Principles of Microeconomics Study Guide

Publication Overview, Author Biography, and Academic Preface

Title Page & Publication Details

  • Work Title: Principles of Microeconomics (Seventh Edition)

  • Author: N. Gregory Mankiw (Harvard University)

  • Publisher: Cengage Learning (20152015, 20122012

  • Primary ISBNs: ISBN-13: 978-1-285-16590-5978\text{-}1\text{-}285\text{-}16590\text{-}5; ISBN-10: 1-285-16590-X1\text{-}285\text{-}16590\text{-}X

  • Publication Location: 200 First Stamford Place, 4th Floor, Stamford, CT 06902, USA

  • Publishing Executive Team:

    • Senior Vice President, Global Product Manager: Jack W. Calhoun

    • Vice President, General Manager: Erin Joyner

    • Product Director: Mike Worls

    • Developmental Editor: Jane Tufts

    • Product Development Manager: Jennifer E. Thomas

    • Content Developers: Clara Goosman and Elizabeth A. Beiting-Lipps

    • Senior Content Project Manager: Colleen A. Farmer

    • Senior Marketing Manager: Robin LeFevre

    • Cover Painting: Wojciech Gerson (1831–19011831\text{--}1901)

  • Dedication: "To Catherine, Nicholas, and Peter, my other contributions to the next generation."

About the Author: N. Gregory Mankiw

  • Academic Position: Robert M. Beren Professor of Economics at Harvard University.

  • Educational Background: Studied economics at Princeton University and Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT).

  • Teaching Experience: Has taught macroeconomics, microeconomics, statistics, and principles of economics; spent one summer long ago as a sailing instructor on Long Beach Island.

  • Scholarly & Popular Contributions: Published widely in academic journals including American Economic Review, Journal of Political Economy, and Quarterly Journal of Economics, as well as popular media such as The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal. Author of the intermediate-level textbook Macroeconomics (Worth Publishers).

  • Professional Roles & Public Service:

    • Research Associate of the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER).

    • Adviser to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) and the Federal Reserve Banks of Boston and New York.

    • Member of the ETS Test Development Committee for the Advanced Placement exam in economics.

    • Chairman of the President's Council of Economic Advisers from 20032003 to 20052005.

  • Personal Life: Resides in Wellesley, Massachusetts, with his wife Deborah, three children (Catherine, Nicholas, and Peter), and border terrier, Tobin.

Preface to the Student: The Purpose of Economic Study

  • Core Definition: Alfred Marshall defined economics in his 18901890 textbook, Principles of Economics, as "a study of mankind in the ordinary business of life."

  • Three Primary Motivations for Studying Economics:

    1. Understanding World Phenomena: Explains everyday realities such as apartment shortages in New York City, airline ticket pricing strategies (weekend stayover discounts), executive and celebrity compensation (e.g., Leonardo DiCaprio), international living standard disparities (e.g., in African nations), inflation variations, and job market fluctuations.

    2. Enhancing Individual Economic Agency: Provides decision-making tools for lifetime choices including years of schooling, spending vs. saving, investment strategies, and business pricing. Optimizing individual decision-making contributes directly to overall economic well-being.

    3. Grasping the Boundaries of Public Policy: Enables citizens and voters to evaluate the trade-offs of taxation, free trade, environmental protection, and government budget deficits, thereby enhancing aggregate social welfare.

Fundamental Economic Concepts: Scarcity, Efficiency, and Welfare

Etymology and the Problem of Resource Allocation

  • Etymological Origin: The word economy stems from the Greek word oikonomos, meaning "one who manages a household."

  • Household vs. Societal Allocation:

    • A household must allocate scarce resources (time, food, vehicular mileage) among members based on individual abilities, efforts, and desires.

    • A society must allocate jobs, land, machinery, and final goods/services (e.g., who consumes caviar vs. potatoes, or drives a luxury sports car vs. rides a bus).

  • Scarcity: The limited nature of society's resources. Society cannot produce all the goods and services that individuals desire to consume.

  • Definition of Economics: The study of how society manages its scarce resources through the decentralized choices of millions of households and firms interacting in markets.

The Utilitarian Objective in Economics

  • Maximizing Social Welfare: Economic analysis fundamentally evaluates how decentralized market mechanisms or central interventions allocate scarce resources to maximize aggregate human satisfaction, well-being, and utility.

  • Analytical Focus: Evaluating trade-offs, marginal benefits, marginal costs, and policy interventions based on their capacity to optimize net social benefits and minimize deadweight losses.

Principles of Individual Decision-Making

Part I IntroductionChapter 1 Easel

Principle 1: People Face Trade-offs

  • The Adage: "There ain't no such thing as a free lunch." Achieving one desired objective requires sacrificing another.

  • Individual Level Trade-offs: A student allocating time between studying economics and studying psychology; every hour spent studying one subject is an hour lost for the other, or lost from leisure activities (napping, bike riding, TV) or earning spending money at a part-time job. Parents allocating income between food, clothing, family vacations, or savings for retirement/college.

  • Societal Level Trade-offs:

    • "Guns vs. Butter": Allocating more resources to national defense ("guns") reduces the capacity to produce consumer goods ("butter") to raise domestic living standards.

    • Clean Environment vs. High Income: Environmental regulations force polluting firms to incur compliance costs. These higher costs reduce firm profits, lower worker wages, or raise consumer prices, sacrificing material income to gain health and environmental utility.

    • Efficiency vs. Equality:

    • Efficiency: The property of society getting the maximum benefits from its scarce resources (the size of the economic pie).

    • Equality: The property of distributing economic prosperity uniformly among the members of society (how the pie is divided into individual slices).

    • Trade-off Mechanism: Policies designed to equalize well-being (welfare systems, unemployment insurance, progressive individual income tax) redistribute income from the financially successful to the needy. This reduces the reward for hard work, diminishing work effort and total production. Attempting to cut the economic pie into equal slices causes the pie itself to shrink.

Principle 2: The Cost of Something Is What You Give Up to Get It

  • Opportunity Cost Definition: Whatever must be given up to obtain some item. Rational decision-making requires comparing the full costs and benefits of alternative courses of action.

  • The College Decision Example:

    • Direct Expenditures: Tuition, books, room, and board.

    • Misconceptions: Room and board are true costs only to the extent that they are more expensive at college than elsewhere (since shelter and food are needed regardless of college attendance).

    • Largest Hidden Cost: The value of time. Forgoing full-time employment earnings during four years of study constitutes the single largest cost of higher education.

    • Professional Athletes: High-ability college athletes who can earn millions in professional sports face an exceptionally high opportunity cost for attending college, leading them to rationally forgo a college degree.

Principle 3: Rational People Think at the Margin

  • Rational People: Individuals who systematically and purposefully do the best they can to achieve their objectives, given available opportunities.

  • Marginal Change: A small incremental adjustment to an existing plan of action ("margin" means edge).

  • Optimization Decision Rule: A rational actor takes an action if and only if the marginal benefit (MBMB) exceeds the marginal cost (MCMC):

Action taken if and only if MB>MC\text{Action taken if and only if } MB > MC

  • Example 1: Cell Phone Call:

    • Plan Details: Fixed fee of Fixed Fee=textdollar40/month\text{Fixed Fee} = \text{\\textdollar}40/\text{month}, plus Rate=textdollar0.50/minute\text{Rate} = \text{\\textdollar}0.50/\text{minute}. Average monthly usage is 100 minutes100\text{ minutes}, yielding a total bill of Bill=$40+($0.50×100)=$90\text{Bill} = \text{\textdollar}40 + (\text{\textdollar}0.50 \times 100) = \text{\textdollar}90.

    • Average Cost: Average Cost=$90100=$0.90/minute\text{Average Cost} = \frac{\text{\textdollar}90}{100} = \text{\textdollar}0.90/\text{minute}.

    • Decision: Evaluating a 10-minute10\text{-minute} call with a benefit valued at $7.00\text{\textdollar}7.00:

    • Incorrect Average Cost Analysis: 10 minutes×$0.90=$9.00 cost>$7.00 benefit10\text{ minutes} \times \text{\textdollar}0.90 = \text{\textdollar}9.00 \text{ cost} > \text{\textdollar}7.00 \text{ benefit} (reject call).

    • Correct Marginal Analysis: Marginal cost is 10 minutes×$0.50=$5.0010\text{ minutes} \times \text{\textdollar}0.50 = \text{\textdollar}5.00. Since $7.00 benefit>$5.00 marginal cost\text{\textdollar}7.00 \text{ benefit} > \text{\textdollar}5.00 \text{ marginal cost}, making the call maximizes net utility.

Cell phone marginal benefit
  • Example 2: Airline Standby Seats:

    • Flight Costs: A 200-seat200\text{-seat} plane costs $100,000\text{\textdollar}100,000 to fly across the US. Average cost per seat is $100,000200=$500\frac{\text{\textdollar}100,000}{200} = \text{\textdollar}500.

    • Standby Scenario: A plane is about to depart with 1010 empty seats. A standby passenger offers $300\text{\textdollar}300 for a ticket.

    • Marginal Analysis: The marginal cost of adding one passenger is merely the cost of the bag of peanuts and can of soda consumed. Because $300 marginal revenue>MC\text{\textdollar}300 \text{ marginal revenue} > MC, selling the ticket increases total airline profit and net social benefit.

  • Example 3: Water-Diamond Paradox:

    • Water is essential for human survival, yet cheap. Diamonds are non-essential, yet extremely expensive.

    • Explanation: Willingness to pay depends on the marginal benefit of an extra unit, which depends on existing abundance. Water is plentiful, so the marginal benefit of an additional cup is tiny. Diamonds are rare, making the marginal benefit of an additional unit very large.

Principle 4: People Respond to Incentives

  • Incentive Definition: Something (such as a prospect of a punishment or reward) that induces a person to act.

  • Price Incentives in Markets: Higher prices encourage consumers to decrease consumption (MB<MCMB < MC) and induce producers to increase production (MB>MCMB > MC).

  • Public Policy & Unintended Consequences: Policies that alter costs or benefits change human behavior, frequently yielding unintended side effects.

  • Case Study: Automobile Safety Laws (Ralph Nader & Sam Peltzman):

    • Policy: Congress mandated seat belts in all new cars following public concern raised by Ralph Nader's 19651965 book Unsafe at Any Speed.

    • Incentive Shift: Seat belts reduce the probability of injury or death from an accident, making accidents less costly.

    • Behavioral Response: Drivers respond as they would to improved road conditions—by driving faster and less carefully. This increases the total number of accidents.

    • Empirical Findings (Sam Peltzman, 1975): Safety laws resulted in fewer deaths per accident, but a higher total number of accidents. Net result: little change in driver deaths, but an increase in pedestrian deaths.

  • Case Study: Gasoline Prices (2005–20082005\text{--}2008):

    • Shock: Limited oil supply plus surging global demand (especially from China) pushed US gas prices from $2\text{\textdollar}2 to $4\text{\textdollar}4 per gallon.

    • Observed Behavioral Responses:

    • Shift toward small fuel-efficient cars and scooters; surge in bicycle sales and repair.

    • Increased ridership on public transit.

    • Increased demand for camels in Rajasthan, India, to replace expensive gas-guzzling tractors.

    • Order books filled for fuel-efficient aircraft (Boeing 737 and Airbus A320 up to 40%40\text{\%} cheaper to operate).

    • Real estate decisions adjusted: home purchases near Amtrak stations (e.g., Demetrius Stroud).

    • Education shifts: students opting for online courses to avoid commuting costs (e.g., Christy LaBadie at Northampton Community College).

    • Celebrities modifying behavior: Sean "Diddy" Combs flying commercial first-class rather than spending $200,000+\text{\textdollar}200,000+ on private jet flights.

Principles of Human Interaction and Market Coordination

Wall Street Journal Cartoon

Principle 5: Trade Can Make Everyone Better Off

  • International Trade Misconceptions: Trade between nations (e.g., US and China) is not a zero-sum sports competition with a winner and a loser. Trade makes both countries better off.

  • Family Analogy: Isolating a family from society requires growing its own food, making its own clothing, and building its own home. Specialization allows each individual/family to focus on activities they perform best (farming, sewing, construction).

  • Social Welfare Gains: Through trade, participants access a significantly broader variety of goods and services at substantially lower costs.

Principle 6: Markets Are Usually a Good Way to Organize Economic Activity

  • Central Planning Collapse: The demise of communist systems in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in the 1980s1980\text{s} demonstrated the systemic failure of central planning.

    • Central Planning Assumption: Government officials are best positioned to allocate scarce resources (determining what, how much, and who produces/consumes).

  • Market Economy: An economy that allocates resources through the decentralized decisions of many firms and households as they interact in markets for goods and services.

  • Adam Smith's Invisible Hand:

    • Published in his 17761776 treatise An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations.

    • Core Insight: Participants in a market economy are motivated by self-interest, but are guided by an "invisible hand" to promote overall social welfare.

Adam Smith Portrait
  • Quote: "It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest."

    • Price as the Mechanism: Prices adjust to reflect both the social value of a good to consumers and the social cost to producers. Unimpeded prices direct decentralized buyers and sellers toward outcomes that maximize total social welfare.

    • Distortionary Interference: When government prevents prices from adjusting naturally (taxes, price controls like rent control, or central planning), it prevents the invisible hand from coordinating economic activity, reducing aggregate well-being.

Principle 7: Governments Can Sometimes Improve Market Outcomes

  • Enforcing Legal Institutions & Property Rights: Markets require institutional rules to function. Property rights give individuals the ability to own and exercise control over scarce resources.

    • Farmers will not grow crops if they expect them to be stolen; restaurants will not serve food without assurance of payment; media companies will not produce content if illegal copying is unchecked. Courts and police enforce these rights.

  • Correcting Market Failure: A situation in which a market left on its own fails to allocate resources efficiently.

    • Causes of Market Failure:

    1. Externality: The uncompensated impact of one person's actions on the well-being of a bystander (e.g., pollution imposing uncompensated health costs).

    2. Market Power: The ability of a single economic actor (or small group) to unduly influence market prices (e.g., a single well owner in a town charging exorbitant prices for water).

  • Promoting Equality: Markets reward individuals according to their ability to produce things others are willing to pay for (e.g., professional basketball players earning more than professional chess players). Government intervention via income taxes and welfare transfers aims to achieve a more equitable distribution of well-being.

Principles of Economy-Wide Dynamics

Principle 8: A Country's Standard of Living Depends on Its Ability to Produce Goods and Services

  • Global Income Disparities (20112011 Data):

    • Average American income: $48,000\text{\textdollar}48,000

    • Average Mexican income: $9,000\text{\textdollar}9,000

    • Average Chinese income: $5,000\text{\textdollar}5,000

    • Average Nigerian income: $1,200\text{\textdollar}1,200

  • Life Quality Correlations: High average income directly correlates with superior nutrition, better healthcare, longer life expectancy, and higher ownership of consumer durables (cars, TVs).

  • Historical Growth in the United States: Real income grows at approximately 2%2\text{\%} per year, doubling average real income every 35 years35\text{ years}. U.S. average real income has increased approximately eightfold over the past century.

  • Primary Determinant: Productivity—the quantity of goods and services produced from each unit of labor input.

  • Policy Implication: To raise living standards, public policy must boost productivity by ensuring workers are well educated, equipped with superior tools/capital, and given access to advanced technology.

  • In The News: Robert D. McTeer, Jr. on Economic Training:

    • The Broken Window Fallacy: A teenager breaks a baker's window. The crowd argues that the baker hiring a repairman creates an economic stimulus. The fallacy overlooks that the baker would otherwise have purchased a new suit; spending was merely diverted, not created.

    • The Job-Counting Fallacy: Progress relies on job destruction in low-productivity sectors. Agricultural employment dropped from 90%90\text{\%} of the U.S. population to 3%3\text{\%}, freeing labor to become technology specialists, educators, and healthcare workers.

Principle 9: Prices Rise When the Government Prints Too Much Money

  • Inflation Definition: An increase in the overall level of prices in the economy.

  • Historical Hyperinflation: In Germany (January 19211921 to November 19221922), a daily newspaper's price rose from 0.30 marks0.30\text{ marks} to 70,000,000 marks70,000,000\text{ marks} as the quantity of money tripled monthly.

  • U.S. Experience: The high inflation of the 1970s1970\text{s} (where prices more than doubled, prompting President Gerald Ford to call inflation "public enemy number one") was driven by rapid growth in the money supply. Low inflation in the 2000s2000\text{s} (\text{\textapprox} 2.5\text{\%} per year) corresponds to slow monetary growth.

  • Primary Cause: Growth in the quantity of money. When the state creates large quantities of currency, the value of money falls.

Principle 10: Society Faces a Short-Run Trade-off between Inflation and Unemployment

  • Short-Run Mechanism of Monetary Injections:

    1. Increasing the quantity of money stimulates the aggregate level of spending, boosting demand for goods and services.

    2. Higher demand induces firms to raise prices over time, but in the short run encourages them to hire more workers and expand output.

    3. Increased hiring reduces unemployment.

  • Short-Run Trade-off: Over a horizon of one or two years, economic policies push inflation and unemployment in opposite directions.

  • Business Cycle: Irregular and largely unpredictable fluctuations in economic activity, measured by the production of goods and services or employment levels.

  • Policy Application (Obama Administration, 2008–20092008\text{--}2009): During the severe economic downturn caused by financial system failures, President Barack Obama enacted a stimulus package of tax cuts and increased government spending, while the Federal Reserve expanded the money supply. This short-run intervention aimed to reduce unemployment, balancing short-term relief against long-term inflation risks.

Comprehensive Summary of the Ten Principles of Economics

Category

Principle Number & Statement

Core Mechanism / Focus

How People Make Decisions

Principle 1: People Face Trade-offs

Choices require trading off one goal for another (e.g., Efficiency vs. Equality).


Principle 2: The Cost of Something Is What You Give Up to Get It

Opportunity cost includes all explicit and implicit forgone alternatives.


Principle 3: Rational People Think at the Margin

Rational actors choose where MB=MCMB = MC for incremental adjustments.


Principle 4: People Respond to Incentives

Behavior changes predictably when marginal costs or benefits change.

How People Interact

Principle 5: Trade Can Make Everyone Better Off

Specialization and exchange increase the overall size of the economic pie.


Principle 6: Markets Are Usually a Good Way to Organize Economic Activity

The "invisible hand" uses price signals to coordinate decentralized decisions.


Principle 7: Governments Can Sometimes Improve Market Outcomes

Interventions can enforce property rights or correct market failures (externalities, market power).

How the Economy Works as a Whole

Principle 8: A Country's Standard of Living Depends on Its Ability to Produce Goods and Services

Productivity (output per labor unit\text{output per labor unit}) is the primary driver of real living standards.


Principle 9: Prices Rise When the Government Prints Too Much Money

Excessive money creation degrades currency value, causing inflation.


Principle 10: Society Faces a Short-Run Trade-off between Inflation and Unemployment

Monetary expansion boosts short-run spending/hiring, temporarily lowering unemployment.

Review Questions, Assessment Solutions, and Applications

Key Concepts Defined

  • Scarcity: The limited nature of society's resources.

  • Economics: The study of how society manages its scarce resources.

  • Efficiency: The property of society getting the maximum benefits from its scarce resources.

  • Equality: The property of distributing economic prosperity uniformly among the members of society.

  • Opportunity Cost: Whatever must be given up to obtain some item.

  • Rational People: People who systematically and purposefully do the best they can to achieve their objectives.

  • Marginal Change: A small incremental adjustment to an existing plan of action.

  • Incentive: Something that induces a person to act.

  • Market Economy: An economy that allocates resources through the decentralized decisions of many firms and households as they interact in markets for goods and services.

  • Property Rights: The ability of an individual to own and exercise control over scarce resources.

  • Market Failure: A situation in which a market left on its own fails to allocate resources efficiently.

  • Externality: The impact of one person's actions on the well-being of a bystander.

  • Market Power: The ability of a single economic actor (or small group of actors) to have a substantial influence on market prices.

  • Productivity: The quantity of goods and services produced from each unit of labor input.

  • Inflation: An increase in the overall level of prices in the economy.

  • Business Cycle: Fluctuations in economic activity, such as employment and production.

Solutions to Chapter 1 Review Questions

  1. Examples of Personal Trade-offs:

    • Allocating time between studying for an economics exam vs. working an hourly job.

    • Allocating monthly income between purchasing healthy groceries vs. saving for college tuition.

    • Choosing between spending time volunteering at a local clinic vs. resting for personal mental health.

  2. Opportunity Cost of a Disney World Vacation:

    • Monetary outlays: plane tickets, hotel rooms, park admission tickets, restaurant meals (minus ordinary food costs).

    • Non-monetary outlays: forgone wages from taking time off work, or lost study time that could yield higher future grades/income.

  3. Marginal Benefit of a Glass of Water:

    • Although water is necessary for life, the marginal benefit of an extra glass is small because water is abundant for most individuals in developed nations. The marginal benefit depends on current consumption levels.

  4. Why Policymakers Consider Incentives:

    • Policy interventions alter the marginal costs and marginal benefits facing private actors. Failing to account for incentive changes leads to unintended consequences (such as increased auto accidents from mandatory seat belt laws).

  5. Why International Trade Is Not Zero-Sum:

    • Trade allows nations to specialize in activities where they have a comparative advantage, expanding total output and allowing all trading partners to consume a larger quantity and variety of goods.

  6. The Function of the Invisible Hand:

    • The invisible hand uses market prices to coordinate decentralized self-interested decisions of buyers and sellers, directing resources toward outcomes that maximize total social welfare.

  7. Causes of Market Failure:

    • Externalities: Uncompensated impact on a bystander (e.g., industrial pollution ruining river water for local fishermen).

    • Market Power: Undue influence over market price by a single firm/actor (e.g., a single cable television provider in a municipality).

  8. Importance of Productivity:

    • Productivity is the fundamental determinant of real income growth and living standards. Higher output per worker per hour generates greater aggregate wealth and consumption.

  9. Definition and Cause of Inflation:

    • Inflation is the sustained increase in the overall price level of an economy. It is primarily caused by excessive growth in the quantity of money printed by the central bank/government.

  10. Short-Run Relationship between Inflation and Unemployment:

    • In the short run (1–2 years), policies that increase aggregate demand raise prices (inflation) while encouraging higher production and hiring, thereby lowering unemployment.

Quick Check Multiple Choice Solutions

  1. Answer: a. Economics is best defined as the study of how society manages its scarce resources.

  2. Answer: c. Your opportunity cost of going to a movie is the total cash expenditure needed to go to the movie plus the value of your time.

  3. Answer: b. A marginal change is one that incrementally alters an existing plan.

  4. Answer: b. Adam Smith's "invisible hand" refers to the ability of free markets to reach desirable outcomes, despite the self-interest of market participants.

  5. Answer: d. Governments may intervene in a market economy in order to protect property rights, correct a market failure due to externalities, and achieve a more equal distribution of income.

  6. Answer: a. If a nation has high and persistent inflation, the most likely explanation is the central bank creating excessive amounts of money.

Solutions to Chapter 1 Problems and Applications

  1. Trade-offs Analysis:

    • a. Family buying a car: Money spent on a car cannot be used for home repairs, college savings, or vacations.

    • b. Congress member on national parks: Public funds spent on national parks cannot be allocated to national defense or healthcare programs.

    • c. Company president opening a factory: Capital invested in a new factory cannot be used to upgrade existing technology or pay dividends to shareholders.

    • d. Professor preparing for class: Time spent preparing for class cannot be spent conducting research or grading papers.

    • e. College graduate deciding on grad school: Time and money spent in graduate school mean forgoing four years of full-time employment wages and job experience.

  2. Comparing Psychological Benefits to Monetary Costs:

    • Convert the psychological benefit into its monetary equivalent by determining the maximum amount of money you would be willing to pay for that vacation experience. If your willingness to pay exceeds the total financial outlays plus forgone wages, the vacation maximizes your net utility.

  3. True Cost of Skiing:

    • Scenario A (Planning to work): Cost = Out-of-pocket expenses (ski lift ticket, equipment rental) + forgone wages from your part-time job.

    • Scenario B (Planning to study at the library): Cost = Out-of-pocket expenses + the value of the lost study time (measured by potential lower grades or lost learning).

  4. Opportunity Cost of Spending textdollar100\text{\\textdollar}100 Today:

    • The opportunity cost of spending $100\text{\textdollar}100 today is forgoing the $105\text{\textdollar}105 ($100×1.05\text{\textdollar}100 \times 1.05) you would have in one year by depositing the money in a bank account earning 5%5\text{\%} interest.

  5. Product Development Decision:

    • Existing Investment: $5 million\text{\textdollar}5\text{ million} already spent is a sunk cost and must be ignored.

    • Marginal Analysis: Remaining cost to complete = $1 million\text{\textdollar}1\text{ million}. Expected sales = $3 million\text{\textdollar}3\text{ million}.

    • Decision: Go ahead with development because $3 million marginal revenue>$1 million marginal cost\text{\textdollar}3\text{ million marginal revenue} > \text{\textdollar}1\text{ million marginal cost}, yielding a net marginal profit of $2 million\text{\textdollar}2\text{ million}. The maximum the company should pay to complete development is $3 million\text{\textdollar}3\text{ million}.

  6. Social Security Incentives:

    • a. Incentive to save while working: Reduced future Social Security benefits for those with higher wealth/earnings reduces the incentive for workers to save independently for retirement.

    • b. Incentive to work past age 65: Reducing Social Security benefits when an individual earns income creates an effective marginal tax on labor, discouraging elderly individuals from continuing to work.

  7. Welfare Reform Incentives:

    • a. Work incentives: Limiting benefits to two years increases the opportunity cost of remaining unemployed, strongly incentivizing recipients to search for work.

    • b. Equality vs. Efficiency: The two-year limit improves efficiency by restoring work incentives and expanding output, but may reduce equality by lowering the safety net for those unable to secure employment.

  8. Government Activity Motivations:

    • a. Regulating cable TV prices: Efficiency (correcting market power/monopoly failure).

    • b. Providing food vouchers to poor: Equality.

    • c. Prohibiting smoking in public places: Efficiency (correcting negative health externalities imposed on bystanders).

    • d. Breaking up Standard Oil: Efficiency (correcting market power/monopoly failure).

    • e. Imposing higher personal income taxes on high earners: Equality.

    • f. Instituting drunk driving laws: Efficiency (correcting severe negative safety externalities).

  9. Statements Evaluated for Equality and Efficiency:

    • a. "Universal Healthcare Guarantee":

      • Equality: High (ensures equal access to medical well-being).

      • Efficiency: Low (requires high taxation and distorts incentives for both patients and healthcare providers, creating deadweight loss).

    • b. "Unending Unemployment Benefits":

      • Equality: High (protects laid-off workers' living standards).

      • Efficiency: Low (reduces the marginal benefit of searching for a new job, prolonging unemployment and reducing total national output).

  10. Historical Standard of Living Changes:

    • Modern living standards are vastly higher than two generations ago due to dramatic increases in labor productivity brought on by technological progress, superior capital equipment, and higher educational attainment.

  11. Increased Savings and Productivity Growth:

    • Increased national savings provides banks with capital to lend to businesses for constructing new factories and purchasing advanced machinery. This capital accumulation raises the marginal product of labor (productivity).

    • Beneficiaries: Workers earn higher real wages, business owners earn higher returns, and consumers enjoy cheaper goods.

    • Free Lunch? No, society sacrifices current consumption to save and invest for future benefits.

  12. The Inflation Tax:

    • When the government prints currency to cover expenditures, it expands the money supply and drives up the price level. The "tax" falls on everyone who holds money, as the purchasing power of their cash holdings diminishes.