GMS note 7

Managing Quality & Quality Control

Quality and Strategy

  • ### Quality as a Competitive Advantage Organizations achieve a competitive advantage through:

    1. Differentiation

    • Offering unique, high-quality products.

    • Example: Bose differentiates its audio systems based on superior sound quality that meets customer expectations.

    1. Cost Leadership

    • Producing quality goods at low cost.

    • Example: Nucor Steel produces quality steel efficiently via consistent processes, enabling lower pricing.

    1. Response

    • Providing quick, customized service.

    • Example: Dell builds PCs to customer specifications within hours, enhancing customer satisfaction.

      • Conclusion: Quality drives strategic approaches in organizations by boosting customer satisfaction and enhancing market success.

Quality and Profitability


How Quality Improvement Increases Sales
  1. Speed Response

  • Faster service fosters customer trust, resulting in increased sales.

  1. Flexible Pricing

  • Higher quality enables competitive yet profitable pricing strategies.

  1. Improved Reputation

  • A strong brand reputation encourages repeat business and customer loyalty.

  • ### How Quality Improvement Reduces Costs

    1. Reduced rework and scrap.

    2. Fewer warranty claims and failures.

    3. Lower inspection and maintenance costs.

    • Overall Insight: Quality enhancements lead to reduced internal and external failures while increasing value delivery.

Cost of Quality (COQ)

  • ### Definition
    The Total Cost of Quality (COQ) pertains to all expenditures made to attain and keep quality standards free of defects, encompassing costs for conformance and repercussions of non-conformance.


Categories of COQ

Category

Description

Examples

Prevention Costs

Investments to avoid defects before they occur.

Training, maintenance, quality planning.

Appraisal Costs

Costs incurred in inspecting product quality.

Testing, audits, inspections.

Internal Failure Costs

Costs arising from defects before products reach customers.

Rework, scrap, downtime.

External Failure Costs

Costs associated with defects after products have been used by customers.

Warranty claims, returns, lost customers.

  • ### Good vs. Bad Costs

    • Good Costs: Prevention + Appraisal = Investments that enhance quality.

    • Bad Costs: Internal + External Failure = Wasted resources due to poor quality.

    • Goal: Transition the focus from failure costs to prevention costs.

Total Quality Management (TQM)

  • ### Definition
    Total Quality Management (TQM) is a comprehensive approach integrating all organizational functions and processes with the aim of achieving continuous improvement and elevated customer satisfaction.

  • ### Core Principles of TQM

    • Satisfy customer requirements.

    • Execute tasks correctly in the first attempt.

    • Ensure consistency (reduce variation).

    • Commit to continuous improvement.

    • Instill quality in all organizational endeavors.

Seven Concepts of TQM
  1. Continuous Improvement (Kaizen)

    • Mandates continual enhancements in quality, processes, and efficiency.

  2. Six Sigma

    • A data-driven strategy aimed at minimizing defects and variability in processes.

  3. Employee Empowerment

    • Promotes staff participation and responsibility toward quality initiatives.

  4. Benchmarking

    • Involves comparing organizational performance against industry leaders.

  5. Just-In-Time (JIT)

    • Aims to minimize inventory and defects by aligning production schedules with demand.

  6. Taguchi Concepts

    • Focuses on designing robust systems that can withstand variations.

  7. Knowledge of TQM Tools

    • Involves the application of statistical and analytical methods for effective quality control.

Continuous Improvement Process (CIP)

  • Recognizes that innovation leads to continually changing performance standards. Processes deemed effective today may become obsolete tomorrow.

PDCA (Deming) Cycle
  • A four-step model for continuous improvement:

  • Plan: Identify customer needs and establish goals.

  • Do: Execute improvements or solutions.

  • Check: Assess results and identify issues or areas for improvement.

  • Act: Implement corrective actions and standardize successes.

  • The PDCA cycle is perpetuated consistently to uphold progress.

Six Sigma

  • ### Meaning
    A methodology that initially emerged from Motorola, later propagated by GE and Honeywell.

  • ### Two Interpretations

    1. Statistical:

    • Represents a 99.9997% defect-free rate, equating to 3.4 defects per million opportunities.

    • The process variation fits within a range of ±6σ.

    1. Philosophy:

    • A disciplined framework aimed at diminishing defects, reducing costs, and improving customer satisfaction.

Taguchi Concepts

  • ### Philosophy
    The majority of quality problems originate within product and process design.

  • ### Key Elements

    • Robust Design: Ensures that products deliver consistent performance even in adverse conditions.

    • Quality Loss Function (QLF): The societal costs increase as products deviate from their target specifications, even when such deviations fall within tolerance limits.

    • Variables:

      • (L): Loss incurred.

      • (C): Cost associated with a deviation at the specification limit.

      • (D): Deviation from the target value.

    • Example of QLF Calculation:

      • If deviation = 2 ohms, target loss at 5 ohms = $10.

Tools of TQM (The “Magnificent Seven”)

Tool

Purpose

Check Sheet

Collects data to highlight patterns or trends.

Pareto Chart

Identifies the limited causes responsible for the majority of issues.

Histogram

Displays frequency distribution of measured values.

Scatter Diagram

Illustrates relationships between two variables.

Cause-and-Effect Diagram (Fishbone)

Identifies root causes for defects.

Flowchart

Mapped visual representation of the process sequence for clarity.

Control Chart

Monitors variations of a process over time.

Example: Check Sheet for Hospital Delays

Reason

Mon

Tue

Wed

Thu

Fri

Total

Overload of patients

5

2

2

5

7

21

Patient discharge problems

2

1

1

2

4

10

Staff problems

5

2

5

1

2

15

Lack of rooms

5

2

4

5

5

21

Pareto Chart
  • Utilizes the 80/20 rule to articulate that 80% of issues generally stem from 20% of causes.

    • Bars arranged by frequency with a cumulative percentage line to concentrate efforts.

    • Addressing the top three causes may potentially resolve approximately 85% of delays.

Histogram
  • Visual depiction of performance data distribution.

    • Example: Repair times indicating the most prevalent duration is between 10-15 minutes.

    • Steps to Create a Histogram:

    1. Select measure.

    2. Gather data.

    3. Develop frequency table.

    4. Create the histogram chart.

    5. Interpret results.

Scatter Diagram
  • Exhibits correlations between pairs of variables:

    • Positive Correlation: As x increases, y also increases.

    • Negative Correlation: As x increases, y decreases.

    • No Correlation: Random scatter implies no relationship.

    • Nonlinear Pattern: Curvilinear correlations.

Fishbone (Cause-and-Effect) Diagram
  • A visual technique used to identify potential causes categorized under:

    • Materials

    • Methods

    • Machines

    • Manpower

    • Measurement

    • Environment

    • Example: Causes of lead-time delays can include supplier issues, transportation problems, and demand variations.

Flowchart
  • A schematic representation of steps within a process that assists in identifying inefficiencies or bottlenecks (e.g., a hospital emergency service flow).

Statistical Process Control (SPC)

  • ### Purpose
    To observe, quantify, and amend process variations in real-time.

  • ### Types of Variation

    • Natural (Common) Causes: Random variations that are typically expected.

    • Assignable (Special) Causes: Variations that can be identified and corrected, e.g., operator errors or machine malfunctions.

Control Chart
  • A graphical representation of process performance data featuring upper and lower control limits.

Performance Measurement

  • ### Categories

    • Variables: Continuous measures (e.g., weight, length, and time).

    • Attributes: Categorical measures (e.g., defective or non-defective).

Advantages
  • Variables: Provide more detail concerning the magnitude of errors.

  • Attributes: Simpler and faster for inspection processes.

Sampling Concepts

  • Impracticality of 100% Inspection: Given high costs and logistical constraints, sampling becomes necessary.

  • Objective: To estimate the characteristics of a process (mean, variance) utilizing statistics derived from samples.

  • Process Distribution: Represents the totality of the production population.

  • Sampling Distribution: Refers to the distribution of sample averages; it gradually resembles a normal curve as per the Central Limit Theorem.

Central Limit Theorem (CLT)

  • States that, regardless of the population distribution shape, sample means tend to create a normal distribution if the sample size is sufficiently large (n ≥ 30).

    • The mean of sample means is denoted by extμext{μ}.

    • The standard deviation of sample means is given by racσext√nrac{σ}{ ext{√}n}.

    • Distribution Regions:

    • 99.73% of results fall within the range of ext±3σext{±3σ}.

    • 95.45% falls within the range of ext±2σext{±2σ}.

Control Charts for Variables




  • ### Purpose
    To differentiate between random and assignable variation using time-series records.



  • ### Chart Types and Purposes


    Chart Type

    Monitors

    Purpose



    x̄ Chart

    Process mean

    Identifies central tendency.



    R Chart

    Range

    Assesses variability across samples.






    Example Grouped Under Oat Flakes Box Weight




    • Mean: 16g, σ=1gσ = 1g, z = 3 → 99.73% of weights fall within specific limits.

      • If samples exceed control limits, an investigation into assignable causes is required.

    Mean and Range Chart Interpretation
    • The x̄ -Chart reveals shifts in the process mean.

    • The R-Chart shows alterations in variability.

    • Utilizing both charts supports maintaining stable and predictable operations.

    Control Charts for Attributes

    • Utilized for categorical data, specifically for counting the number of defects.

    • ### A. p-Chart

      • Monitors the proportion of defects, leveraging the binomial distribution.

      • Example: Clinic Waiting Time:

      • Sample size n = 70; 15 samples denote 80 total defects.

      • Mean proportion calculated as rac8015×70≈0.076rac{80}{15×70} ≈ 0.076.

      • Indicates the process is in control with no points exceeding set limits.

    • ### B. c-Chart

      • Appropriate when multiple defects per unit may arise (e.g., typos, malfunctions in circuits).

      • Distribution Mechanisms:

      • Population adheres to the Poisson distribution, but sampling aligns with a normal approximation.