Overview of Criminal Law
Nature of Criminal Law
Definition: Unlike civil actions where plaintiffs seek personal remedies, crimes involve "the state" (e.g., Federal or State government) as the principal entity.
Societal Harm: Crimes inflict harm upon society rather than just individual victims.
Legislative Definition: Crimes are defined by legislatures through statutes that outline various prohibited conducts.
Fairness in Punishment: For government punishment to be fair, citizens must have clear notice of what is criminally prohibited.
Business Involvement: Businesses can be both victims and perpetrators. If an employee commits a crime for the business's benefit, the business can also be convicted.
Criminal Elements
Ignorance of the Law: "Ignorance of the law is no excuse" indicates that society determines what is harmful, not the individual.
Components of a Crime:
Actus Reus: The act defined as criminal.
Mens Rea: The requisite criminal intent, or "guilty mind".
Strict Liability Crimes: Crimes such as possession of child pornography, sale of tobacco to minors, or speeding that do not require proof of intent for conviction.
Differences Between Criminal and Civil Law
Criminal Law:
Injury to the public.
Prosecuted by the government.
Burden of proof: "beyond a reasonable doubt".
Possible penalties: fines or incarceration.
Civil Law:
Private injury or wrong.
Plaintiff sues the defendant.
Burden of proof: "preponderance of the evidence".
Penalties typically monetary.
Types of Crimes
Felonies: Crimes punishable by imprisonment for more than one year or death.
Examples: Murder, rape, kidnapping, armed robbery, embezzlement, insider trading, fraud, racketeering.
Misdemeanors: Petty offenses punishable by imprisonment for less than one year.
Examples: Petty theft, assault, trespassing, vandalism.
Offenses Against the Person
Homicide: The unlawful killing of one person by another without legal justification.
First Degree Murder: Intentional homicide committed with "malice aforethought".
Voluntary Manslaughter: Intentional killing occurring in "sudden heat of passion" due to provocation.
Involuntary Manslaughter: Lesser willfulness; often results from reckless actions leading to death (e.g., reckless driving resulting in fatal accidents).
Offenses Against the Person: Assault and Battery
Assault: An attempt to commit battery or placing another person in fear of immediate battery.
Battery: The unlawful application of force to another person, which does not need to be violent.
Offenses Against Property
Larceny: Wrongfully taking and carrying away another's personal property with the intent to steal.
Robbery: Larceny committed through violence or intimidation.
Embezzlement: Larceny by someone entrusted with another's property who then wrongfully takes possession.
False Pretenses: Acquiring property through false representations intended to defraud.
Receiving Stolen Property: Accepting property known to be stolen.
Forgery: False writing of a document of legal significance with intent to defraud.
Extortion: Wrongfully collecting money or valuables through threats.
Offenses Against Habitation and Other Crimes
Burglary: Breaking and entering a dwelling or commercial building with intent to commit a felony.
Arson: Deliberately setting fire to property, regardless of intent to collect insurance.
Bribery: Offering a secret payment to influence an official’s actions.
Perjury: Committing the act of lying under oath in judicial proceedings.
White Collar Crime
Definition: Crimes occurring in a business context, often involving non-violent means to gain personal or business advantage.
White Collar Crime: Fraud
Fraud: Utilization of deception to obtain money or property.
Types of Fraud:
Securities Fraud: Deception to bypass SEC regulations.
Financial Institution Fraud: Fraud against banks and credit unions.
Mail and Wire Fraud: Use of mail or electronic communication to facilitate fraud.
Ponzi Scheme: A fraudulent system where returns are paid to earlier investors using the capital of newer investors.
White Collar Crime Continued
False Statements: Engaging in cover-ups or misleading federal officers during investigations.
RICO Violations: Engaging in a pattern of racketeering defined by committing at least two acts of a variety of existing crimes, such as mail/wire securities fraud.
Criminal Law and Constitutional Criminal Procedure
Initiation of a Criminal Case:
Begins with an arrest if caught in act or fleeing; otherwise, a warrant is issued.
Warrant Issuance: Must be based on probable cause as assessed by a judge or magistrate.
Preliminary Hearing: Determines if sufficient reason exists for trial.
Bail: Monetary amount to ensure attendance at trial; can only be withheld if a flight risk exists.
Criminal Procedure Continued
Information and Indictment: Prosecutor submits an Information or seeks a grand jury indictment based on evidence to establish probable cause.
Arraignment: Defendant responds to accusations; must plead guilty or not guilty.
Prosecution's Burden: Must prove guilt "beyond a reasonable doubt" if the case goes to trial.
Plea Bargaining: Option for defendants to plead guilty in exchange for a recommendation for a lesser sentence.
Sentencing: Occurs after a guilty verdict or plea, followed by possible appeal.
Constitutional Rights of the Accused
4th Amendment: Protects against unreasonable search and seizure; warrants require probable cause.
5th Amendment: Protects against double jeopardy and self-incrimination; includes Miranda rights.
6th Amendment: Ensures the right to a speedy trial, confrontation of witnesses, and attorney assistance for defendants.
8th Amendment: Prohibits cruel and unusual punishment, along with excessive bail and fines.
4th Amendment
Protection Against Unreasonable Searches: Police cannot enter or seize property without a warrant based on probable cause.
Exceptions to the Warrant Requirement
Plain View: Officers may seize items in plain sight while legally present.
Crime in Progress: Officers may act to prevent immediate crimes observed.
Destruction of Evidence: Officers can act when evidence risks being destroyed.
Emergency Circumstances: Officers can enter to assist individuals in danger.
Consent: Officers can search areas voluntarily permitted by individuals.
Officer Safety: Officers may conduct protective sweeps for weapons.
Incident to Lawful Arrest: Officers can search arrested individuals.
Automobile Searches: Officers may search a stopped vehicle's passenger compartment.
Stop and Frisk: Allows officers to conduct limited searches for safety reasons during lawful stops.
5th Amendment Rights
Double Jeopardy: Prohibiting prosecution for the same offense multiple times.
Self-Incrimination: The defendant cannot be compelled to testify against themselves, and custodial interrogations require Miranda rights.
6th Amendment Rights
Speedy Trial: Right to confront witnesses and examine them in court.
Assistance of Counsel: Right to legal representation, with state provision for indigent defendants.
8th Amendment Rights
Prohibits cruel and unusual punishment and excessive bail or fines.
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree and the Exclusionary Rule
Definition: Evidence obtained in violation of constitutional rights is considered "fruit of the poisonous tree" and is generally inadmissible in court.