Disturbance of Ecosystems

Definition of Disturbance

  • Disturbance: An event that alters the biodiversity of a community by removing organisms or changing resource availability.

  • Disturbances can be either positive or negative in their impact.

Examples of Disturbances

  • Fire

  • Human Activity

  • Flood

  • Drought


Ecosystem Resiliency

  • Ecosystem Resiliency: Some ecosystems demonstrate the ability to recover from disturbances within relatively short periods.

  • Positive Disturbances:
      - Forest fires can lead to beneficial ecological outcomes through processes such as secondary succession.


Recovery Time After Disturbance

  • Certain ecosystems require extended periods to recover and may never be restored to their original state.

  • Species extinction can occur due to habitat degradation, leading to reduced biodiversity.

  • Example: Water pollution resulting in mortality for aquatic species such as fish.


Food Web Dynamics in a Salmon–Forest Ecosystem

  • The balance in a salmon-forest ecosystem is represented in a Partial Food Web:   - Key Species:
        - Salmon
        - Bears
        - Berries/Plants
        - Eagles
        - Trout
        - Decomposers

  • Nutrient Flow:
      - Carnivores (e.g., bears) feed on salmon, transferring nutrients to the forest, which are absorbed by trees.   - Trees create shaded ponds vital for juvenile trout's growth, demonstrating matter and low-entropy energy flow.


Impact of Disturbance on Food Web

  • Removal of decomposers leads to nutrient deficiency, hampers tree growth, and results in loss of shade for ponds.

  • The disturbance causes cascading effects:
      - Decline in bear, trout, and eagle populations due to reduced salmon availability.


Disturbances Affecting Ecosystem

  • Disturbances in one part of an ecosystem can induce effects throughout the ecosystem, likened to dominoes falling.

  • Human-Induced Disturbances:
      - Hunting
      - Deforestation (removal of trees)
      - Unsustainable fishing practices
      - Pollution


Case Study: The American Alligator

  • Impact: Historically, seen as a pest and hunted excessively, leading to population decline and endangered status.

  • Resulting Issue:
      - Disappearance of alligators correlating with plummeting game fish populations.
      - Alligators predominantly prey on large fish (e.g., Gar), which increased in number without alligator predation, harming game fish.


Case Study: The Sea Otter

  • Habitat: Sea otters inhabit kelp forests; giant kelp is crucial in producing oxygen and providing habitat.

  • Historical Overhunting: In the 18th century, sea otters were hunted to near extinction for their fur and perceived competition by fishermen.

  • Resulting Ecosystem Changes:
      - Increased sea urchin populations due to the absence of sea otters led to kelp forest degradation, disrupting fish spawning habitats.


Concept of Keystone Species

  • Keystone Species: Species that have a disproportionately large impact on their ecosystem.
      - Example: Sea otters maintain kelp forests; without them, urchin populations explode, destroying kelp and affecting fish.

  • Trophic Cascade: Removing a keystone species leads to population changes across trophic levels, disrupting ecosystem balance.
      - Example: Jaguars as keystone species in Central and South America, controlling prey populations, maintaining ecological balance.


Additional Keystone Species Examples

  • Parrotfish: Cleans corals on the Great Barrier Reef, essential for coral health and ecosystem resilience.

  • Sharks: Highest order predator in Atlantic Ocean food webs; their decline affects populations of tuna, mackerel, and others, creating imbalance in marine ecosystems.


Trophic Cascade and Ecosystem Disruption

  • Through the removal of keystone species (e.g., sharks), food web balance is upset — affecting producers like phytoplankton due to increased shrimp-like creatures that overconsume them.


The Salmon Fishery

  • Commercial Practices: 95% of US commercial salmon fishing occurs off the coast of Alaska employing methods like:   - Gillnets: Net openings designed to entrap fish; fatal for fish as they become gilled.   - Purse Seines: Nets that encircle fish schools, preventing escape as they are collected.


Bycatch Issues in Fishing

  • Bycatch: Unintentional capture of non-target species, including:   - Other fish species
      - Sea turtles
      - Marine mammals (dolphins, whales)

  • Community Disruptions from Bycatch:
      - High mortality rates in returned bycatch.
      - Juvenile fish populations suffering leads to reduced reproductive capacity.
      - Endangered and keystone species included in bycatch.


Reducing Bycatch Solutions

  • Strategies:
      - Use of acoustic devices to deter marine mammals from nets.   - Designing nets with smaller mesh to reduce entrapment of larger species.   - Incorporating weak links in gill nets to allow large animals to escape.   - Providing awareness to fishermen about high-risk areas for bycatch and safe return methods.


Human-Caused Disturbances

  • Examples of human-induced disturbances:
      - Overhunting and overfishing
      - Deforestation
      - Unsustainable farming practices
      - Industrialization and urban development
      - Pollution (water and air)
      - Introduction of invasive species that disrupt native populations.

  • Impact: Human activities have globally affected every ecosystem, both directly and indirectly.


Ecosystem Recovery after Disturbances

  • The possibility of recovery depends on the nature of the disturbance:   - Temporary disturbances allow ecosystems to recover.
      - Persistent disturbances (e.g., invasive species) lead to potential ecosystem collapse.

  • Example: Fishing with lines and hooks may be sustainable, while daily net fishing may lead to severe ecosystem damage.


Biodiversity's Role in Recovery

  • Biodiversity: Increased diversity enhances an ecosystem's resilience and recovery capability.

  • Scenario Comparison:
      - Ecosystem A, with higher biodiversity, better withstands losses (e.g., clams due to parasites) due to multiple food chains supporting top predators.


Human Population Growth

  • Human population has risen exponentially over the past centuries.

  • Carrying Capacity:
      - The maximum population sustainable by available resources, determining when growth levels off.   - Ongoing debate among experts about whether it nears 6 billion or 16 billion.

  • Limitations: Potential limiting factors include:   - Fresh water
      - Food supply
      - Diseases

  • Humans' capability to adapt and modify environments often allows them to exceed anticipated carrying capacities.