Analysis of the 1918 Spanish Flu Virus

Jeffrey Taubenberger and the 1918 Spanish Flu

  • Jeffrey Taubenberger, a medical doctor at the Institute of Defense, investigated the 1918 Spanish flu.
  • He aimed to characterize the virus and understand its evolution by:
    • Retrieving fixed tissues from deceased servicemen archived at the Department of Defense.
    • Exhuming bodies buried in permafrost in Alaska who died during the pandemic.
  • Using molecular biology and PCR amplification, they amplified the gene segments of the 1918 Spanish flu.

Resurrecting the Spanish Flu

  • Reverse genetics was employed to engineer gene segments into DNA plasmids.
  • These plasmids were designed to produce both positive and negative sense RNA.
  • Transfecting these plasmids into a cell culture system allowed for the generation of the 1918 Spanish flu virus.
  • The plasmids, encoding gene segments of the 1918 Spanish flu, are transfected into cell culture.
  • Positive and negative sense RNAs are produced, leading to viral protein production from the RNA and creation of the viral genome from negative sense RNA.
  • These components self-assemble into virions, effectively resurrecting the flu virus in a petri dish.
  • The supernatant containing the virus can be amplified for further study.

Sialic Acid Binding Specificity

  • Taubenberger and Terence Tumpey characterized the sialic acid binding properties of the resurrected virus.
  • They compared viruses from the first and second waves of the 1918 Spanish flu.
  • The "1918 New York" strain, representing the first wave, could bind to both alpha 2-3 (avian linkage) and alpha 2-6 (human linkage) sialic acids.
  • The 1918 virus, initially identified in New York from returned servicemen, showed affinity for both alpha 2-3 and alpha 2-6 sialic acid linkages.
  • This dual specificity suggests a possible origin from birds, with subsequent mutations enabling binding to human receptors.
  • Evolution in the human host led to increased specificity for alpha 2-6 linkages.
  • The "1918 South Carolina" strain (second wave) exhibited only alpha 2-6 specificity.
  • The 1918 virus adapted to its human hosts, increasing its specificity for the alpha 2-6 linkage for efficient infection and transmission.
  • Changes in hemagglutinin binding site correlated with these changes in specificity.

Tissue Distribution of Sialic Acid Linkages

  • Humans possess both alpha 2-3 and alpha 2-6 sialic acid linkages, but their distribution varies in the respiratory tract.
  • The upper respiratory tract has high levels of alpha 2-6 linkages, while the lower airways (bronchioles and alveoli) contain cells with alpha 2-3 linkages.
  • Avian influenza viruses, with alpha 2-3 specificity, face a barrier in infecting the human upper respiratory tract due to the absence of alpha 2-3 linkages.
  • Infection by avian influenza requires the virus to reach the lower airways through prolonged or high-concentration exposure.
  • The initial 1918 infection may have involved bird flu introduction, with subsequent evolution from alpha 2-3 to alpha 2-6 specificity through repeated exposures.

Pathogenicity of the Spanish Flu

  • The 1918 Spanish flu caused a significant drop in life expectancy with high mortality in young adults (twenties and thirties).
  • Resurrecting the virus allowed for in-depth understanding of its pathogenicity.
  • The 1918 virus grew to very high levels compared to seasonal flu strains.
  • Experiments using reverse genetics showed that multiple gene segments contributed to the virus' virulence.
  • In ferrets, the 1918 strains caused rapid death within five days, unlike seasonal flu strains.
  • Swapping polymerase gene segments from 1918 into other strains showed increased virulence, though not as high as the original 1918 strain.

Immunopathology and Cytokine Storm

  • Gene microarray analysis revealed an overactive inflammatory response in ferrets infected with the 1918 virus.
  • The 1918 infection induced a sustained, high-level inflammatory response, characterized by a type one interferon signature.
  • Infection with the 1918 virus resulted in a sustained inflammatory response in the lungs, leading to viral primary pneumonia.
  • The pathogenicity of the 1918 Spanish flu was due to a combination of high viral titer and sustained inflammation in the lungs.
  • The overactive inflammatory response, termed a cytokine storm, contributed to the severity of the disease and will be discussed later in the context of COVID-19 immunopathology.