U
INTRODUCTION
The role of work in behavioral change among criminals is analyzed, questioning if employment serves as a turning point in the life course of offenders.
The study by Christopher Uggen published in the American Sociological Review investigates whether providing jobs leads to reduced criminal activities and recidivism rates.
RESEARCH OVERVIEW
Key Questions Addressed
Is work an effective turning point for criminals?
Does work lead to a decrease in criminal behavior and recidivism?
How does age interact with the effects of employment on crime rates?
Background Literature
Previous studies on work and crime have produced inconclusive results, largely due to selection bias and age-employment interactions.
The existing literature underlines that life-course transitions, such as marriage and employment, may have age-specific effects on crime.
METHODOLOGY
Event History Models
The study utilizes event history models to capture the dynamics of employment in relation to recidivism, focusing on:
- Eligibility for jobs
- Current participation in work programs
- Job assignment history
Participant Profile
The analysis was based on data from the National Supported Work Demonstration Project.
Participants included individuals with a history of incarceration, drug abuse, high unemployment, and a record of prior arrests.
FINDINGS
Age and Employment Relationship
Employment plays a significant role in reducing crime among older offenders (those aged 27 and above) but less so among younger offenders (teens and early twenties).
For older criminals, marginal employment opportunities result in lower self-reported rates of recidivism.
Age-specific effects indicate that younger offenders do not significantly benefit from job placements in the same way that older offenders do.
Major Empirical Findings
Age-Differentiated Effects
- Employment impacts on crime are age-graded, suggesting older offenders experience positive behavioral changes from employment, while younger offenders show negligible changes.Temporal Dynamics
- The effects of work on recidivism diminish over time.Causal Inferences
- Employment influences recidivism; however, whether employment merely correlates with reduced crime or causes it is still debated.
IMPLICATIONS FOR POLICY
Employment programs serve as a crucial policy tool for reducing recidivism among older offenders, indicating a potential pathway for rehabilitation.
Investments in work interventions should focus more on age-appropriate strategies rather than generic programs for all age groups.
CONCLUSION
The study concludes that while work does not uniformly benefit all offenders, it significantly aids older offenders in reducing their criminal behavior and recidivism rates.
Future research should continue to refine our understanding of how age and employment intersect to affect criminal behavior over the life course.
ntroduction to the Influence of Schools on Crime
American children spend approximately 15,000 hours by high school graduation in school, which includes both school hours and after-school activities.
This extensive exposure increases their likelihood of victimization by crime on campus than off campus, as evidenced by Zhang et al. (2016).
Theoretical traditions within criminology attribute significant importance to schools for shaping criminal orientations and behavior in youth and adulthood.
Key theoretical constructs include:
- Social Bonds: Schools foster relationships that influence criminal behavior (Hirschi, 1969).
- Deviant Peer Groups: Connections to delinquent peers due to school interactions (Cohen, 1955).
- Reputation and Identity: The formation of reputations that affect one’s further interactions and social standing (Mowen & Brent, 2016; Rios, 2011).
- Social Capital: Schools contribute to the social networks that affect opportunities later in life (Hoffmann & Dufur, 2008).
- General Strain: School experiences can contribute to strain that leads to delinquent behaviors (Agnew, 2001).Credentials, opportunities, habits, and skills from schooling affect adult market prospects, which in turn impacts long-term criminal trajectories (Laub & Sampson, 2003).
Review Focus
This review examines the impact of normal school practices and experiences on delinquent behavior, particularly the social consequences of school punishment and policing (Kupchik, 2016).
The review also investigates questions about how school experiences affect illegal behavior outside of school, the outcomes of school practices on safety, and the broader implications of crackdown practices.
School Attitudes, Performance, and Experiences
Criminologists focus on processes affecting the relationship between schooling and illegal behavior, namely:
- School Failure: Poor academic performance leading to deviant behavior due to strain (Agnew, 2001).
- Educational Expectations: Higher expectations correlate with lower delinquency rates (Crosnoe, 2006).
- Engagement: School engagement positively influences delinquency reduction (Hirschfield & Gasper, 2010).
- Grouping Practices: The structure and group composition within schools that might affect behaviors.Challenges in Establishing Effects:
- Factors are highly correlated and mutually reinforcing, complicating causal inferences.
- Many cross-sectional studies don’t adequately address selection bias, leading to inconclusive results on the influence of school factors on delinquency.
- Reciprocal relationships complicate causality, as delinquency can adversely affect school performance and vice versa (Kirk & Sampson, 2013).
Recent Studies Addressing These Obstacles
Three studies emphasized distinctions among multiple school-related factors, controlling for stable traits and time-varying covariates:
1. Hirschfield & Gasper (2010): Investigated emotional, behavioral, and cognitive engagement among Chicago elementary students, finding behavioral engagement significantly reduced delinquency.
2. Hoffmann et al. (2013): Analyzed school attachment and academic performance (GPA) across grades 7 to 11, presenting evidence that GPA affects subsequent delinquency independently.
3. Wang & Fredricks (2014): This study established reciprocal effects between school engagement and delinquency through multiple survey waves, reinforcing that behavioral engagement reduces delinquency.While these studies employed rigorous controls for internal validity threats, the potential selection bias cannot be entirely negated.
School Policies and Crime Control
The school-crime crackdown arose from increased school violence in the late 1980s and 1990s, triggering school safety initiatives involving harsher punishments (Kupchik, 2016).
Data indicate significant increases in school punishments and arrests amid this crackdown:
- Out-of-school suspensions escalated from 1.7 million (3.7%) in 1974 to 3.3 million (6.9%) in 2006.
- The number of school resource officers (SROs) surged from approximately 100 in the 1970s to over 14,000 by 2003 (Fabelo et al., 2011).
Impact on School Social Climate
The crackdown led to skepticism regarding its effectiveness in enhancing school safety, as rates of victimization decreased in parallel with broader crime trends (Zhang et al., 2016).
Authoritative school climates, fostering strict but fair discipline while promoting support, remain positively associated with student safety (Cornell et al., 2015).
Crackdown practices may undermine supportive relationships within schools, transferring disciplinary responsibilities to less equipped staff, which diminishes authority warmth and procedural justice (Kupchik, 2010).
The Impact of School Policing and Security
Limitations in literature expose a lack of pre- and post-crackdown outcome measures to ascertain the effectiveness of school policies on crime directly.
Studies suggest that increased policing, while correlating with higher reporting of offenses, may reflect heightened awareness rather than increased misconduct (Na & Gottfredson, 2013; Owens, 2017).
Variation in policy applications across states lends credence to claims regarding the impact of loosened definitions of infractions and changing disciplinary standards.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Criminological assessments of school policies must weigh school safety improvements against potential community risks associated with increased youth criminalization.
There’s an urgent need for robust research on the efficacy of alternative disciplinary approaches, including restorative justice and PBIS, and on abrupt policy shifts shifting away from exclusionary practices (Mader et al., 2016).
The integration of strong qualitative data alongside traditional quantitative methodologies would solidify findings and better inform policy decisions.
Creating a Context for Institutions
· Impacts at the Macro level “trickle” down to the Micro level
o There is often not a trickle up to the macro unless we consider the macro reactions to individual outcomes
§ Ex. Someone commits a mass shooting; thus the community works to alter gun laws and responses
· Broader Family Context
o These are the elements of the routine family life that participate in tightly coupled packages of disadvantage
§ In conjunction with parental incarceration, these impacts and adverse childhood experiences transmit disadvantage through generations
o Importance of life course impacts on success and relationships
Family and Crime
· Theories that incorporate the family
o Social control, self-control, age-graded theory of social control, strain, learning, subcultural etc
o Essentially, all theories have some aspect of family
· Significant findings in the family-crime connection
o Criminal/antisocial kin
o Large family size
o Poor child-raring methods
o Abuse/neglect
o Parental conflict/disrupted families
o Other parental features
· Parental incarceration (PI_ and the Broader family context (BFC)
Education and Crime
· Education usually serves as a way to reduce deviant behavior
o Time in school is behavior/time controlled
o Hidden curriculum
o Intervention policies
o Vehicle for economic mobility
o Providing survival resources
§ Food, clothes, supervision, etc
· However, education can also perpetuate (or even create) deviant behavior
o School-to-prison pipeline
o Suspensions
o Reproduction of inequality
o Opportunities with “deviant peers”
Health and Crime
· Negative health behaviors may correlate with deviant behaviors, but it is a hard sell to believe negative health plays a casual role in crime/deviance
o Perhaps the only casualty form health to deviance is neurodivergence
· The relationship usually works in the opposite direction where crime/deviance begets negative health behaviors
o Also consider risky behaviors relating to health (unprotected sex, substance use, violence, etc)
· Incarceration
o Prisoners possess a constitutional right to health care
§ Short-term benefits, long-term consequences
o Increase in chronic health problems
§ Increased exposure to infectious disease
o Time incarcerated matters less than incarceration as an event
o During incarceration
§ Increased morality for whites
§ Reduced morality for blacks (reducing external dangers such as street violence while introducing healthcare)
Immigration and Crime
· Immigration to an area shows null or negative connection to crime rates
· Immigration as a protective factor from deviance
o Usually, it takes about three generations to reach parity in deviant behavior
· However immigration populations face other challenges
o Deviance by existing without documentation
§ Or even targeted regardless of documentation
o Specific tasks forces aimed at their demographic
§ ICE
§ Immigration detention centers
§ Civil law vs criminal law detention centers 9no right to legal representation, no government-appointed lawyers, can be held indefinitely, etc)
Stratification and Crime
· We know inequality tends to correlate with deviance/crime
o Reasoning differs based on perspectives
· Probability of arrests remains stable after three decades
o Incarceration is where the biggest disparity occurs
o Increase in low-level, low-rate delinquents rather than dangerous or high-rate offenders
§ Non-violent, non-serious, and non-repeated (non-non-nons)
· Increased public punitiveness is the product of political realignment following reconstruction and the creation of law-and-order politics, rather than a fear of crime.
· Spatial concentration of incarceration
Hypothesis on Family and Crime
Different theories may hypothesize varied relationships between family and crime, with some emphasizing the family as a crucial influence for individuals due to:
- Social Control Theory: Posits that strong family bonds create constraints against deviance.
- Strain Theory: Suggests that familial pressures can cause stress that leads to deviance.
- Learning Theory: Indicates that familial interactions can socialize individuals into criminal behavior.Family dynamics that increase deviant behavior include:
- Parental criminal history
- Dysfunctional family structures, including abuse and neglect
- Large family size leading to lack of attention for each child.
Education and Deviance
Education is typically viewed as a reducing factor for deviance and as a vehicle for social mobility; however, it could also:
- Perpetuate inequality, especially through a hidden curriculum that discriminates against disadvantaged groups.
- Contribute to the school-to-prison pipeline through:
- Zero-tolerance policies
- Over-policing in schools leading to criminal records for minor infractions.
Health and Crime Relationship
The relationship could go both ways, where:
- Negative health behaviors lead to deviant actions (e.g., drug abuse resulting in theft).
- Deviant behavior leads to poor health outcomes (e.g., increased risk of injury or mental health issues from violence).Two additional examples:
- Substance abuse leading to criminal activity.
- Obesity and socioeconomic status leading to crime through missed opportunities.
Immigration and Crime Perspectives
Perspectives on immigration's influence on crime rates:
- Decreased Crime Rates: Some evidence shows that immigrants tend to have lower crime rates due to strong community ties.
- Increased Crime Rates: Others argue that immigration leads to increased competition for jobs and resources, which can result in higher crime rates.
Giordano et al. Findings
Broader Family Context: Includes elements such as:
- Parental incarceration that influences deviant behavior through a lack of guidance or financial resources.
- Scenarios could include a child with an incarcerated parent engaging in risky behaviors due to lack of supervision.Variables impact the outer environment by being positioned within multiple levels:
- A person in a family, a family in a community, affecting broader societal interactions.Findings showcase a life-course perspective where parental incarceration uniquely compounds disadvantages, differing from other factors like poverty in long-term behavioral outcomes.
Hirschfield's Insights
School-Crime Crackdown:
- Refers to aggressive policies enacted in response to perceived school violence in the late 20th century.
- Real-world examples include increased police presence in schools and compulsory reporting of juvenile infractions.
- These measures can disproportionately harm minority students through racial profiling.School sanctions can lead to deviant behavior either through punishment or as a form of social labeling, influencing students' self-identity.
Concluding Remarks: Criminologists should focus on researching the effects of school discipline on student outcomes and advocating for restorative justice practices over punitive measures.
Uggen's Analysis
Two opposing views on employment’s impact on deviance:
- Life-Course Perspective: Employment provides stability that reduces recidivism, particularly for older offenders.
- Non-Life-Course Perspective: Employment may not have significant long-term effects, especially for younger offenders.The author notes age interacts significantly with employment and deviance, suggesting that older offenders benefit more from employment than younger ones.
The pattern indicates that recidivism is highest in the first year post-release but tends to decrease as time progresses, particularly influenced by stable employment during that period.