events when the original event cannot be verified. | Limits conclusions about memory accuracy in everyday situations. |
Incomplete explanation | Reconstructive memory explains that schemas influence recall but does not clearly explain the precise processes through which memories are reconstructed. | Suggests it is only a partial explanation of memory. |
Real-world application – Eyewitness Testimony
Eyewitness testimony (EWT): Evidence provided by someone who witnessed a criminal event.
If memory is reconstructive, witnesses may unintentionally change details when recalling an event.
Schemas and expectations can influence what witnesses remember, potentially leading to inaccurate testimony.
Therefore, courts should be cautious when relying on eyewitness accounts.
Exam Application – Reconstructive Memory
For scenario questions, use this chain:
Identify the schema: What existing knowledge or expectations does the person have?
Explain the influence: How might this schema affect what they remember?
Apply to the scenario: Identify the specific details they have changed, added or omitted.
Example: Maryam's shoplifting incident
Step | Application |
|---|---|
Schema | Maryam has an existing schema of shoplifting involving valuable or desirable products. |
Influence | Her schema may influence how she reconstructs the incident when recalling it. |
Application | She reports that coffee and hair products were stolen, despite the CCTV showing lower-value items such as frozen peas and tinned beans. |
Key takeaway: Maryam may have reconstructed the event using her expectations of what shoplifting typically involves, rather than accurately recalling the items that were actually stolen.