Comprehensive Notes on the Protestant Reformation and Catholic Counter-Reformation

Lutheran Tradition

  • Foundational Basis: Based on the teachings of Martin Luther, specifically keyed in on the Book of Romans.
  • Core Theological Doctrine:
    • Justification by Faith: People are justified by grace through faith. They cannot be saved by works or any other human endeavor because humanity is inherently sinful.
    • Priesthood of All Believers: All people are equally sinful and equally saved.
    • Doctrinal Hierarchy: Depravity of mankind is primary; sovereignty of God is secondary.
    • Sola Scriptura: Only follow the Scriptures as the authority for faith and practice.
  • Major Incidents and Timeline:
    1. Posting of the 95 Theses (1517): Prompted directly by the selling of indulgences.
    2. Diet of Worms (1521): Luther was called to account for his writings.
    3. Translation and Writing: Following the Diet of Worms, Luther translated the Bible into German and wrote extensively.
    4. Protestant Precedent: Lutheranism was the first "Protestant" religion, paving the way for several other Protestant movements later on.
  • Key Theologians: Martin Luther, Philip Melanchthon.

Reformed Tradition

  • Swiss Origins: Developed contemporaneously with Luther in Switzerland.
  • Ulrich Zwingli:
    • Swiss reformer based in Zurich.
    • Beliefs were essentially identical to Luther's.
    • Marburg Colloquy: Zwingli and Luther almost agreed on all substantive points of theology and nearly merged their movements.
    • Death: Killed during a religious civil war in Switzerland.
    • Key Reformed Theologians: Ulrich Zwingli, Martin Bucer.
  • John Calvin:
    • French reformer based in Geneva.
    • Systematic Theology: Found in the Institutes of Christianity.
    • Primary Doctrine: Absolute sovereignty of God.
    • Human Condition: Mankind are sinners and deserve eternal damnation.
    • Predestination: God has already chosen who will go to Heaven and who will go to Hell. If a person is saved, that is grace ("right on"); if not, they received what they deserved anyway.
    • Purpose of Existence: "The end of man is to glorify God" (the primary purpose of man is to worship God). This belief created an intense drive in people to attempt to create society in the image of a "New Jerusalem," whether in Geneva, London, or Boston.
    • Spin-Offs and Followers:
    • John Knox: Scottish Presbyterians
    • French Huguenots: French Calvinists
    • Puritans and Separatists: Located in England (the Separatists are more commonly known as "the Pilgrims")
    • Oliver Cromwell: Led much of the British Parliament in 1640 (who were Puritan)

Radical Reformation and the Anabaptist Tradition

  • Overview: Unaffiliated congregations of people who practiced adult/believers' baptism. Referred to as the "left wing" of the Reformation due to their highly liberal stance for their time. Most groups were pacifist and peaceful, though some groups were violent.
  • Key Theologians and Movements:
    • Original Leaders: George Blaurock, Conrad Grebel, Felix Manz, Michael Sattler.
    • Mennonites: Followers of Menno Simons.
    • Amish: Followers of Jacob Amman (formed in the 1600s). Many of the Amish fled to America during the Thirty Years' War and settled in the religiously pluralist colony of Pennsylvania, in what eventually became known as Lancaster County.
    • Quakers: George Fox became known as the founder of the "Quakers."
    • Baptists: Roger Williams (who also founded the colony of Rhode Island in America) is considered the founder of the Baptist Church, and therefore also the Southern Baptist Church.
  • Core Theology:
    • Sola Scriptura
    • Eschatology: Hope for a better life in Heaven
    • Humility and Simpleness
    • Separation from the World
    • Radical Discipleship: Follow Christ to the end / imitation of Christ
    • Believers' Baptism
    • Pacifism
    • Separation of Church and State
  • Reasons for Hostility and Persecution:
    • Separation of Church and State / Infant Baptism Conflict: If no one is baptized in a state church, how does that church gain its members? If the state-sponsored church lacks members, who will instruct the people to follow the king? If no one follows the king, who will protect the church?
    • Pacifism Conflict: If everyone practices pacifism, an effective military force cannot be raised for defense.
  • Modern Descendants: Direct descendants of the Anabaptists continue into the modern day.

English Reformation

  • Catalyst: Began entirely because King Henry VIII could not produce a male heir.
  • Historical Process and Timeline:
    1. Divorce and Break with Rome: Henry VIII obtained a divorce from Catherine, but only after throwing the Catholic Church out of England because the Pope would not grant the divorce.
    2. Act of Supremacy (1534): Officially declared the King to be the supreme head of the English Church.
    3. Reign of Edward: When Henry died, his young son Edward became king. Because he was too young to rule, regents governed for him. Edward died before reaching child-rearing age.
    4. Reign of Mary: Mary (the eldest daughter) ruled after Edward and attempted to re-Catholicize England, but failed. Mary died after being queen for only a few years.
    5. Reign of Elizabeth: Elizabeth became queen after Mary and maintained a neutral theological course, favoring neither Calvin-esque Puritanism nor Catholicism.
  • Important Figures:
    • William Tyndale: Translated the Bible into English.
    • Thomas Cranmer: Served as Archbishop of Canterbury during Edward's reign; was later executed by Queen Mary.

Catholic Counter-Reformation

  • Core Objective: An attempt by Catholics to reform the Church from the inside, rather than allowing it to be reformed by external Protestant forces.
  • Key Figures, Institutions, and Events:
    1. Girolamo Savonarola (1452–1498): Florentine preacher and monk who was executed when he preached against the power of the Pope.
    2. Spanish Inquisition / Cardinal Ximenez: Mechanism for internal reform and enforcement of orthodoxy in Spain.
    3. Ignatius of Loyola and the Society of Jesus (Jesuits): Founded to defend and expand Catholic teachings through discipline, education, and missionary work.
    4. Council of Trent: Major ecumenical council held to redefine Catholic doctrine and execute administrative reforms.