Ethno-Diplomacy: The Uyghur Hitch in Sino-Turkish Relations Notes

About the East-West Center

  • Established by U.S. Congress in 1960
  • Aims to strengthen relations among peoples and nations of Asia, the Pacific, and the U.S.
  • Focuses on education, research, and dialogue on critical issues
  • Funded by U.S. government, private agencies, and regional governments

Ethno-Diplomacy: Uyghur Hitch in Sino-Turkish Relations

Executive Summary
  • Since 1949, China's approach to Uyghur separatism was viewed as a domestic concern.
  • In the early 1990s, recognized international implications due to Uyghur nationalism in Turkey.
  • Historical ties between Uyghurs and Turkey date back to competition over control of Xinjiang in the late 19th century.
  • Turkey has historically provided asylum and support to Uyghur refugees and organizations.
  • Sino-Turkish diplomatic relations began in 1971 but were marginal until the 1990s.
  • China's economic growth shifted power dynamics, enabling Beijing to apply pressure on Ankara to limit Uyghur support.
Historical Context of Sino-Turkish Relations
  • Pre-Republic China: The connection between the Ottoman Empire and China.
  • Republican China: Initial attempts to influence Xinjiang met with resistance.
  • People’s Republic of China (PRC): Hostility ensued after Turkey participated in the Korean War (1950).
Uyghur Nationalism in Turkey
  • Uyghurs, claiming independence from the PRC, turned to Turkey for cultural and political support.
  • Reflects broader Turkic solidarity and historical ties.
  • Multiple waves of Uyghur migration to Turkey since the late 19th century, especially post-1949.
Uyghur Presence and Activism
  • Cultural Organizations: Host significant activism related to Uyghur rights and independence.
  • Key Figures: İsa Yusuf Alptekin and Mehmet Emin Bu˘gra were vital in forging connections between Turkey and Uyghurs.
  • Current State: Various Uyghur organizations exist in Turkey and engage in political activism, yet face challenges due to Chinese pressure on Turkey.
Impact of Chinese Pressure
  • Increased economic, military, and diplomatic ties between Turkey and China since the late 1990s.
  • Military Collaborations: Focus on arms development and counter-terrorism agreements.
  • Ankara’s recent reluctance to support Uyghur causes officially reflects this pressure.
Turkey's Dilemma
  • Balancing cultural affinity with Uyghurs and geopolitical interests with China.
  • The Kurdish issue complicates the Turkish stance; similar claims of ethnic rights can’t be publicly supported for both ethnic groups.
Conclusion: Limits of China's Ethno-Diplomacy
  • China's tightening of relations has subdued Uyghur activism in Turkey but has also led to solidarity and international visibility for their cause.
  • Alternative bases for activism have emerged outside Turkey, notably in Western Europe and North America.
  • The Uyghur issue continues to resonate within Turkey while posing a challenge to Beijing’s diplomatic efforts.