(copy)

Executive Power, National Security, and the War on Terror

  • Definition of the Executive Branch:

    • The executive branch is the branch of government charged with putting the nation's laws into effect.

    • While the president operates as the head of the executive branch and executes policies across economic, domestic, social, and foreign spheres, the war-making capacity represents one of the most significant exercises of executive power.

    • Although the Constitution grants Congress the explicit authority to declare war, the president is designated as the commander in chief.

  • The September 11, 2001 Attacks and Immediate Executive Responses:

    • On September 11, 2001, nineteen terrorists affiliated with Osama bin Laden's Al Qaeda organization hijacked four commercial passenger aircraft within the United States.

    • Two planes were deliberately flown into the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center in New York City.

    • One hijacked aircraft struck the Pentagon outside Washington, D.C.

    • A fourth aircraft crashed into an open field in rural southwestern Pennsylvania after passengers revolted against the hijackers.

    • Chief of Staff Andrew Card delivered news of the second plane strike directly to President George W. Bush while the president was visiting an elementary school classroom in Sarasota, Florida.

    • Following the attacks, President Bush issued unilateral executive orders that executed several security directives:

    • Mobilized the Ready Reserve of the Armed Forces into active military service.

    • Seized overseas financial assets and froze financial transactions of individuals and entities suspected of sponsoring terrorism.

    • Created the executive Office of Homeland Security.

  • Detention of Enemy Combatants: The Case of Yaser Hamdi:

    • In the autumn of 2001, fighters of the Afghan Northern Alliance, operating in coordination with U.S. armed forces in Afghanistan, captured Yaser Hamdi.

    • Hamdi was an American citizen, born in Baton Rouge, Louisiana; his parents had moved the family back to Saudi Arabia approximately one year after his birth.

    • The United States military detained Hamdi on accusations that he aided the Taliban in combat operations against U.S. armed forces in Afghanistan.

    • Hamdi was transferred between multiple military detention facilities and classified as an "enemy combatant," held indefinitely without access to legal counsel and denied the means to challenge his imprisonment in federal court.

    • In June 2002, Esam Fouad Hamdi filed a legal petition for a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of his son.

    • A writ of habeas corpus represents a judicial directive ordering the government to formally present criminal charges and produce evidence justifying the detention of an incarcerated individual.

    • The petition argued that Yaser Hamdi's prolonged, extrajudicial detention violated the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution.

    • His father maintained that the 20-year-old20\text{-year-old} had traveled to Afghanistan solely to undertake relief work, arriving only months prior to the September 11 attacks, and lacked sufficient time to undergo combat training.

    • Bush administration attorneys asserted that under Article II of the Constitution, the Executive holds plenary authority to detain enemy forces pursuant to inherent wartime executive authority.

  • Targeted Lethal Drone Strikes: Anwar al-Awlaki and American Citizens:

    • In September 2011, during the administration of President Barack Obama, an American targeted airstrike took place in a remote desert in Yemen.

    • The target was Anwar al-Awlaki, an American-born cleric identified by counterterrorism officials as a high-ranking operational figure and online recruiter for Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP).

    • Al-Awlaki had produced English-language sermons urging violent jihad against Western nations.

    • Unmanned aerial vehicles (drones), consisting of two Predator drones that painted targets with lasers and larger Reaper drones that fired three Hellfire missiles, completely destroyed the vehicle convoy.

    • Also killed in the strike was Samir Khan, an American citizen from North Carolina who served as the editor and creative director of AQAP's English-language propaganda periodical, Inspire.

    • Two weeks following this strike, a subsequent U.S. drone strike in Yemen killed al-Awlaki's 16-year-old16\text{-year-old} son, Abdulrahman al-Awlaki, who was an American citizen born in the United States and searching for his father.

    • Government officials privately referred to the death of the younger al-Awlaki as an unintended "mistake" occurring during an operation targeted at a different Al Qaeda operative who was absent from the site.

    • Within a single month, three United States citizens were killed abroad by lethal drone strikes without judicial indictment or jury trial.

  • Statutory and Executive Justifications for Lethal Force:

    • The legal underpinning cited by both the Bush and Obama administrations for unilateral military actions abroad was the Authorization for Use of Military Force Act of 2001 (AUMF).

    • Passed by Congress in the immediate wake of September 11, 2001, the AUMF granted the president statutory power to utilize all "necessary and appropriate force" against nations, organizations, or persons suspected of planning, authorizing, committing, or aiding the 9/11 attacks.

    • Critics, such as Representative Barbara Lee of California, voiced concern that the open-ended language of the AUMF provided successive presidents with an unchecked mandate to conduct endless military actions abroad without returning to Congress for formal authorizations of war.

    • In 2012, White House counterterrorism adviser John Brennan insisted that lethal strikes against American citizens occurred only when capture was unfeasible, after exhaustive interagency legal review, and when the target posed an imminent threat.

    • On May 22, 2013, Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr. issued a formal memo acknowledging that the United States government had deliberately targeted and killed Anwar al-Awlaki, marking the first known intentional extrajudicial killing of an American citizen by the government since the American Civil War.

    • Holder revealed that four American citizens in total had been killed in counterterrorism operations outside areas of active hostilities since 2009 (al-Awlaki intentionally, and three others—including Samir Khan and Abdulrahman al-Awlaki—unintentionally).

    • Precedent for extrajudicial drone strikes on citizens existed as early as 2002 under the Bush administration, when a Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) drone strike in Yemen eliminated a vehicle carrying suspected militants that included an American citizen.

Constitutional Foundations, Selection, and Federalist No. 70

  • The Constitutional Framing and Executive Selection:

    • The delegates to the 1787 Constitutional Convention sought an energetic executive capable of national leadership, yet they harbored intense anxiety over creating an elected monarchy reminiscent of the British Crown.

    • Small states opposed direct popular election of the executive, fearing that the larger voting populations of populous states would dominate presidential contests and subordinate minor state interests.

    • Delegates widely assumed that citizens would predominantly cast votes for candidates from their native states.

    • Direct popular election was rejected due to widespread distrust of the general public's capacity to evaluate national candidates dispassionately.

    • The Convention established the Electoral College, an indirect mechanism wherein each state selects electors equal to its total congressional delegation (members in the House of Representatives plus two senators), chosen in a manner directed by each state legislature.

  • Tenure, Term Limits, and the Twenty-Second Amendment:

    • The delegates established a presidential term of 4 years4\text{ years}, with no constitutional ceiling on the frequency of reelection.

    • Alexander Hamilton advocated that both the president and federal senators serve during good behavior (effectively life tenure, mirroring federal judges), but this proposal was overwhelmingly rejected.

    • George Washington established the two-term precedent by voluntarily stepping down in 1797 after serving two consecutive four-year terms (1789–17971789\text{--}1797).

    • This norm persisted unbroken until Franklin D. Roosevelt was elected to four consecutive terms (1933–19451933\text{--}1945) during the dual crises of the Great Depression and World War II.

    • In response to Roosevelt's extended tenure, Congress passed and the states ratified the Twenty-Second Amendment (1951):

    • Restricts any individual from being elected to the presidency more than twice.

    • Limits an individual who assumes the presidency (via death, resignation, impairment, or impeachment) and serves more than 2 years2\text{ years} of an unexpired term to a single subsequent elected term.

  • Constitutional Qualifications for Office:

    • Under Article II, Section 1 of the United States Constitution, candidates for the presidency must satisfy three baseline criteria:

    • Must be a "natural born Citizen" (or a citizen of the United States at the time of the constitutional adoption).

    • Must have attained the minimum age of 35 years35\text{ years}.

    • Must have been a resident within the United States for at least 14 years14\text{ years}.

    • The text does not explicitly bar women from holding the office, though women were broadly disenfranchised and legally restricted from holding political offices within the states at the time of ratification.

  • Hamilton's Defense of the Executive: Federalist No. 70:

    • Published as part of The Federalist Papers, Alexander Hamilton authored Federalist No. 70 to counter Anti-Federalist accusations that a single executive concentrated excessive power.

    • Hamilton asserted that "Energy in the Executive is a leading character in the definition of good government."

    • Executive energy is essential for:

    • Defending the nation against foreign attack.

    • Securing the steady administration of federal statutes.

    • Protecting private property against domestic disorder and unlawful combinations.

    • Securing individual liberty against the intrigues of faction, personal ambition, and anarchy.

    • Hamilton identified the core ingredients of an effective executive as unity, duration, adequate provision for its support (salary), and competent constitutional powers.

    • Plural or multi-member executives undermine executive operations:

    • Plural executives dilute the essential operational virtues of "decision, activity, secrecy, and despatch," which inherently belong to a single individual.

    • Multi-member councils lead to personal animosity, partisan friction, and administrative paralysis.

    • A divided executive obscures accountability, making it impossible for the voting public to discern who is responsible for executive failures or abuses of power.

  • Executive Nomenclature and Early Precedents:

    • Vice President John Adams originally recommended the official title: "His High Mightiness, the President of the United States and Protector of their Liberties."

    • Thomas Jefferson dismissed Adams's suggested title as "the most superlatively ridiculous thing I ever heard of."

    • The Convention adopted the simple title "President of the United States," and George Washington established the modest, republican tradition of addressing the chief executive as "Mr. President."

    • Washington's 1796 portrait reflects this republican restraint: he is depicted in a plain black wool coat rather than military uniform or royal regalia, seated next to books and scrolls indicating scholarship, with desk legs featuring carved eagles and fasces (bundled rods) evoking the Roman Republic's concept of strength through political unity.

Presidential Powers and Executive Roles

  • Classification of Executive Powers:

    • Formal (Enumerated) Powers: Authorities explicitly granted to the executive branch within the text of Article II of the Constitution.

    • Informal Powers: Ancillary authorities not explicitly mentioned in the constitutional text, but asserted as necessary to execute enumerated responsibilities and manage the executive establishment.

    • Political scientists classify presidential activities into five distinct roles: Chief Executive, Chief Diplomat, Commander in Chief, Chief Legislator, and Party Leader.

  • Chief Executive:

    • Article II vests the executive power solely in the president, directing the officeholder to "take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed" and swearing an oath to "faithfully execute the Office of President of the United States."

    • The President directs a bureaucracy composed of fifteen major cabinet departments, executive agencies, and civil servants.

    • Cabinet Mechanics:

    • The Cabinet consists of the heads of the fifteen executive departments (mostly titled secretaries, alongside the Attorney General), the Vice President, and any agency leaders accorded cabinet rank by the president (e.g., Administrator of the EPA, Director of the OMB, U.S. Ambassador to the UN, U.S. Trade Representative, Director of National Intelligence, Administrator of the Small Business Administration).

    • Cabinet secretaries are appointed by the president and require confirmation by a simple majority vote (50%+150\% + 1) of the Senate.

    • Secretaries act as administrative links between the White House and the vast federal bureaucracy, though they frequently develop independent institutional loyalties or experience pressure from departmental interest groups.

    • Modern presidents appoint approximately 1,0001\text{,}000 senior administrative officials who require Senate confirmation, alongside thousands of non-confirmed political appointees.

    • The president exercises bureaucratic oversight by:

    • Issuing executive orders directing agencies on how to implement statutes (e.g., President Trump's April 2017 directive ordering Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos to review federal regulations that encroached upon state and local educational autonomy).

    • Requiring written opinions from principal officers regarding departmental responsibilities.

    • Leveraging the federal budget to reward or discipline administrative agencies.

  • Chief Diplomat:

    • Article II grants the president explicit authority to negotiate foreign treaties, appoint ambassadors, and receive foreign ambassadors and public ministers.

    • Treaties negotiated by the president require the advice and consent of the Senate, requiring ratification by a two-thirds (23\frac{2}{3}) supermajority vote.

    • Presidential diplomacy combines ceremonial functions (such as hosting formal state dinners or attending sporting events with foreign heads of state, exemplified by President Obama hosting British Prime Minister David Cameron at an NCAA basketball tournament game in 2012) with high-stakes international negotiations (such as bilateral summits at the G-7 or United Nations General Assembly).

    • Advantages over Congress: Political scientist Clinton Rossiter observed that the single-person executive inherently possesses "secrecy, dispatch, unity, continuity, and access to information," which are structural advantages denied to a collective body of 535 legislators.

  • Chief Legislator:

    • Although the Constitution grants primary lawmaking authority to Congress, modern presidents actively direct the national policy agenda.

    • State of the Union Address:

    • Mandated under Article II, Section 3, directing the president to periodically provide Congress with information on the state of the union and recommend expedient legislative measures.

    • Thomas Jefferson discontinued in-person speeches to Congress, initiating a tradition of submitting written reports that lasted until Woodrow Wilson revived the in-person address in 1913. Jimmy Carter also sent a written message in 1981 prior to leaving office.

    • Today, the State of the Union serves as a televised platform used to mobilize the public and place legislative pressure on members of Congress.

    • Formal Legislative Veto:

    • The president can sign a bill into law or veto it, returning the unsigned bill with written objections to the house of origin within ten days (excluding Sundays).

    • Congress can override a presidential veto with a two-thirds (23\frac{2}{3}) supermajority vote in both the House of Representatives and the Senate.

    • A pocket veto occurs when the president takes no action on a bill during the final ten days of a congressional session; because Congress is adjourned, the bill automatically dies without an opportunity for an override.

    • Veto overrides are historically rare due to the difficulty of assembling two-thirds majorities in both chambers. Consequently, the mere threat of a presidential veto frequently forces Congress to amend legislation to conform to executive preferences.

  • Commander in Chief:

    • Under Article II, Section 2, the president serves as commander in chief of the Army, Navy, and state militias when called into active federal service.

    • The president sits at the peak of the military chain of command and retains sole operational command over the strategic nuclear arsenal.

    • The president is accompanied at all times by a military aide carrying the classified nuclear emergency satchel (commonly called the "nuclear football"), which contains authenticated codes and strategic retaliatory strike plans.

    • War Declarations: Congress has officially declared war in only five international conflicts throughout American history: the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War, the Spanish-American War, World War I, and World War II (1941). In contrast, presidents have deployed military force abroad hundreds of times without formal congressional declarations (such as the invasions of Afghanistan in 2001 and Iraq in 2003).

  • Pardons and Reprieves:

    • Article II grants the executive the power to grant reprieves and pardons for federal offenses, excluding cases of legislative impeachment.

    • A pardon completely eliminates legal penalties and restores full civil rights to an individual convicted of a federal crime.

    • A reprieve represents a temporary postponement of criminal punishment due to extenuating circumstances, such as health conditions.

    • Executive clemency cannot be checked, overturned, or modified by either Congress or the federal courts, though officials who receive pardons remain subject to congressional impeachment.

    • Presidents routinely grant controversial pardons during their final weeks or days in office, occasionally benefiting personal or political allies.

Unilateral Executive Instruments

  • Executive Privilege:

    • The asserted constitutional prerogative of the president to withhold internal documents, communications, memoranda, and meeting transcripts from congressional committees or federal judicial inquiries.

    • Originating with George Washington, presidents have defended executive privilege as essential for protecting frank, unvarnished advice from staff without fear of immediate political retribution.

    • In United States v. Nixon (1974), the Supreme Court formally recognized the legitimate constitutional basis of executive privilege for military, diplomatic, or sensitive state secrets, but ruled that the privilege cannot be used to shield materials relevant to a criminal prosecution.

  • Executive Agreements:

    • Direct pacts concluded between the president and the executive leader of a foreign sovereign government.

    • Unlike formal treaties, executive agreements do not require the advice and consent of a two-thirds (23\frac{2}{3}) Senate supermajority.

    • Executive agreements do not bind future presidential administrations and lack the enduring statutory permanence of ratified treaties, though they are often classified for national security reasons.

  • Signing Statements:

    • Written annotations, legal opinions, and interpretive commentary issued by the president concurrently with the formal signing of an enrolled bill into law.

    • Presidents use signing statements to direct administrative agencies on how to implement statutory provisions, occasionally signaling that the executive considers specific statutory requirements unconstitutional infringements on executive prerogatives.

    • Critics argue that when a president uses a signing statement to enforce statutes selectively, the executive usurps congressional legislative authority.

  • Executive Orders:

    • Direct policy directives issued unilaterally by the president to executive branch departments and administrative agencies that carry the binding force of law without requiring congressional approval.

    • While executive orders routinely govern minor bureaucratic operations, they have historically been used to execute major public policies without congressional assent.

    • Notable Historical Examples:

    • Franklin D. Roosevelt's Executive Order 9066 authorized the forced military exclusion and internment of over 130,000130\text{,}000 Japanese Americans during World War II.

    • Political scientist William Howell identified that unilateral tools allow presidents to act "first and alone,"