Notes on Democracy 1960-1968
Common Threads: Prosperity and Activism
- How the prosperity of the 1950s shaped the activism of the 1960s is a central question.
- The impact of the Civil Rights Movement on other groups.
- Definitions of democracy by the New Liberalism, New Conservatism, and the New Left.
- The influence of anti-communism on U.S. foreign policy.
- How desires for rights and concerns about limited resources would continue to shape American society after the 1960s.
The ANT Four and the Lunch Counter
- February 1, 1960: Franklin McCain and Joseph McNeil sat at a Woolworth's lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina, and asked for service.
- Ezel Blair and David Richmond joined them in their protest against segregation.
- The students faced insults, but also some encouragement from white customers.
- A policeman present was unsure how to react, highlighting the challenge to white authority.
- McCain noted the policeman's defenselessness, emphasizing the disruption caused by their actions.
- The students stayed until closing time, denied service but gaining a sense of empowerment.
- They realized they had power to challenge injustice through nonviolent protest.
Discovery of Power
- The actions of the ANT Four were inspired by Christianity and Mahatma Gandhi's activism.
- Blair described the sit-in as sitting at the "table of democracy."
- The initial protest inspired more students to join, testing the power of ordinary people.
- The story of the ANT Four reflected the broader experiences of the country in the 1960s.
- People sought to address problems like consumerism, civil rights, and the Cold War.
- A new form of liberalism emerged, aiming to confront communism abroad and reform life at home.
New Approaches to Power
- The discontents at the end of the 1950s led to new ideas and strategies in the 1960s.
- Various groups, especially poor groups, became energized.
- Civil rights activists, new liberals, new conservatives, and the new left proposed different solutions to domestic and international issues.
- Young people played a significant role in these movements, with differing views on power and democracy.
Grassroots Activism for Civil Rights
- The ANT Four were part of a new generation impatient with the slow pace of desegregation mandated by the Supreme Court in Brown v. Board of Education.
- They moved beyond court cases and boycotts to new tactics.
- The Greensboro protests led to sit-ins at lunch counters by hundreds of students.
- Woolworths and other stores eventually agreed to serve African Americans.
- The Greensboro sit-in inspired civil rights activism in other communities and led to the formation of the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC).
- Wait-ins at beaches, kneel-ins at churches, and paint-ins at art galleries occurred.
- These demonstrations opened facilities to black patrons and energized the civil rights movement.
The New Liberalism
- After being out of power in the 1950s, liberals offered a new agenda.
- This agenda addressed the civil rights movement, consumerism, and the Cold War.
- Faith in economic growth was a key element.
- Liberals believed the U.S. needed to expand its economy to meet domestic and international challenges.
- The federal government could manipulate the budget to ensure full employment, consumer demand, and a rising GNP.
- Liberals emphasized the quality of life and the broader public interest.
- The federal government should address poverty, racial inequality, pollution, housing, education, and communism.
- Liberals favored a more powerful federal government, similar to the New Deal and Fair Deal eras.
- The New Deal focused on restoring prosperity during the Great Depression, while the new liberals took prosperity for granted.
- Old liberals feared big business and class conflict, while new liberals saw racial divisions and civil rights as the greatest domestic problems.
The New Conservatism
- Conservatives differed with liberals on the role of government, believing it was already too big.
- They had been out of power for a while; Herbert Hoover's failure during the Great Depression discredited minimalist government, and Hitler's aggression undermined isolationism.
- Conservative ideas began to resurge in the 1950s.
- William F. Buckley's "God and Man at Yale" (1951) criticized liberalism and denial of individualism.
- Russell Kirk's "The Conservative Mind" (1953) argued for a living conservative tradition in America.
- Buckley and Kirk founded the National Review in 1955 to promote conservative ideas, especially anticommunism.
- Senator Barry Goldwater of Arizona was a leading conservative political figure.
- Goldwater advocated for individual freedom, opposed federal power, and took an aggressive stance against communism.
- Young Americans for Freedom gathered in 1960 to adopt the Sharon Statement, calling for government to protect individual liberty by preserving economic freedom and maintaining a strong national defense.
The New Left
- Another young group, inspired by civil rights activism and dissatisfied with campus life, rejected both conservatism and liberalism.
- Students felt oppressed by rules and regulations on campuses.
- Female students faced particularly strict rules, including curfews.
- The New Left was a radical movement aiming to create a more democratic nation.
- Students for a Democratic Society (SDS) emerged in 1960, seeking radical alternatives to society.
- The Port Huron Statement (1962) argued that American society denied people real choice and power.
- SDS advocated for participatory democracy.
- SDS did not rely on the old left but believed students would lead the way by fighting for control of their schools.
- SDS membership increased significantly.
The Presidential Election of 1960
- The election offered a choice between a liberal Democratic future and a moderate Republican status quo.
- Democratic nominee John F. Kennedy was open to the liberal agenda and optimistic.
- Kennedy spoke of a "new frontier" with unknown opportunities and threats, calling for economic growth, slum rebuilding, poverty reduction, education improvement, and enhanced retirement.
- Republican opponent Richard Nixon favored balanced budgets, limited government, and the acceptance of New Deal programs.
- Nixon did not embrace the bold programs of the new liberalism or the strident anticommunism of the new conservatives.
- The election was very close; Kennedy won by fewer than 120,000 votes.
- Kennedy kept much of the Democratic New Deal coalition together.
- Voters turned to a Democrat influenced by liberal ideas and eager to explore the new frontier.
Map 26.1: The Presidential Election of 1960
- John F. Kennedy won 303 electoral votes (56.5%) and 34,226,731 popular votes (49.7%).
- Richard Nixon won 219 electoral votes (40.75%) and 34,108,157 popular votes (49.5%).
- Minor parties won 15 electoral votes (3%) and 501,643 popular votes (0.7%).
- 15 electoral votes went to segregationist Democrat Harry F. Byrd.