Untitled Flashcard Set
Multiple choice
Two short answer questions
Something more covered than others?
No relatively proportional
A question or two on keigergard but less than descartes
No questions are - in meditation 1 is descart showing -
A b c is the options for what one is
In meditation 1 descartes does something - what does it mean
A
B
C
D
Format of short answer questions
One is conceptual
One is compair and contrast two thinkers
No dates
Greek terms -
Roots of the word philosophy - greek word for philosophy means
Love of wisdom/knowlage
Know eudaimonia - happiness/flourishing - telos of human life (End) Aims for
Going through
Meno - Plato
What is the Meno about?
Beginning of an attempt to find what Virtue is
Theory of knowledge - Knowledge as recollection: We had access to before we were born
Must be a gift from the gods becuase is it not taught or by nature
The Apology - Plato
Socrates is on trial:
What is he accused of?
Corrupting the youth
Busybody
Weaker argument the stringer
Worships the wrong gods
What animal is he compaired to? Gad Fly (An annoying fly) (A buzzing annoying thing)
What a good human life is like
Claiming to know what you dont know
“The unexsamined life is not worth living”
What does this diolouge tell us of his perspective of human nature?
“The unexsamined life is not worth living”
WHat is the outcome of the trial?
He's guilty
What does he think about death
We shouldn't fear death, because we shouldn't fear what we don't know
The Creto - Plato
Dialouge between creto and socrates
Creto wants socrates to escape prison
Diffierences and similarities between socrates
All rules and laws should be follwed or obeyd (Socrates)
MLK and socrates share pushing up against norms -
break in the understanding of justice
What is MLks problem with the white moderate -
Those who understand but dont do anything about it are worse - Passively standing by is in some ways worse
Ranciere - Ignorant schoolmaster
Supposed to teach them something but they dont speak the same language
Understand eventually on their own
Stultification vs emancipation
Stultification: Dependence on an explicator, Ex School (Knowlage is more in the teacher than the text)
Emancipation (The act of an intelligence obeying only itself even though the will obeys another)
Not simply a lak of a teacher
You rely on the books to learn - its up to you to do it and to learn from it. Knowledge coming from the text.
Principle quality
Eveyone has eual capacity for intelligence
Aristotle - nechemecian ethics
What is a virtue
The mean between to extremes
Studying vituosly - Dont spend all your time but dont spend none of your time -
Ex: bravery - between being rash and being a coward
Relative to you -
Building burining down
How do we develope the virtues?
Through habit overtime
What is the end of a good human life according to aristotle
Eudimoneia - Happiness or flourishing ( End words which aristotle thinks a good human life is after)
Achieve by living virtuosly and reasoning well
Exspert from metaphysis - Aristotle
4 Causes
Material -
Formal -
Efficiciant -
Final -
Ex: Table
Material - Manmade plastic
Formal - Its design, The thing that its for
Efficiciant - The person/thing that made it
Final - Its Formal cause done well : TO hold things up
Why have this structure?
Classification and knowing the sucseffulness
Applies to human beings
Formal Cause of human beings (Design) - use our reason, thats what makes us special
Final Cause: Using our reason well.
You should be able to do this breakdown
Reasoning well should lead to virtue- (Mean between two extremes)
Aquinas, - The
What is the purpose of the 5 ways?
Proving the existence of god
What are the general structure of each of these 5 ways -
Motion - Whos moving the mover? Things cant move themselves - Thus has to e god
The rest follow a similar logic - 5th is close enough
Cause - God is the first cause 9 (The efficient cause)
Everything has a cause - a maker/creator - Cannot have the expanding ino infinity
Contingency - God cannot not exist
Really similar to the 2nd way -
We find things that are psoible to be and posible to not be: Evey Being is is contingent but sme being has to be not contingent - Something has to be to kick off all th ebeing and not being
Gradation of Being - Scale of what we say is good, degree of how much of something; there has to be a maximum in any category - Thus the utter most case of that is God - Close to platos form (Need some whole perfect quality everything else can be derived from)
Intelligent Design - natural beings are working twords a goal ( Aiming twords) (thats not by chance)
What lacks intelligence archives gold by being directed by something intelligent:
Tress, Birds, Plants: WOrk twords a goal - dont have knowledge How do they do it
God is directing them twords and end -
We have these qualities were exspirirencing they make sense until l here has to be something that started them off
“And this being we all god” - is how he ends all
SO herefore God is how he sets up his argument
Thus God Exists
Understand the structure of all them - what are the qualities
Motion
Efficient caution
Gradation of being
Intelligent design
Kierkegaard
Emphasis on faith
Story on abraham and Issac
Terms -
Knight of infinite resignation: The on ewho renounces and doubts everything in the material world and is interested in the transcendent the world of he eternal Ex; Socrates ( Questioning everything) Almost a dislike of the material world - Willing to die for ideas
Opposed to
Knight of infinite faith: Passes through resignation, comes back to the material world and accpets whats good about it. Able to take a genuine joy in the world
Abraham - is Knight of infinite faith:
Feels care and concern for his son - has thus ultimate faith not just living in the world of ideas
Kight of faith is having to do something that is seen as un ethical
Ethical and what God is telling you to do conversation -
Descartes - Discourse on method
Whats the point of the writing?
Giving us the groundwork for what he will then do - Talks about why hes doing it then how hes doing it (Guidlines)
Meditations
Important Concepts:
Method of doubt:
Doubting everything -
Anti - Empiricist = Anti - sensory things and senses
Ex: Pensil in glass of water, dreams, evil demon : All decive us
What are we left with?
Absoluute knowlage - Mind over/Body: Mind body dualism
Clear and distinct ideas are the only thing that can be in our
“I think therefore I am” - Its my miind that tells me anything without being
Sence experiences are linked to the body!
Then theres our brain - Our brain can get confused by our senses
What ways does mind over body show up in societ?
FOr descartes - the mind is where we achieve the knowledge
Proving of God:
We end up depending on God for his sense of knowledge - Cant have true knowledge ( God is no deciver )
- - - - - - - - - —- - ——————————————————————————————
Exam Tuesday March 3rdWhat is Philosophy?
How do we become good students of philosophy?
F 1/16 Plato, Meno
Socratic Method: ex, Teachers/Therapiss - Probing through questions
Humans dont like the unkwn
Can virtue be taught?
Learners Paradox - Souls have access to knowledge, then, forget. Learning is getting access to what we already know.
What was the exercise?
Exercise with the slav - the square
Sophits -
of our time (sophistry) -
Knowledge vs. true belif
Taught vs. by nature
Either a natural thng or by Gods - thats it
T 1/20 Rancière, excerpt from The Ignorant Schoolmaster (Bb)
Learning withought a teacher
The experiment? -
Emancipation - Not having all come from one master
You dont need an expicator
Critique of school
F 1/23 Plato, The Apology
Socrates on trial defending himself
“Busybody” - in other people buisness
Acused for:
Fale deitiies
Making the stronger argument the weaker
Corrupting the youth - Doubt different than standard
Curiosity in beneath the earth and in heavens
Socratic Wisdom
To know you dont Know - Wise to understand you dont know alot of things
You shouldnt fear what you dont know
“The unexsamined life is not worth living”
T 1/27 Plato, Crito
Friend approaches him in jail, Socrates argues and declines
Cretos Reasons why he should escape prison:
His children (Obligation to raise them)
Socrates was wrongly condemnd
Belives socrates is being a coward
Following unjust laws makes socrates Unjust
Cretos own reputation - Bad light in the eyes of many
Creto would loose his friend
Creto has a clear practical escape plan
Remaining in prison is collaborating in his own death
The opinion of the many vs. the experts
Socrates: The opinion of the many is not powerfulas it cannot make one foolish nor make one wise
Socrates values Truth/Knowlage over Life/Death
We shall never do wrong willingly therefore we shall never do wrong n return for a wrong
Becoming a Martr
F 1/30 Martin Luther King, “Letter from a Birmingham Jail” (Bb)
Civic engagement/Civic deuty
What is the claim that is than being argued about?
Just laws are moral laws
Democracy could lead to equality
Unjust laws should be changed
Advocating for change
T 2/3 Aristotle, excerpts from Nicomachean Ethics (Bb)
What makes a good life?
Teleological - aims at Telos(an End)
Happiness = Eudaimonia (Flourishing)
Flourishing = Doing function well
Habits forming our character
Reason as the thing that separates us from others (capacity to reason)
The Function Argument: The good of something depends on its function
Hapiness
F 2/6 Aristotle, excerpts from Metaphysics (Bb)
Discussion Board Post
4 Causes of aristotle
The material Cause
The formal Cause
The Efficient cause
The Final Cause
Habbit is important in deepening virtue
Different Kinds of Virtue
A virtue is a mean between two extremes
Humans as Divinely Created
T 2/10 Aquinas, excerpts from the 5 ways (Bb)
Motion - Things cant move themselves
Cause - God is the first cause
Contingency - God cannot not exist
Gradation of Being - Scale of what we say is good
Intelligent Design -
F 2/14 Kierkegaard, excerpt from Fear and Trembling (Bb)
Discussion Board Post
Physical notes
Mind over matter
F 2/20 Descartes, Discourse on Method
Mind Body Dualism
Emphasies: systemic doubt, human reason, scientific inquiry
Discourse is laying the groundwork for the meditations
Purpose of doubting ones previous knowledge
WHAT DO YOU TRULY KNOW
Metaphysical Investigation - What can I trust what cant I trust
Considerations concerning the sciences
Chief Rules
Rules of Method
Clear and distinct Ideas
Break everything down to its smallest
Conduct thoughts in order
Being very thorough
Descartes is trying to go back to Pre-knowlage
3. Rebuilding a () Secure foundation- Builds ones house to tear it down
MORAL CODE:
1. Obey the laws and customs of my country2. Be firm and resolute in my actions
3. Master myself rather than fortune
4. Devote my life to the cultivation of my reason
4. Prove the existence of God/ The soul
3 Things not susceptible to doubt
“I think therefore I am”
-
Proofs of God
-
Movement of the heart (Not important
Pre- requisite to the meditations - Emphasis on exspirimentation
Clarifying that hes doing this for himself
Independent Project
Argues for a rational Soul
Mind Body Dualism - “Soul is immortal”
T 2/24 Descartes, Meditation 1-3
MEDITATION 1: Getting used to Doubting
Wants to find a solid grounding for ALL knowledge
“Method of Doubt”
Wants something definitely true to base knowledge off of
Beliefs coming from the senses can reasonably be doubted
Ex; Cup in water
ANTI - Empiricism: Rejects the notion that sensory experience and observation are the primary or sole sources of knowledge
The Dream Scenario
The Evil Demon Senario
Systematically deceiving you at every turn
The Matrix
Halusonogenic state - the doubt of all things
Throws all of our beliefs into question
Aiming To show that the Empiricism are wrong ANTI - Empiricism
MEDITATION 2
Accomplish: What it means to exist
Foundation of knowledge cannot come from the senses
THE COGITO: I Think Therefore I am
I think so I exist
I do indeed think
Therefore I exist
Capacity to be deceived is through thought able to have thoughts
“I am thinking therefore I exist because I know I am thinking”
Doubting you exist, YOU are doing the doubting
Has proven that “I” exist - I cannot doubt that I am a thing that thinks
Pink rabbit Senario
Cogito Ergo Sum: “I have to Exsist”
DESACRATES IS A RATIONALIST
Visiting the idea of oneself
Ex: Wax -
Not Qualitative is Quantitative
MEDITATION 3
Why would he want to prove god exists:
Idea of Perfection
“Nothing is greater that can come from something lesser”
To have the idea of perfection, you had to get it from some perfect thing
Something cannot come from nothing.
Can We create something that is totally new?
F 2/27 Descartes, Meditation 4-6
MEDITATION 4
Only an imperfect deceiver can practice deliberate perception
Mistakes - Will extends beyond intellect
God have him INFINITE free will
Be careful what we take in as knowledge
Capacity to be wrong (Free Will)
MEDITATION 5
Examines his own mind
Mathematical and geometrical truths
1.Rejects that he made up these properties (DOUBT)
2. Rejects that he learnd through experience (Nature to the mind)
Conclusion: The Physical World May Exist
ONTOLOGICAL Proof of God
ONTOLOGICAL - dealing with the nature of being.
I have an idea of supremely perfect being
Necessary existence is a perfection
Therefore a supremely perfect being exists
3. Proves existence of god
Perfect in his mind - greater cant come from lesser
Claim: God is no deciver
God isint deceiving him
Free Will
Meditator turning attention to material objects (Essence outside the mind)
Size, shape, position (qualities)
- There could be material things
Mathematical and geometrical truths
Concept of perfection
Exsistence is one of gods perfections - Ontological proof of god
Privalege the mind over any sensory exspirence
Perfection ~ Existence
“I cannot imagine God withought existence
MEDITATION 6
Discussion of mind and body
Rational conception vs. Imagination
Imagination = the mind not understanding
The body is not essential to who we are
Clear and distinct
In Contemporary Society - Mind Over Body = Male Over Female
Mind Body Dualism - The Mind is doing the living
-Things become less clear when the body gets involved
Minds and bodies are connected -
Deny all the sensory physical experience
F 3/6 Dan Nixon, “The Body as Mediator” (Bb)
Critique on Descartes
Pysical Over Mental
World, Mind, Body as one (way they work together)
Body is the groundwork
We Perceive First - developmentally