Land Law Lecture:

Duties of Trustees

Right of Beneficiaries

Resolution of Beneficiaries

Resolution of Disputes and Co-owned Land


Co-owned land always held on trust

  • Section 34-36 LPA 1925: wherever land conveyed to two or mor people, a trust will be statutory imposed (if not expressly created)


TOLATA 1996: Trustees’ powers

  • section 6: trustees have all the powers of an absolute owner

  • Section 7: peer to partition the land

  • Section 8 (1): powers under ss6 and 7 may be excluded or restricted

  • Section 8 (2) and trust can require consent of beneficiaries before exercise of peepers under ss6 and 7

  • Section 9: trustees may delegate owners to beneficiaries

  • Section 11: duty to consult beneficiaries


Right of beneficiaries

  • Section 11: right to be consulted

  • Section 12: right to occupy

  • TSB Bank plc v Marshall (1998)

  • Section 13: conditions on right to occupy


What if co-owners cannot agree?

  • Section 14 and 15 TOLATA 1996

  • Nahum v Hafiz (2015)


TOLATA 1996

SECTION 15 (1) AND 15 (3): Court to have rested to:

  • the intentions of he persons who established the rust

  • The purpose of the trust,

  • The welfare of any children who occupy the land

  • The interests of any secured creditors (i.e. mortgage lenders) AND

  • The circumstances and wishe of any beneficiaries of full age and entitled to an interest in possession or (in case of dispute) of the majority (According to the value of their combined interests)

Mortgage Corporation v Shaire (2001)

Bank of Ireland Home Mortgages Ltd v Bell (2001)

Edward’s v Lloyds TSB (2004)


Bankruptcy: app;ovation for sale less than 12 moths after bankruptcy

  • S335A Insolvency Act 1986

  • Interests of bankrupts creditors

  • If property is a dwelling-house of bankrupt and spouse or civil partner:

    • Partner’s conduct in contributing the bankruptcy

    • Needs and financial resources of spouse/cp

    • Needs of any children

  • All circumstances of the case other than the needs of the bankrupt

Bankruptcy: application for sale more than 12 months after bankruptcy

  • section 335A(3) after a year:

  • The court shall assume, unless the circumstances of the cases are exceptional, that the interest of the bankrupt’s creditors outweigh all other consideration


What are exceptional circumstances?

Re Citro (1991) ((pre-TOLATA)

Barca v Mears (2004)

Re Kaira(2006)

Ford v Alexander (2013)

Everett v Budhram [2009] EWCH 1291 (ch)

Claughton v Charalambous (1999)