Language Development in Early Childhood
Conversational Skills in Preschool Years
- Conversational skills improve with age.
- Early preschool conversations often take the form of collective monologues.
- Children understand turn-taking but their statements may not connect to what others say.
- Example: One child talks about blocks, another about dolls independently.
- At three, children become more aware of reciprocal conversation conventions.
- Communications become more interactive with shared content.
- Novel information builds on previous comments.
Referential Skills
- Verbal pragmatics includes referential skills.
- Referential skills involve accurately communicating information, thoughts, intentions, and feelings.
- This communication considers the listener's characteristics and circumstances.
- By age four, children understand the need to modify communication based on the listener's needs.
- Example: Preschoolers simplify speech when talking to younger children (Baldwin, 1993).
- Children readily restate or repeat information if the listener misunderstands (Ferrier, Dunham, & Dunham, 2000; Pruden, Hirsh-Pasek, Golinkoff, & Hennon, 2006).
Pragmatic Listening Skills
- Pragmatic listening skills are apparent in the preschool years.
- Children use non-verbal cues like gazing and nodding to show they are listening.
- They also use vocalizations such as 'uh huh'.
- These cues reinforce and maintain conversations (Hamo & Blum-Kulka, 2007; Katz, 2004).
- Preschoolers show they're unclear by adjusting facial expressions.
- They are less likely than older children to ask for clarification until about age eight (Ackerman, 1993; John, Rowe, & Mervis, 2009).
Theories of Language Acquisition
Behaviorist Approach
- Behaviorism posits that correct grammar is shaped through conditioning.
- Parents reinforce correct grammatical forms and correct errors.
- Example: Parents respond more positively to 'I have three feet' than 'I have two foots'.
- Children then generalize the correct elements to similar utterances.
- However, parents rarely correct grammatically incorrect sentences but factual ones (Brown & Hanlon, 1970; Cazden & Brown, 2014; Penner, 1987).
- Limited evidence supports behaviorism as to how children acquire grammar after Skinner's theory.
Expansions and Recasts
- Parents are more likely to use expansions, repeating the child’s utterance with corrections inserted.
- Example: A child says, 'I have two foots,' and the parent responds, 'Of course, you have two feet! Look, let’s count them!'
- Recasts are similar with slightly different structures.
- Example: A child says, 'I have two foots,' and the parent responds, 'Daddy has two feet as well.'
- Instead of direct reinforcement, parents provide more precise and expanded grammatical models (Bohannon & Stanowicz, 1988; Chouinard & Clark, 2003).
- Exposure to these models is associated with increasingly correct grammatical forms (Farrar, 1992).
Social Learning and Scaffolding
- Social learning models emphasize the role of parents in providing supportive scaffolding (Bruner, 1996).
- Parents point to objects as they name them and repeat new words (Waxman, Lynch, Casey, & Baer, 1997).
- They use short sentences and concrete nouns (Hoff-Ginsberg, 1997).
- Scaffolding Example:
- Parent 1: 'Take your shoes off. Then put your shoes in the cupboard. Then come and kiss mummy goodnight.'
- Parent 2: 'After you take off your shoes and put them in the cupboard, come and kiss me goodnight.'
- The simplified grammar of Parent 1 is an example of child-directed speech.
- Child-directed speech is a language scaffolding technique used intuitively by adults (Messer, 1994).
- Recasting and expansion are forms of linguistic scaffolding.
- This highlights different forms of expression making children aware of structure and organization.
- Linguistic scaffolding, like the scaffolds used in building construction provides a temporary structure within which young children can build their own language structures.
- The scaffolding must change in response to the child’s linguistic development.
Imitation and Linguistic Play
- Social learning includes imitation.
- Children may copy utterances but their reproductions are often different.
- The imitation may involve prototype sentence forms but with new words.
- The child’s imitation may contain prototype words cast into new sentence forms.
- Remembered words and sentence forms can reappear later.
- Example: A child repeating their mother’s mealtime pleas to a toy rabbit.
- Linguistic imitation stimulates language development.
- Children rehearse new skills in linguistic play.
- Language play is less readily observed than physical play (Messer, 1994).
Nativist Approach and the Wug Experiment
- Children are resilient in acquiring language even in adverse conditions, supporting the nativist approach.
- Children infer grammatical relationships rather than merely copying.
- In Berko’s (1958) ‘wug’ experiment, children were shown pictures of imaginary creatures.
- Example: Children were shown a picture of one creature and told, 'Here is a wug.' Then, they were shown two and asked, 'Here are two ——'.
- Children correctly completed the sentences with 'wugs'.
- Berko reasoned children applied a general rule for forming plurals by adding 's'.
- The children’s success did not depend on copying but inferring grammatical structures.
- Berko theorized the grammatical rule operated unconsciously and may be innate.
Language Acquisition Device (LAD)
- Research provided empirical evidence for the LAD.
- Evidence was found in subsequent research based on Berko’s experiments.
- Deaf children spontaneously developed signing systems.
- These systems had distinctive grammar even when parents couldn’t sign (Goldin-Meadow, 2003).
- Early experiences with language are crucial for the LAD.
- The case of Genie shows the importance of early language exposure.
- Genie, isolated from age 20 months to 13 years, failed to develop effective spoken language (Rymer, 1994).
- Chomsky’s theory emphasizes innate mechanisms.
- Children build on imperfect grammatical structures.
- Environmental factors, including imitation and parental modelling play a role in grammar development (Goldberg, 2004).
Limitations of Nativist Theory
- Nativist theory primarily accounts for grammar, not semantics and pragmatics.
- It focuses on receptive language and neglects expressive language.
- Expressive language depends heavily on environmental factors.
Language Development in Deaf Children
- Some deaf individuals do not develop spoken language however, they develop expressive language in the form of gestures.
- Young deaf children spontaneously build personal gestural systems (Goldin-Meadow, 2003).
- Children who use these signs use grammatical structures different from spoken language.
- 'Home' signing systems are more likely when deaf children have hearing parents who aren't proficient in formal signing systems.
- Formal signing systems are true languages.
- The Deaf community defines 'Deaf' as a unique culture.
- Adopting sign language involves adopting social attitudes and cultural values.