Chapter 5 & 6- Equal Rights and All things Media
Foundations of Civil Rights and Equal Protection
Struggle Towards Fairness:
Equal rights involves an ongoing struggle toward fairness for historically marginalized groups, specifically:
African Americans
Hispanic communities
LGBTQ individuals
Women
Civil Rights Definition:
Defined as the equal protection under the laws and equal access to opportunities.
Equal Protection Clause:
Constitutional mandate establishing that no state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
Categories of Discrimination:
Public Discrimination: Discrimination carried out or sanctioned by governmental entities.
Private Discrimination: Discrimination originating from individuals and private businesses.
Judicial Standards of Review and Equal Protection Jurisprudence
Standards of Judicial Scrutiny:
Strict Scrutiny:
Applied to cases involving suspect classifications such as race or national origin.
Requires the government to prove that the classification serves a compelling state interest and is narrowly tailored.
Intermediate Scrutiny:
Applied to classifications involving gender or sex.
Reasonable Basis Test:
Applied to laws involving age, income, and other non-suspect classifications.
Requires only a legitimate reason or rational relationship to a valid governmental objective.
Plessy v. Ferguson (1896):
Context and Legislation: Centered on Louisiana's Separate Car Act (1920).
Case Background: Homer Plessy, an individual who was white and black, was arrested after attempting to ride in an all-white train car.
Doctrine Established: Upheld racial segregation under the "Separate but Equal" doctrine, validating different facilities for Blacks and whites.
Standard Used: Decided under the reasonable basis test.
Brown v. Board of Education:
Case Background: Henry Brown sought admission for his -year-old daughter, Linda Brown, to attend a neighborhood school closer to their home rather than traveling to a segregated Black school.
Core Conflict: The closer school was exclusively designated for white students.
Judicial Determination: Ruled that segregated educational facilities are inherently unequal, officially applying the strict scrutiny standard.
Additional Equal Protection Case Precedents:
Loving v. Virginia
United States v. Virginia
Forms of Discrimination and Historical Barriers to Voting Rights
Legal Classifications of Discrimination:
De Jure Discrimination: Discrimination that is directly written into and enforced by law.
De Facto Discrimination: Discrimination that occurs through habit, social tradition, practice, or custom rather than formal legal statutes.
Voting Rights Enfranchisement:
16th: Noted historically in relation to granting newly freed slaves the right to vote.
19th: Enfranchisement extending voting rights on the basis of sex (women's suffrage).
Historical Voting Suppression Mechanisms:
Poll Tax: Mandatory fee where individuals had to pay between and in order to cast a ballot.
Literacy Test: Evaluative reading and comprehension tests administered selectively to disenfranchise voters.
Grandfather Clause: Statutory exemption allowing an individual to vote only if their grandfather had possessed the right to vote prior to the Reconstruction era.
Public Opinion and Models of Representation
Public Opinion:
Definition: The politically relevant opinions expressed by citizens openly.
Analogy of Consumer Preferences: Paralleled to personal preferences between market alternatives, such as choosing between McDonald's and Burger King.
Three Types of Politicians (Representation Styles):
Delegate: A representative who votes strictly according to the expressed desires and instructions of their constituents.
Trustee: A representative who votes based on their own judgment, conscience, and moral beliefs rather than constituent demands.
Politico: A representative who alternates behavior, voting as either a delegate or a trustee depending on the specific issue or political context.
Political Socialization: Primary and Secondary Agents
Political Socialization Definition:
The learning process through which individuals acquire their political beliefs, values, and orientations.
Primary Agents of Socialization:
Agents that have a direct, early, and foundational influence on worldview:
Family
Early education (K-12)
Religious background
Secondary Agents of Socialization:
Agents that influence political views later in life or through external social environments:
Peer groups (including teammates, friends, and co-workers)
Major events (historical, social, or economic crises and milestones)
Political leaders
Mass media
Frames of Reference in Political Thinking
Frames of Reference ("Political Glasses"):
The cognitive lenses and baseline perspectives through which individuals perceive, filter, and interpret political issues:
Party Identification: An enduring emotional and psychological attachment to a specific political party.
Political Ideologies: A coherent and consistent pattern of opinions regarding the proper role, scope, and duties of government.
Group Orientation: Political viewpoints shaped by demographic and social identities, including identifiable patterns such as gender gaps.