Overview of Criminal Law

Nature of Criminal Law

  • Definition: Unlike civil actions where plaintiffs seek personal remedies, crimes involve "the state" (e.g., Federal or State government) as the principal entity.

  • Societal Harm: Crimes inflict harm upon society rather than just individual victims.

  • Legislative Definition: Crimes are defined by legislatures through statutes that outline various prohibited conducts.

  • Fairness in Punishment: For government punishment to be fair, citizens must have clear notice of what is criminally prohibited.

  • Business Involvement: Businesses can be both victims and perpetrators. If an employee commits a crime for the business's benefit, the business can also be convicted.

Criminal Elements

  • Ignorance of the Law: "Ignorance of the law is no excuse" indicates that society determines what is harmful, not the individual.

  • Components of a Crime:

    • Actus Reus: The act defined as criminal.

    • Mens Rea: The requisite criminal intent, or "guilty mind".

  • Strict Liability Crimes: Crimes such as possession of child pornography, sale of tobacco to minors, or speeding that do not require proof of intent for conviction.

Differences Between Criminal and Civil Law

  • Criminal Law:

    • Injury to the public.

    • Prosecuted by the government.

    • Burden of proof: "beyond a reasonable doubt".

    • Possible penalties: fines or incarceration.

  • Civil Law:

    • Private injury or wrong.

    • Plaintiff sues the defendant.

    • Burden of proof: "preponderance of the evidence".

    • Penalties typically monetary.

Types of Crimes

  • Felonies: Crimes punishable by imprisonment for more than one year or death.

    • Examples: Murder, rape, kidnapping, armed robbery, embezzlement, insider trading, fraud, racketeering.

  • Misdemeanors: Petty offenses punishable by imprisonment for less than one year.

    • Examples: Petty theft, assault, trespassing, vandalism.

Offenses Against the Person

  • Homicide: The unlawful killing of one person by another without legal justification.

    • First Degree Murder: Intentional homicide committed with "malice aforethought".

    • Voluntary Manslaughter: Intentional killing occurring in "sudden heat of passion" due to provocation.

    • Involuntary Manslaughter: Lesser willfulness; often results from reckless actions leading to death (e.g., reckless driving resulting in fatal accidents).

Offenses Against the Person: Assault and Battery

  • Assault: An attempt to commit battery or placing another person in fear of immediate battery.

  • Battery: The unlawful application of force to another person, which does not need to be violent.

Offenses Against Property

  • Larceny: Wrongfully taking and carrying away another's personal property with the intent to steal.

  • Robbery: Larceny committed through violence or intimidation.

  • Embezzlement: Larceny by someone entrusted with another's property who then wrongfully takes possession.

  • False Pretenses: Acquiring property through false representations intended to defraud.

  • Receiving Stolen Property: Accepting property known to be stolen.

  • Forgery: False writing of a document of legal significance with intent to defraud.

  • Extortion: Wrongfully collecting money or valuables through threats.

Offenses Against Habitation and Other Crimes

  • Burglary: Breaking and entering a dwelling or commercial building with intent to commit a felony.

  • Arson: Deliberately setting fire to property, regardless of intent to collect insurance.

  • Bribery: Offering a secret payment to influence an official’s actions.

  • Perjury: Committing the act of lying under oath in judicial proceedings.

White Collar Crime

  • Definition: Crimes occurring in a business context, often involving non-violent means to gain personal or business advantage.

White Collar Crime: Fraud

  • Fraud: Utilization of deception to obtain money or property.

  • Types of Fraud:

    • Securities Fraud: Deception to bypass SEC regulations.

    • Financial Institution Fraud: Fraud against banks and credit unions.

    • Mail and Wire Fraud: Use of mail or electronic communication to facilitate fraud.

    • Ponzi Scheme: A fraudulent system where returns are paid to earlier investors using the capital of newer investors.

White Collar Crime Continued

  • False Statements: Engaging in cover-ups or misleading federal officers during investigations.

  • RICO Violations: Engaging in a pattern of racketeering defined by committing at least two acts of a variety of existing crimes, such as mail/wire securities fraud.

Criminal Law and Constitutional Criminal Procedure

  • Initiation of a Criminal Case:

    • Begins with an arrest if caught in act or fleeing; otherwise, a warrant is issued.

    • Warrant Issuance: Must be based on probable cause as assessed by a judge or magistrate.

    • Preliminary Hearing: Determines if sufficient reason exists for trial.

    • Bail: Monetary amount to ensure attendance at trial; can only be withheld if a flight risk exists.

Criminal Procedure Continued

  • Information and Indictment: Prosecutor submits an Information or seeks a grand jury indictment based on evidence to establish probable cause.

  • Arraignment: Defendant responds to accusations; must plead guilty or not guilty.

  • Prosecution's Burden: Must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" if the case goes to trial.

  • Plea Bargaining: Option for defendants to plead guilty in exchange for a recommendation for a lesser sentence.

  • Sentencing: Occurs after a guilty verdict or plea, followed by possible appeal.

Constitutional Rights of the Accused

  • 4th Amendment: Protects against unreasonable search and seizure; warrants require probable cause.

  • 5th Amendment: Protects against double jeopardy and self-incrimination; includes Miranda rights.

  • 6th Amendment: Ensures the right to a speedy trial, confrontation of witnesses, and attorney assistance for defendants.

  • 8th Amendment: Prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, along with excessive bail and fines.

4th Amendment

  • Protection Against Unreasonable Searches: Police cannot enter or seize property without a warrant based on probable cause.

Exceptions to the Warrant Requirement

  • Plain View: Officers may seize items in plain sight while legally present.

  • Crime in Progress: Officers may act to prevent immediate crimes observed.

  • Destruction of Evidence: Officers can act when evidence risks being destroyed.

  • Emergency Circumstances: Officers can enter to assist individuals in danger.

  • Consent: Officers can search areas voluntarily permitted by individuals.

  • Officer Safety: Officers may conduct protective sweeps for weapons.

  • Incident to Lawful Arrest: Officers can search arrested individuals.

  • Automobile Searches: Officers may search a stopped vehicle's passenger compartment.

  • Stop and Frisk: Allows officers to conduct limited searches for safety reasons during lawful stops.

5th Amendment Rights

  • Double Jeopardy: Prohibiting prosecution for the same offense multiple times.

  • Self-Incrimination: The defendant cannot be compelled to testify against themselves, and custodial interrogations require Miranda rights.

6th Amendment Rights

  • Speedy Trial: Right to confront witnesses and examine them in court.

  • Assistance of Counsel: Right to legal representation, with state provision for indigent defendants.

8th Amendment Rights

  • Prohibits cruel and unusual punishment and excessive bail or fines.

Fruit of the Poisonous Tree and the Exclusionary Rule

  • Definition: Evidence obtained in violation of constitutional rights is considered "fruit of the poisonous tree" and is generally inadmissible in court.