Comprehensive Guide to Logic, Inference, Syllogisms, and Eduction

Foundations of Reasoning and Inference

  • Definition and Nature of Reasoning:

    • Reasoning is the third act of the mind and represents the highest level of mental operation.
    • It is an operation of the intellect that produces a real increase in knowledge.
    • It is defined as the mental process through which the intellect arrives at a new proposition or conclusion derived from previously possessed judgments and premises.
    • This cognitive operation is also designated as inference and finds its formal verbal expression through the syllogism.
  • Argument:

    • An argument is the reason, proof, or evidence offered for or against a proposition.
    • It serves as the verbal expression of the internal reasoning process, structured as a declaration that deduces one statement from others.
  • Syllogism:

    • A syllogism is an argument consisting of three propositions so interconnected that if the first two propositions (the premises) are posited, the third proposition (the conclusion) necessarily follows.
  • Inference Defined:

    • Inference constitutes one of the fundamental methods for arriving at truth.
    • Broad Sense: Any process by which the intellect moves from one or more propositions to other propositions that are seen to be implied by the former.
    • Strict Sense: The formal mental operation by which the mind acquires new knowledge by explicitly drawing out the objective implications of what is already known.
  • Essential Properties of Inference:

    • Antecedent: Derived from the Latin antecedo ("that which goes before"). It is defined formally as that from which something is inferred (the premises).
    • Consequent: Derived from the Latin consequor ("that which follows after"). It is defined formally as that which is inferred from the antecedent (the conclusion).

Antecedent and Consequent Relationship in Inference

  • The Sequence:

    • The sequence is the vital nexus or connection between the antecedent and the consequent; it represents the very heart of inference.
    • When an inference is made, intellectual assent bears directly upon this sequence.
    • The sequence is formally signaled by conclusion indicators, including:
    • Therefore
    • Consequently
    • Accordingly
    • Hence
    • Thus
    • And so
    • For this reason
  • Forms of Inference:

    • Deductive Reasoning: A process of drawing conclusions from accepted premises by proceeding logically from the universal (general) to the singular (specific).
    • Inductive Reasoning: A process of drawing conclusions from accepted premises by proceeding logically from the singular (specific) to the universal (general).

Systematic Hierarchy of Reasoning and Logical Deductions

  • Primary Divisions of Inference:
    • Immediate Inference: A direct reasoning process passing from a single proposition to a new proposition without the intervention or aid of a second proposition or a third term. It yields a new proposition, but not an entirely new truth.
    • Example: Crimes are evil acts; therefore, crimes are evil acts.
    • Subdivided into: Logical/Square of Opposition and Eduction.
    • Mediate Inference: A reasoning process that advances from two or more propositions to a conclusion through the mediation of an intervening third term.
    • Subdivided into: Categorical Syllogisms and Hypothetical Syllogisms (Conditional, Conjunctive, and Disjunctive).

Immediate Inference and Eduction

  • Eduction (Equivalence or Equipollence):

    • A judgment or statement that re-expresses the idea conveyed by an original proposition.
    • A formal method whereby a proposition is reformulated into a distinct structural shape without altering the essential meaning or truth-value of the original proposition.
    • Example: Eat all you can; therefore, eat as long as you can.
  • Conversion:

    • A form of eduction in which the truth of a proposition is restated by transposing the subject and predicate of the original proposition without overextending the quantity of either term.
    • Convertend: The original proposition subjected to conversion.
    • Converse: The resulting transposed proposition.
    • Fundamental Procedural Rules of Conversion:
    • 1. Interchange the positions of the subject and the predicate.
    • 2. Retain the original quality (an affirmative remains affirmative; a negative remains negative).
    • 3. Do not extend the quantity of any term (a term that is particular in the convertend cannot be made universal in the converse).
    • 4. Particular negative (OO) propositions cannot undergo valid conversion; an attempted conversion of an OO proposition is formally and materially invalid.

Structural Rule Diagram for Conversion

  • Types of Conversion:

    • Simple Conversion: Occurs when the quantity of the original proposition remains identical in the converse.
    • Universal negative (EE) and particular affirmative (II) propositions yield valid simple converses (E→EE \rightarrow E and I→II \rightarrow I).
    • Universal affirmative (AA) and particular negative (OO) propositions generally cannot undergo simple conversion.
    • Exception for AA Propositions: An AA proposition can undergo simple conversion (A→AA \rightarrow A) if and only if the predicate is the exact definition of the subject, making the terms coextensive and mutually interchangeable.
    • Examples of Simple Conversion:
      • I→II \rightarrow I: Some teachers are considerable people; therefore, some considerable people are teachers.
      • E→EE \rightarrow E: No adult person is an infant; therefore, no infant is an adult person.
      • A→AA \rightarrow A (Coextensive/Definition): A triangle is a three-sided figure; therefore, a three-sided figure is a triangle.
      • A→AA \rightarrow A (Coextensive Identity): Mr. Lou Hualda is our teacher in Logic; therefore, our teacher in Logic is Mr. Lou Hualda.
    • Partial Conversion (Conversion by Limitation / Per Accidens):
    • Occurs when the quantity of the original proposition is modified (reduced) in the converse.
    • Valid partial conversions include universal affirmative to particular affirmative (A→IA \rightarrow I) and universal negative to particular negative (E→OE \rightarrow O).
    • Invalid transitions: E→IE \rightarrow I, A→EA \rightarrow E, and A→OA \rightarrow O are not logically equivalent.
  • Obversion:

    • A method of immediate inference that reformulates a proposition by altering the quality of the copula (rendering affirmative propositions negative, and negative propositions affirmative) and replacing the predicate with its contradictory or contrary term.
    • Obvertend: The original proposition subjected to obversion.
    • Obverse: The resulting restatement.
    • Procedural Rules of Obversion:
    • 1. Retain the original subject and its original quantity.
    • 2. Change the quality of the copula.
    • 3. Substitute the original predicate with its contrary or contradictory term.

Structural Rule Diagram for Obversion

  • Distinction Between Contradictory and Contrary Terms:
    • Contradictory Terms: Terms that belong to completely different classes or genera; they represent the simple, absolute negation of one another (exhaustive dichotomy leaving no middle ground).
    • Contrary Terms: Terms that belong to the same genus but occupy extreme opposite positions within that genus (permitting intermediate states).

Tabular Comparison of Contradictory and Contrary Terms

  • Contradictory Examples:

    • mortal becomes non-mortal or immortal
    • educated becomes uneducated
    • eligible becomes ineligible
  • Contrary Examples:

    • hot opposes cold
    • beautiful opposes ugly
    • long opposes short
  • Application of Obversion Across All Four Propositional Forms:

    • A→EA \rightarrow E: Every man is mortal; therefore, no man is immortal.

    • E→AE \rightarrow A: You are bad; therefore, you are good. (Using contrary predicate).

    • I→OI \rightarrow O: Few men are weak; therefore, few men are not strong.

    • O→IO \rightarrow I: Not all days are bright; therefore, some days are dark.

    • Contraposition:

  • A composite process of eduction combining obversion and conversion, producing an interchangeable subject and predicate along with contradictories of terms.

  • Simple Contraposition:

    • A process of formulating a new proposition whose subject is the contradictory of the original predicate, whose copula quality is changed, and whose predicate is the original subject.
    • Steps for Simple Contraposition:
      • 1. Place the contradictory (or contrary) of the original predicate in the subject position.
      • 2. Change the quality of the copula.
      • 3. Place the original subject unaltered in the predicate position.

Structural Rule Diagram for Simple Contraposition

  • Examples of Simple Contraposition:
    • A→EA \rightarrow E: Every CSU instructor is a professional person; therefore, no unprofessional person is a CSU instructor.
    • E→IE \rightarrow I: No journalists are good politicians; therefore, some bad politicians are journalists.
    • O→IO \rightarrow I: Some politicians are not rich people; therefore, some poor people are politicians.
    • Complete Contraposition:
  • A process of formulating a new proposition whose subject is the contradictory of the original predicate, whose quality remains unchanged, and whose predicate is the contradictory of the original subject.
  • Steps for Complete Contraposition:
    • 1. Place the contradictory (or contrary) of the original predicate in the subject position.
    • 2. Retain the quality of the copula without change.
    • 3. Place the contradictory (or contrary) of the original subject in the predicate position.

Structural Rule Diagram for Complete Contraposition

* *Examples of Complete Contraposition:*
  * A→AA \rightarrow A: *Every CSU instructor is a professional person; therefore, every unprofessional person is a non-CSU instructor.*
  * E→OE \rightarrow O: *No journalists are good politicians; therefore, some bad politicians are not non-journalists.*
  * O→OO \rightarrow O: *Some politicians are not rich people; therefore, some poor people are not non-politicians.*
  • Inversion:
    • A process of eduction that stands as the operational opposite of obversion; it operates by substituting the subject with its contradictory term while retaining the original positional framework of terms.
    • Simple Inversion:
    • Formulates a new proposition where the subject and predicate retain their original structural seats, the quality of the copula is changed, and the subject is replaced by its contradictory term.
    • Steps for Simple Inversion:
      • 1. Replace the subject with its contradictory (or contrary).
      • 2. Change the quality of the copula.
      • 3. Retain the original predicate.

Structural Rule Diagram for Simple Inversion

  • Examples of Simple Inversion:
    • A→OA \rightarrow O: Every CSU instructor is a professional person; therefore, some non-CSU instructor is not a professional person. [Note: rendered as some non-CSU instructor is a professional person in empirical translation variations].
    • E→IE \rightarrow I: No journalists are good politicians; therefore, some non-journalists are good politicians.
    • Complete Inversion:
  • Formulates a new proposition where the subject and predicate remain in their original positions, the quality of the copula is maintained, the quantity is changed, and both the subject and predicate are replaced by their contradictories.
  • Steps for Complete Inversion:
    • 1. Replace the subject with its contradictory (or contrary).
    • 2. Retain the quality of the copula.
    • 3. Replace the predicate with its contradictory (or contrary).

Structural Rule Diagram for Complete Inversion

  • Examples of Complete Inversion:
    • A→IA \rightarrow I: Every CSU instructor is a professional person; therefore, some non-CSU instructor is an unprofessional person.
    • E→OE \rightarrow O: No journalists are good politicians; therefore, some non-journalists are not bad politicians.

The Simple Categorical Syllogism: Structure and Components

  • Basic Composition:

    • A Simple Categorical Syllogism consists of exactly three categorical propositions.
    • These propositions are constructed such that the subject (tt) and predicate (TT) of the conclusion are united or separated through the mediation of a middle term (MM).
    • Archetypal Example:
    • Major Premise: Every animal is mortal;
    • Minor Premise: But every dog is an animal;
    • Conclusion: Therefore, every dog is mortal.
  • Propositional Hierarchy:

    • Major Premise: The first proposition, containing the major term (TT) linked with the middle term (MM).
    • Minor Premise: The second proposition, containing the minor term (tt) linked with the middle term (MM).
    • Conclusion: The third proposition, expressing the final judgment uniting or separating the minor term (tt) and major term (TT).
  • The Three Terms:

    • Major Term (TT):
    • The predicate of the conclusion.
    • Must occur in the conclusion and in the major premise (traditionally stated first).
    • In the archetypal example, mortal is the major term (TT).
    • Minor Term (tt):
    • The subject of the conclusion.
    • Must occur in the conclusion and in the minor premise.
    • Often introduced in logical discourse by the adversative conjunction "but", which historically marks a turn of thought confronting the expectations of an opponent in disputation.
    • In the archetypal example, dog is the minor term (tt).
    • Middle Term (MM):
    • Occurs in both premises, but must never appear in the conclusion.
    • Connects with the major term in the major premise and with the minor term in the minor premise.
    • Serves as the intellectual medium or standard of comparison through which the major and minor terms are united (in affirmative syllogisms) or separated (in negative syllogisms).
    • In the archetypal example, animal is the middle term (MM).
  • Systematic Structural Identification Exercises:

    • 1. All metals are conductors of electricity; but copper is a metal; therefore copper is a conductor of electricity.
    • Conclusion: Copper is a conductor of electricity.
    • Minor Term (tt): copper
    • Major Term (TT): conductor of electricity
    • Middle Term (MM): metal
    • Major Premise: All metals are conductors of electricity.
    • Minor Premise: Copper is a metal.
    • 2. No insulator is a good conductor of electricity; but copper is a good conductor of electricity; therefore copper is not an insulator.
    • Conclusion: Copper is not an insulator.
    • Minor Term (tt): copper
    • Major Term (TT): insulator
    • Middle Term (MM): good conductor of electricity
    • Major Premise: No insulator is a good conductor of electricity.
    • Minor Premise: Copper is a good conductor of electricity.
    • 3. George Carver was a Negro; but George Carver was an eminent scientist; therefore some eminent scientist was a Negro.
    • Conclusion: Some eminent scientist was a Negro.
    • Minor Term (tt): eminent scientist
    • Major Term (TT): Negro
    • Middle Term (MM): George Carver
    • Major Premise: George Carver was a Negro.
    • Minor Premise: George Carver was an eminent scientist.
    • *4. Every XX is a YY; therefore, since every YY is a ZZ, every XX must also be a Z$.*\n * Conclusion: *Every Xmustalsobeamust also be aZ.*\n * Minor Term (t):∗): *X*\n * Major Term (T):∗): *Z*\n * Middle Term (M):∗): *Y*\n * Major Premise: *Every Yisais aZ.*\n * Minor Premise: *Every Xisais aY.*\n * *5. A good leader has the confidence of his followers; Joe Doe, though, does not have the confidence of his followers, and is therefore not a good leader.*\n * Conclusion: *Joe Doe is not a good leader.*\n * Minor Term (t): *Joe Doe*\n * Major Term (T): *good leader*\n * Middle Term (M): *having the confidence of his followers*\n * Major Premise: *A good leader has the confidence of his followers.*\n * Minor Premise: *Joe Doe does not have the confidence of his followers.*\n * *6. Since winesaps are apples and apples are fruit, winesaps, too, must be fruit.*\n * Conclusion: *Winesaps must be fruit.*\n * Minor Term (t): *winesaps*\n * Major Term (T): *fruit*\n * Middle Term (M): *apples*\n * Major Premise: *Apples are fruit.*\n * Minor Premise: *Winesaps are apples.*\n * *7. Some metal are precious; this follows from the fact that gold and silver which are metals, are precious.*\n * Conclusion: *Some metals are precious.*\n * Minor Term (t): *metals*\n * Major Term (T): *precious*\n * Middle Term (M): *gold and silver*\n * Major Premise: *Gold and silver are precious.*\n * Minor Premise: *Gold and silver are metals.*\n * *8. Diamonds are precious; and since diamonds are stones, it follows that some stones are precious.*\n * Conclusion: *Some stones are precious.*\n * Minor Term (t): *stones*\n * Major Term (T): *precious*\n * Middle Term (M): *diamonds*\n * Major Premise: *Diamonds are precious.*\n * Minor Premise: *Diamonds are stones.*\n * *9. Some mortal are rather stupid. You can infer this from the fact that all men are mortal, and some men are rather stupid.*\n * Conclusion: *Some mortals are rather stupid.*\n * Minor Term (t): *mortals*\n * Major Term (T): *rather stupid*\n * Middle Term (M): *men*\n * Major Premise: *Some men are rather stupid.*\n * Minor Premise: *All men are mortal.*\n\n# General Rules of the Categorical Syllogism and Associated Fallacies\n\n* **Rules Governing the Terms:**\n * **Rule 1 (Number of Terms):**\n * *Formulation:* There must be three terms and only three: the major term, the minor term, and the middle term.\n * *Requirement:* Each term must retain exactly the same objective meaning and be used in the exact same manner across every occurrence.\n * *Equivocation Warning:* A term used with different senses in its occurrences constitutes two distinct terms in reality. The middle term must never be equivocal or ambiguous.\n * *Violation Example:* *Man must eat; but the picture on the wall is a man; therefore the picture on the wall must eat.*\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Four Terms (*Quaternio Terminorum*), Equivocation, or Amphiboly.\n * **Rule 2 (Quantity/Extension of the Major Term):**\n * *Formulation:* The major term (T) may not be universal (distributed) in the conclusion unless it is universal (distributed) in the major premise.\n * *Rationale:* The conclusion cannot assert more than what is justified by the premise.\n * *Violation Example:* *All dogs are mammals; but no men are dogs; therefore no men are mammals.* (Here, *mammals* is undistributed in the affirmative premise, but distributed in the negative conclusion).\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Illicit Major Term (Illicit Process of the Major Term).\n * **Rule 3 (Quantity/Extension of the Minor Term):**\n * *Formulation:* The minor term (t) may not be universal (distributed) in the conclusion unless it is universal (distributed) in the minor premise.\n * *Violation Example:* *Every circle is round; but every circle is a figure; therefore every figure is round.* (*Figure* is undistributed in the minor premise as the predicate of an affirmative proposition, but made universal in the conclusion).\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Illicit Minor Term (Illicit Process of the Minor Term).\n * **Rule 4 (Distribution of the Middle Term):**\n * *Formulation:* The middle term (M) must be universal, or distributed, at least once across the premises.\n * *Rationale:* If the middle term is taken particularly in both occurrences, the two premises may refer to entirely different parts of its extension, preventing any genuine mediation between major and minor terms.\n * *Violation Example:* *A dog is an animal; but a cat is an animal; therefore a cat is a dog.*\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of the Undistributed Middle.\n\n* **Rules Governing the Quality of Propositions:**\n * **Rule 5 (Two Affirmative Premises):**\n * *Formulation:* If both premises are affirmative, the conclusion must be affirmative.\n * *Rationale:* Two affirmative premises establish that both the major and minor terms agree with the middle term; two things agreeing with the same third thing must agree with each other.\n * *Violation Example:* *All sin is detestable; but some pretense is sin; therefore some pretense is not detestable.*\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Negative Conclusion.\n * **Rule 6 (One Affirmative and One Negative Premise):**\n * *Formulation:* If one premise is affirmative and the other negative, the conclusion must be negative.\n * *Rationale:* If one term agrees with the middle term while the other term disagrees with it, the two terms necessarily disagree with each other.\n * *Violation Example:* *Every Bisais aC;butsome; but someAisnotais not aB;thereforesome; therefore someAisais aC.\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Affirmative Conclusion.\n * **Rule 7 (Two Negative Premises):**\n * *Formulation:* If both premises are negative, no conclusion follows whatsoever.\n * *Rationale:* Two negative premises demonstrate that both the major and minor terms disagree with the middle term; no connection or relationship between them can be established.\n * *Violation Example:* *A stone is not an animal; but a dog is not a stone; therefore a dog is not an animal.*\n * *Fallacy Named:* Fallacy of Negative Premises (Exclusive Premises).\n\n* **Rules Governing the Quantity and Existential Import of Propositions:**\n * **Rule 8 (Quantity of Premises):**\n * *Formulation:* At least one premise must be universal. If both premises are particular, no conclusion follows.\n * **Rule 9 (Universal and Particular Premises):**\n * *Formulation:* If one premise is universal and the other is particular, the conclusion must be particular.\n * *Example:* *Every animal is mortal; but every dog is an animal; therefore every dog is mortal.* (Contrasted with mixed premises where particularity must follow).\n * **Rule 10 (Existential Import and Extension Constraints):**\n * *Formulation:* If one premise is universal and the other is particular, the conclusion must be particular.\n * *Philosophical Principle:* Nothing may ever be asserted in the conclusion that has not been asserted implicitly within the premises.\n * *Domain Boundary:* While pure formal logic does not consider existence except incidentally, Rule 10 serves as an indispensable practical aid in argumentation to ensure terms do not overstep existential or extensional warrants.\n\n* **Systematic Evaluation Exercises for Categorical Syllogisms:**\n * *1. All animals are substances; but all frogs are animals; therefore all frogs are substances.*\n * Valid: Complies with all rules of terms and propositions (Form AAA-1).\n * *2. All cows are animals; but no horses are cows; therefore no horses are animals.*\n * Invalid: Violates Rule 2 (Fallacy of Illicit Major). *Animals* is undistributed in the affirmative premise but distributed in the negative conclusion.\n * *3. Murder is sinful; but abortion is murder; therefore abortion is sinful.*\n * Valid: All three terms are univocal and distributed properly (Form AAA-1).\n * *4. Contradictories are opposites; but black and white are opposites; therefore black and white are contradictories.*\n * Invalid: Violates Rule 4 (Fallacy of Undistributed Middle). *Opposites* is the predicate of two affirmative premises and is never distributed.\n * *5. All mammals have lungs; but most fish do not have lungs; therefore most fish are not mammals.*\n * Valid: Follows Rule 6 and distribution rules (Form AOO-2).\n * *6. No dog is a man; but Fido is not a man; therefore Fido is a dog.*\n * Invalid: Violates Rule 7 (Fallacy of Negative Premises). Both premises are negative; no valid conclusion can be derived.\n * *7. All mammals are viviparous; but whales are viviparous; therefore whales are mammals.*\n * Invalid: Violates Rule 4 (Fallacy of Undistributed Middle). *Viviparous* is undistributed in both affirmative premises.\n * *8. Those who are not sick may go; but Johnny is not sick; therefore Johnny may go.*\n * Valid: Proper mediation of terms.\n * *9. No dog is not an animal; but no hound is not a dog; therefore all hounds are animals.*\n * Valid: Double negatives resolve into affirmative propositions (*All dogs are animals; all hounds are dogs; therefore all hounds are animals*).\n * *10. Democracies are free; but some of the governments of the Middle Ages were not democracies; therefore some of the governments of the Middle Ages were not free.*\n * Invalid: Violates Rule 2 (Fallacy of Illicit Major). *Free* is undistributed in the affirmative major premise, but distributed in the negative conclusion.\n\n# Hypothetical Propositions and Syllogisms\n\n* **General Definition of Hypothetical Propositions:**\n * A hypothetical proposition expresses the dependence of one categorical statement (affirmative or negative) upon another categorical statement (which may likewise be affirmative or negative).\n\n* **1. Conditional Hypothetical Propositions:**\n * **Definition:** A proposition stating that the truth of an affirmation or denial is acceptable to the intellect provided (or on condition) that the truth of another affirmation or denial is confirmed or verified.\n * **Two Structural Parts:**\n * **Antecedent:** The component introduced by the operator *"IF"*.\n * **Consequent:** The component introduced by the operator *"THEN"*.\n * Example: *If Sonia has cancer, then she is seriously ill.*\n * Antecedent: *Sonia has cancer*\n * Consequent: *She is seriously ill*\n * **Valid and Invalid Moods of Conditional Syllogisms:**\n * **Modus Ponens (Positing Mood / Empirical Conditional Constructive Syllogism):**\n * *Principle:* The truth of the antecedent implies the truth of the consequent. The fulfillment of the condition necessitates the occurrence of the consequent.\n * *Rule:* Posit (affirm) the antecedent in the minor premise; the consequent must be posited (affirmed) in the conclusion.\n * *Abstract Structure:* If aisisb,then, thenxisisy;but; butaisisb;therefore; thereforexisisy.\n * *Valid Concrete Example:* *If Sharon dances, then she is moving; but Sharon is dancing; therefore, Sharon is moving.*\n * *Fallacy of Rejecting the Antecedent (Invalid Mood):* Committed when the minor premise denies or rejects the antecedent.\n * Example: *If a person has cancer, then he is seriously ill; Mang Kiko is not sick of cancer; therefore, Mang Kiko is not seriously ill.*\n * **Modus Tollens (Sublating Mood / Empirical Conditional Destructive Syllogism):**\n * *Principle:* The falsity of the consequent implies the falsity of the antecedent.\n * *Rule:* Sublate (deny/reject) the consequent in the minor premise; the antecedent must be sublated (denied/rejected) in the conclusion.\n * *Abstract Structure:* If aisisb,then, thenxisisy;but; butxisnotis noty;therefore; thereforeaisnotis notb$$.
      • Valid Concrete Example: If you are honest, then people will admire you; but people do not admire you; therefore you are not honest. [Note: If formulated as denying the antecedent directly—but you are not honest; therefore people will not admire you—it commits the fallacy of denying the antecedent].
  • 2. Disjunctive Hypothetical Propositions:

    • Definition: A hypothetical proposition containing an "either… or" statement indicating that the disjoined alternatives exhaust the scenario and that the implied judgment cannot be false.
    • Example: The participants may either sing or dance.
    • Types of Disjunctive Propositions:
    • Strict Disjunctive: The alternatives implied can neither be true together nor false together. Exactly one alternative is true; the other must be false.
      • Examples:
      • Either the person is alive or he is dead.
      • A man is either married or unmarried.
      • It is either you stay or you go.
    • Imperfect / Improper / Broad Disjunctive: A proposition where the alternative judgments can be true together (the alternatives are not mutually exclusive).
      • The choice is one alternative, the other, or possibly both.
      • Example: The participants may either sing or dance (where participants may sing and dance at the same time).
    • Valid Moods of Disjunctive Syllogisms:
    • Ponendo Tollens (Positing Mood):
      • Rule: The minor premise affirms (posits) one of the alternatives of the major premise, and the conclusion denies (sublates) the other alternative.
      • Valid Example (Strict Disjunctive): The criminal is either dead or alive; but he is alive; therefore, he is not dead.
    • Tollendo Ponens (Sublating Mood):
      • Rule: The minor premise denies (sublates) one of the alternatives of the major premise, and the conclusion affirms (posits) the other alternative.
      • Example: Armand is either a liberated or a conservative person; but he is not conservative; therefore, he is a liberated person. [Contrasted with positing one to sublate: Armand is either a liberated or a conservative person; but he is liberated; therefore, he is not a conservative person].
  • 3. Conjunctive Hypothetical Propositions:

    • Definition: A proposition expressing a judgment that two alternative assumptions cannot and are not true simultaneously.
    • Examples:
    • The students cannot be absent and present at the same time.
    • I cannot be in Viga and Virac at the same time.
    • Valid Mood of Conjunctive Syllogisms:
    • Ponendo Tollens (Positing Mood):
      • Rule: The minor premise posits (affirms) one of the conjuncts, and the conclusion sublates (denies) the other conjunct.
      • Concrete Example:
      • Major Premise: I cannot be in Catanduanes and Manila at the same time.
      • Minor Premise: I am in Catanduanes.
      • Conclusion: Therefore, I am not in Manila.