Art History Comprehensive Study Guide to Modernisms: Art, Design, and Ideology (1750–1960)
Defining Modernism and Modernity
Periodization and Chronological Boundaries:
Richard Brettell: Defines the modern period as 1851–1929.
Marilyn Stokstad & Michael Cothren: Periodize modern art as 1900–1945.
AUArts Curricular Standard: Defines the modern period as 1850–1950.
Sam Hunter, John Jacobus, and Daniel Wheeler: Debate potential start dates of 1750, 1855, 1863, and 1874, ultimately placing the formal origin in 1886.
General Historical Epochs:
Early Modern: c. 1450 – 1750s
Modern: c. 1848 – 1960
Postmodern: c. late 1960s – 1990s
Contemporary: 1990s – present

The Concept of Modernity:
Theoretical Definition: Jonathan Harris conceptualizes Modernism as a "theoretical and critical term within the cluster of concepts and themes that dominates discussion of the socio-historical place of art since the mid-nineteenth century."
Socio-Economic Foundations: Modernity is characterized by three core societal conditions:
Increasing Urbanization: Concentration of populations into major metropolitan centers.
Growing Industrialization: Shift toward mechanical production and automated industry.
Global Trade of Commodities: Interconnected international supply chains and consumer goods distribution.

Defining Characteristics of Modernism:
Reactivity to Current Events: Artistic production directly engages contemporary political, economic, and social phenomena.
Fragmentation of Styles and Genres: Breaking away from unified academic conventions into diverse, competing movements (e.g., Realism, Expressionism, Dada, Surrealism, Art Nouveau, International Style).
Focus on New Technologies and Techniques: Integration of industrial materials and synthetic processes (e.g., Atsuko Tanaka's Electric Dress, 1956; Wassily Kandinsky's abstract oil Black Lines, 1913).
Mobilization and Trade of Images: Rapid, global exchange and mass dissemination of visual culture.
Redefinition of the Artist: Re-conceptualizing the artist's role both as an individual creator and an active social agent.
Critical Attitude Toward the Past: Systematic rejection, subversion, or transformation of historical traditions.
Spatial and Institutional Shifts:
Evolution of the display context: From the dense, vertical hanging system of the 18th-century Salon (e.g., Pietro Antonio Martini, Salon du Louvre, c. 1785) to the neutral, isolated White Cube (e.g., Kazuyo Sejima and Ryue Nishizawa, New Museum of Contemporary Art, 2007) to the immersive digital/video Black Box.
Stylistic Oscillation: Ornament and Anti-Ornament:
The trajectory of modern design swings between austere functionalism and decorative historicism:
Minimalist Modernism: Ludwig Mies van der Rohe's Lake Shore Drive Apartments (1948–1951), emphasizing structural steel cages and unadorned glass.
Postmodern Historicism: Charles Willard Moore's Piazza d'Italia (1978–1979), reintroducing ornamentation, historicist arches, and neon illumination.
Harlem Renaissance and Art Deco
Historical Overview and Aesthetic Principles:
Emerging in 1917 and continuing into the late 1930s, the Harlem Renaissance was a vital intellectual, social, and artistic movement among Black American creators.
Shared Attitudes and Goals:
Pride in Black life and cultural identity.
Direct critique and highlighting of institutional racism and social prejudice.
Active engagement with the conditions of modern urban existence.
Assertion of artistic expression as a primary vehicle for freedom and self-determination.
Augusta Savage:
Sculptor and educator who served as a central figure in the movement.
Gamin (1929, painted plaster): A bust depicting her young nephew. Its success earned her a scholarship to study in Paris, where she exhibited at the Salon d'Automne. Modernist qualities include:
Representation of an everyday, living individual rather than a wealthy patron, political figure, or allegorical deity.
Roughly textured, hand-modeled treatment of the cap and shirt, explicitly preserving the tactile presence of the sculptor's hand.

* *Lift Every Voice and Sing / The Harp* (1939): Commissioned for the 1939 New York World's Fair to symbolize Black musical heritage. Named after James Weldon Johnson and J. Rosamond Johnson's hymn (referred to as the African American national anthem). Renamed *Harp* by fair commissioners despite Savage's objections. The original monumental plaster was destroyed after the exposition, though small souvenir bronze/plaster casts survive.
Aaron Douglas:
Synthesized European avant-garde styles (Cubism, Art Deco) with ancestral African visual motifs.
Drew design inspiration from West African masks and sculptures (Senegal, Benin, Congo) as well as the 1922 discovery of King Tutankhamun's tomb in Egypt by Howard Carter and Harry Burton.
Into Bondage (1936, oil on canvas): Depicts shackled Africans marching toward slave ships on the horizon. A lone woman on the left raises her bound hands to direct the viewer's gaze; a central male figure pauses on a slave block to look toward a ray of light emanating from the North Star. Concentric translucent circles radiate outward, visually representing sound and African/African American song.
The Judgement Day (1939, oil on tempered hardboard): Reinterprets his earlier illustration for James Weldon Johnson's book of poetry, God's Trombones. Integrates Art Deco geometric angularity, diamond motifs, and Cubist planar fragmentation to depict Black spiritual and lived experience.
Richard Bruce Nugent and FIRE!!:
Writer and visual artist who challenged normative social and sexual conventions within Harlem.
Co-founded the radical short-lived literary journal FIRE!! Devoted to Younger Negro Artists (November 1926) alongside Aaron Douglas (who designed the cover illustration), Langston Hughes, Zora Neale Hurston, and Wallace Thurman.
FIRE!! content featured avant-garde prose, such as Nugent's short story Cordelia the Crude (exploring youth and sexuality around the Roosevelt Motion Picture Theatre on Seventh Avenue near 145th Street) and Gwendolyn Bennett's Wedding Day (focusing on Paul Watson, a Black former prize-fighter turned banjo player in Montmartre, Paris).

* *Aesthetic Influences*: Nugent drew heavily from late 19th-century Aestheticism and Decadence, specifically Oscar Wilde and Aubrey Beardsley (e.g., Beardsley's 1894 illustrations for *Salomé*). Nugent's *Salome Dancing* (c. 1925–1930, ink over graphite) adapts Beardsley's sinuous, fluid linework to depict Black figures in powerful, sensual poses.
Meta Vaux Warrick Fuller and Ethiopia:
Biographical & Training Context: Born in Philadelphia (1877) to a prosperous middle-class family. Trained at the Pennsylvania Museum and School of Industrial Arts (PMSIA), then studied in Paris (1899–1902) at the Académie Colarossi. Mentored directly by Auguste Rodin at his Villa des Brillants studio, adopting his impressionistic, expressive surface modeling.
Commission for the America's Making Exposition (1921): Commissioned by James Weldon Johnson and W.E.B. Du Bois for the "Americans of Negro Lineage" section at the 71st Regiment Armory in New York City.
Iconography and Form of Ethiopia (1921, painted plaster, 67" high):
Depicts an allegorical Black woman emerging from mummy wrappings.
Her right hand rests on her chest holding the edge of her linen shroud; her left arm extends outward away from her encased legs; her head wears the nemes (Egyptian royal headdress).
Features explicit Black physiognomy (full lips, broad nose, high cheekbones), directly countering the Anglicized features typical of earlier 19th-century neoclassical sculptures.
Draws visual and historical references from the 25th Dynasty Kushite ("Negro") Kings of Egypt (712–664 BCE) and contemporary archaeological excavations at Meroë and Nuri (reported by George Reisner and Maud Cuney Hare in The Crisis).

* *Comparative Works*: Fuller was aware of earlier 19th-century representations of Africa/Ethiopia, including Daniel Chester French's colossal *Africa* (1903–1907, U.S. Custom House, NYC) and Anne Whitney's destroyed plaster *Ethiopia* (1863–1864, inscribed with Psalm 68:31: "And Ethiopia shall lift up her hands unto God"). Fuller sought to replace European romanticizing with an authentic symbol of self-emancipation.
The America's Making Exposition of 1921:
Organized by white Progressive social reformers (General Director John Daniels; Exhibits Director Charles Storey) to demonstrate the contributions of 33 immigrant groups under the banner E Pluribus Unum.
Racial Dynamics: African Americans were included as "honorary immigrants"—a problematic framing that ignored the historical trauma of forced enslavement and citizenship denials. Black leaders (Du Bois, Johnson, Eugene Kinckle Jones) utilized the platform to project Black cultural achievement, labor, and patriotism.
The Black Pavilion and Pageant:
The booth featured displays on Labor, Exploration, Self-Supporting Womanhood, Democracy, National Defense, Literature, and Music, anchored by a central wood-painted pyramid and Fuller's Ethiopia.
Du Bois staged the historical music pageant The Seven Gifts of Ethiopia to America on "Negro Day" (November 11, 1921), featuring explorer Matthew Henson and compositions by Samuel Coleridge-Taylor (Bamboula), Harry Burleigh, and J. Rosamond Johnson.
Stylistic Movements: Rococo versus Neoclassicism
The Rococo Style (c. 1730–1770):
Emerging in early 18th-century France (genre pittoresque), Rococo reflected the refined tastes of the French aristocracy.

* *Five Key Qualities of Rococo*:
1. **Organic Imagery and Forms**: Botanical tendrils, floral vines, and naturalistic motifs integrated into textiles and interiors (e.g., 1740s silk court dresses/mantuas).
2. **Elaborate, Handmade Craftsmanship**: Intricate carving, gilding, and decorative metalwork (e.g., Thomas Johnson's carved gilt-pine candlestands, 1756–1760; Derby and Chelsea porcelain vessels).
3. **Asymmetry**: Deliberate abandonment of classical bilateral symmetry in favor of dynamic visual weight distribution.
4. **S-Scrolls and C-Scrolls**: Curvilinear, undulating structural and decorative lines.
5. **Rocaille**: Shell-like, pebble, and coral shapes integrated into architectural moldings, mirrors, and mantelpieces.

* *Key Figures & Works*:
* *Antoine Watteau*: Pioneer of the *fête galante* genre (e.g., *Les Fêtes Venitiennes*, c. 1718–1719), characterized by poetic, shimmering fabric depictions and fleeting theatrical romance.
* *Jean-François de Troy*: *A Reading from Molière* (c. 1728), documenting intimate domestic Rococo interiors and high-fashion attire.
* *Germain Boffrand*: Designed the *Salon de la Princesse* at the Hôtel de Soubise, Paris (c. 1735–1740), featuring oval spatial planning, integrated mirrors, and ceiling relief spandrels painted by Charles-Joseph Natoire.
* *Jean-Siméon Chardin*: Genre painter praised by Denis Diderot for his tactile realism, subtle light play, and middle-class moral compositions (e.g., *The Governess*, 1739).
Neoclassicism (c. 1750s–1960):
A conscious reaction against the perceived frivolity and sensual excess of Rococo, driven by Enlightenment rationality and archaeological discoveries at Herculaneum and Pompeii.
Key Qualities of Neoclassicism:
Classical Inspiration: Re-activation of ancient Greek and Roman principles, proportions, and poses (such as contrapposto, exemplified by Roman marble copies of Greek originals like Hermes After Naukydes).
Contemporary Subject Matter: Depicting living or recent historical figures rather than purely mythological subjects.
Naturalism over Idealization: Combining ideal proportion with realistic individual likenesses.
Moral Seriousness: Promoting civic virtue, patriotism, and rational restraint.
Key Figures & Works:
Johann Joachim Winckelmann: Art theorist whose treatise Thoughts on the Imitation of Greek Works in Painting and Sculpture (1755) asserted that the only way for modern artists to become great was to imitate ancient Greek purity.
Jean-Antoine Houdon: Executed expressive portrait busts of Enlightenment figures (e.g., Denis Diderot, 1773) and the marble statue of George Washington (1785–1796, Virginia State Capitol). At Washington's insistence, Houdon depicted him in modern military dress rather than a classical Roman toga, positioning him as a modern Cincinnatus.
Benjamin West: The Death of General Wolfe (1770), which revolutionized history painting by rendering British soldiers in contemporary military uniforms rather than classical drapery, retaining classical compositional weight (echoing a Pietà).
Thomas Jefferson: Designed the Virginia State Capitol in collaboration with Charles-Louis Clérisseau, directly modeling it on the ancient Roman temple in Nîmes, the Maison Carrée.

Architectural Principles of the International Style
First Principle: Architecture as Volume:
Structural Transformation: Modern construction replaces load-bearing masonry walls with an internal skeleton frame (cage) of structural steel or reinforced concrete columns.
Wall as Screen: Outer walls no longer support weight; they function as light exterior screens or protective skins (analogous to a boat hull or an umbrella canopy).
Open Box Symbolism: The primary architectural symbol shifts from the dense, solid brick block to the hollow, enclosed volume of an open box.
Cantilevering & Floor Plans: The load-bearing skeleton allows extreme floor-plan flexibility, thin structural piers, and cantilevered facades projecting beyond internal supports.
Critique of American Skyscrapers: Early 20th-century American skyscrapers frequently obscured their non-supporting curtain walls under heavy, pseudo-masonry cladding and decorative setbacks required by zoning laws. Buildings like Raymond Hood's McGraw-Hill Building (1931) and Daily News Building (1930) represent transitional steps toward fully expressing the internal steel cage.
Second Principle: Regularity:
Structural Rhythm: Skeleton frames rely on regularly spaced, equidistant columns to distribute structural loads evenly, creating an underlying structural cadence.
Standardization: Modern industrial fabrication requires standardized, mass-produced architectural components.
Aesthetic Organization: Good modern design visually reinforces this structural regularity rather than forcing artificial, classical symmetry. Regularity is relative; variations are introduced to accommodate distinct functional demands (e.g., differing floor requirements in hotels vs. office lofts).
Third Principle: Avoidance of Applied Decoration:
Rejection of Ornament: Applied historical ornament is rejected as anachronistic and incompatible with industrial manufacturing processes.
Technical Detail as Decoration: Visual interest is generated purely through clean structural details, functional fittings, material texture, and proportional harmony.
Fenestration & Wall Capping: Unadorned window frames, clean wall edges (eliminating traditional heavy roof cornices), and refined railings/parapets provide the necessary detail, highlighting the sleek planes that define architectural volume.
Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood and the Aesthetic Movement
Foundations of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood (1848):
Founded by William Holman Hunt, John Everett Millais, and Dante Gabriel Rossetti as an anti-academic, anti-modern movement.
Rejected the stylized, formulaic compositional rules derived from Raphael and the High Renaissance, advocating a return to the direct observation of nature, vibrant color, and Quattrocento clarity.
Key Pre-Raphaelite Works and Symbolic Naturalism:
William Holman Hunt: The Awakening Conscience (1853, oil on canvas), an allegorical narrative addressing contemporary morality, adultery, and social redemption through meticulous interior detail.
Sir John Everett Millais:
Ophelia (1851–1852, oil on canvas): Painted directly outdoors (en plein air) along the Hogsmill River in Surrey, England. Elizabeth Siddal modeled for Ophelia in a heated bath of water. Plants are rendered with rigorous botanical fidelity, carrying complex symbolic meanings:
Willow, Nettle, Daisy: Associated with abandoned love, pain, and innocence.
Violets (woven around her neck): Symbolize chastity.
Poppies: Symbolize death.
Portrait of John Ruskin (1853–1854): Painted against the gushing rocks of Glenfinlas in Scotland, capturing Ruskin's mandate for artists to "go to Nature in all singleness of heart."
Dante Gabriel Rossetti: La Pia de' Tolomei (1868–1880), depicting Dante's character falsely accused of infidelity, modeled by Jane Burden (Janey Morris, wife of William Morris).
Sir Edward Burne-Jones and the Aesthetic Movement:
In contrast to Hunt's moralizing narratives, Burne-Jones embraced the principles of the Aesthetic Movement ("art for art's sake"), focusing on beauty, lyrical mood, and decorative harmony.
The Golden Stairs (c. 1876): Depicts a repetitive, rhythmic procession of ethereal female figures descending a staircase holding musical instruments.

* *Spatial Construction*: Employs flattened spatial planes and shallow perspective, explicitly borrowing from pre-1520 Early Renaissance masters like Piero della Francesca (*The Flagellation of Christ*, 1450s).
Gothic Revival and the Arts and Crafts Movement
Origins and Architectural Logic of the Gothic:
Medieval Foundations: Early Gothic (e.g., Notre-Dame de Paris, begun c. 1163) transitioned into High Gothic (e.g., Chartres Cathedral, c. 1194–1220).
Structural Innovation: Replaced massive, solid load-bearing masonry walls with a delicate linear stone skeleton supported by pointed arches, flying buttresses, delicate tracery, crockets, and expansive rose windows that flooded interior spaces with colored light.

Gothic Revival:
Re-evaluating medieval architecture as a noble visual system. Early British manifestations include Batty Langley's treatise Gothic Architecture, Improved by Rules and Proportions (1740) and Horace Walpole's country estate Strawberry Hill (c. 1749, Twickenham).

The Arts and Crafts Movement:
Emerging in late 19th-century Britain as an anti-industrial design crusade, countering machine mass-production and the degradation of human labor.
John Ruskin's Theoretical Foundation: In The Stones of Venice (1851–1853) and Modern Painters, Ruskin idealized the medieval artisan, arguing that Gothic architecture fostered joy, creative freedom, and moral integrity among workers.
William Morris (1834–1896):
Famous Dictum: "Have nothing in your houses that you do not know to be useful or believe to be beautiful."
Three Core Principles:
Truth to Materials: Preserving and highlighting the intrinsic qualities of wood, wool, metal, and glass.
Elevation of Gothic Art and Architecture: Adapting medieval flat repeat patterns, stained glass, and tapestry techniques.
Valorization of Handcraft: Re-establishing the direct connection between maker, object, and user to reform social relations.
Key Works & Projects:
Red House (1859, Bexleyheath): Designed with architect Philip Webb as an integrated medievalist family home; led to founding the design firm Morris, Marshall, Faulkner & Co. (1861; later Morris & Co.).
Textiles & Tapestries: Hand-block printed wallpapers and fabrics (Strawberry Thief, 1883; Honeysuckle, 1876; Lodden, 1883) and high-warp tapestries (The Woodpecker Tapestry, c. 1885), drawing visual inspiration from medieval tapestries like The Lady and the Unicorn.

* *Socialist Activism*: Founded the Hammersmith Socialist League (1884) and authored essays on labor reform (e.g., *The Revival of Handicraft*).
Canadian Arts and Crafts Practice:
Canadian metalworker Paul Beau (Montreal) applied Arts and Crafts principles using accessible metals (copper, brass) to highlight hand-hammered textures.

* Beau executed hand-forged wrought iron hinges, door pulls, and decorative metalwork for the rebuilt Canadian Parliament Buildings in Ottawa (1920), incorporating Celtic and Gothic tendril forms.
Design Reform, Colonialism, and Art Botany in Nineteenth-Century Britain
Imperial Politics and the British East India Company:
Corporate Colonialism: Formed by royal charter in 1600, the British East India Company (EIC) expanded from a commercial trading monopoly into an imperial ruling force across India (establishing bases in Madras, 1639; Bombay, 1661).
Opium Wars: EIC exploited Indian agricultural land to grow opium, forcing it into Chinese markets (resulting in the Anglo-Chinese Opium Wars of 1839–1842 and 1856–1860) to resolve trade imbalances caused by British demand for Chinese tea, silk, and porcelain.

* *Indian Rebellion of 1857–1859*: Widespread anti-colonial uprising triggered by economic exploitation, forced displacement of weavers, and military subjugation. Led to the dissolution of the EIC (1873), direct rule by the British Crown under the Government of India Act (1858), and Queen Victoria assuming the title Empress of India (1876).
The Government Schools of Design and Economic Botany:
Following an 1835 Parliamentary inquiry into why British manufactured goods lacked original design aesthetic compared to French products, the British government founded the Government School of Design (1837, housed at Somerset House; later the Royal College of Art).

* *Economic Botany at Kew Gardens*: Botanical science at the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew was deeply tied to British imperial expansion. Botanical illustrators (such as Sarah Drake) mapped plant species for industrial exploitation (rubber, tea, cotton, cinchona). Historian Lucile Brockway notes: "There is no way to draw the line between science, commerce and imperialism in the work of the Kew collectors."

The Great Exhibition of 1851 and the Valorization of Indian Design:
Held in Joseph Paxton's Crystal Palace in Hyde Park, London, the Great Exhibition of the Works of Industry of All Nations (1851) showcased international manufactures.

* *Assessment of Indian Manufactures*: British design reformers (Owen Jones, Richard Redgrave, Henry Cole) observed that Indian textiles, metalwork, and jewelry displayed a superior understanding of ornamentation compared to British industrial products.
* *Key Principles Exemplified by Indian Goods*:
* Flat, conventionalized surface decoration respecting the structural surface.
* Harmonious, non-illusionistic color distribution.
* Absence of vulgar, three-dimensional spatial trickery.


The Campaign Against "False Principles" in Design:
In 1853, the Museum of Ornamental Art staged the Exhibition of False Principles in Decoration ("Gallery of Horrors"), showcasing rejected commercial products.

* *Design Condemnations*:
* **False Principle**: 3D illusionistic naturalism on flat surfaces (e.g., carpets printed with realistic 3D flowers; wallpapers depicting realistic animals or architectural perspectives).
* **Satirized in Literature**: Charles Dickens satirizes this rigid reform dogma in *Hard Times* (1854), where Mr. Gradgrind and a government officer inform Sissy Jupe that walking on carpets with realistic flower patterns is logically impossible and forbidden.
* **False Applied Objects**: Gas jets shaped like convolvulus flowers (natural forms used for artificial mechanical functions).
Christopher Dresser and "Art Botany":
Scientific Design: Christopher Dresser (1834–1904) studied art botany at the Government School of Design and earned a doctorate from the University of Jena for his research on plant morphology and Johann Wolfgang von Goethe's concept of the Urpflanze (the archetypal generative plant form).


* *Dresser's Theoretical Axioms*:
* **Unity in Variety**: Expressing the underlying mathematical laws (spiral leaf distributions, geometric symmetry) unifying all plant species.
* **Adaptation to Purpose**: Designing everyday household objects with the same functional efficiency found in ecological systems.
* *Industrial Production*: Unlike William Morris, Dresser embraced machine fabrication, creating radically minimalist, highly functional metalwork (e.g., electroplated nickel silver toast racks for Hukin & Heath, c. 1880; geometric claret jugs; blown Clutha glass for James Couper & Sons).


Owen Jones and Modernist Pattern Theory:
Architect and designer Owen Jones published The Grammar of Ornament (1856), establishing fundamental geometric principles for decorative pattern design.

* Praised Islamic architectural ornamentation—specifically the **Alhambra** in Granada, Spain—and Indo-Islamic textiles as achieving perfect harmony between form, surface, and abstract geometry.
Textile Production: Handcraft versus Industrial Replication:
Kashmir Shawls: Traditional Indian shawls woven from fine pashmina goat hair using hand-manipulated bobbins (kani technique), requiring 18 months to 3 years to complete a single garment.
British Industrial Appropriations: British manufacturers in Paisley, Scotland used industrial Jacquard looms and roller-printing to mass-produce cheap imitations ("Paisley shawls"), undermining traditional Indian hand-weaving economies.



Anni Albers and the Mechanics of Weaving:
In On Weaving (1965), Bauhaus textile artist Anni Albers analyzed the fundamental structural logic of textile construction:
Plain Weave: The basic, un-elastic 1/1 interlacing of two perpendicular systems of threads (warp and weft) at right angles.
Twill Weave: Characterized by diagonal lines (twill lines) formed when weft threads float over multiple warp threads in a staggered progression.
Satin Weave: A complex arrangement of widely distributed, non-adjacent intersections (stitchers), producing a smooth, lustrous, unbroken surface sheen.