Notes on Theoretical Nursing Models and Theory Categories

Goals of Theoretical Nursing Models

  • Identify domain and goals of nursing.

  • Provide knowledge for nursing administration, practice, education, and research.

  • Guide research and curriculum development.

  • Establish criteria for measuring quality of care.

  • Provide systematic structure for nursing activities.

Grand Theories
  • Abstract, broad, and complex, providing a structural framework for general ideas about nursing.

  • Address the question "What is nursing?" and focus on the whole of nursing.

  • Address nursing metaparadigm components: person, nursing, health, environment.

  • Example: Dorothy Johnson's Behavioral System Model focuses on restoring equilibrium to the behavioral system.

Middle-Range Theories
  • More limited in scope and less abstract; address specific phenomena (e.g., uncertainty, comfort).

  • Often developed from research, practice, or other disciplines.

  • Example: Kolcaba's theory of comfort guides nurses in meeting physical, psychospiritual, environmental, and sociocultural comfort needs.

Practice Theories
  • Also known as situation-specific theories, narrow in scope and focus.

  • Guide care for a specific patient population at a specific time (bring theory to the bedside).

Theory Levels
  • Hierarchy (most to least abstract): Metatheory \to Grand theories \to Middle-range theories \to Practice theories

Types of Theories
  • Descriptive theories: Describe phenomena and identify circumstances of occurrence; help explain patient assessments.

  • Prescriptive theories: Address nursing interventions, guide practice change, and predict consequences.

Theory-Based Nursing Practice
  • Essential for advancing nursing as a practice-oriented profession, deriving knowledge from sciences, experience, and standards.

Shared (Interdisciplinary) Theories
  • Explain phenomena specific to the discipline that developed them, but are applied in nursing.

  • Examples:

    • Piaget's theory of cognitive development: aids pediatric nurses in designing therapeutic play.

    • Knowles' adult learning theory: helps plan discharge teaching.

Shared Theory and Systems in Nursing Practice
  • Many nursing theories are based on systems theory; the nursing process is a system with a specific purpose to guide clinical judgment and deliver person-centered care.

  • Nursing Process Components (as a system):

    • INPUT: Patient interaction with the environment (Psychological, Physiological, Developmental, Sociocultural, Environmental, Spiritual domains).

    • OUTPUT: Patient's health status for returning to the environment.

    • FEEDBACK: Outcomes reflecting patient responses to interventions, family responses, and consultations.

    • CONTENT: Product and information obtained from the system (e.g., skin care needs for impaired bed mobility).

Overview of Select Shared Theories
  • Human needs (Maslow's Hierarchy): Explains that needs motivate human behavior, prioritizing physiological and safety needs before higher-level psychological, sociocultural, developmental, and spiritual needs.

  • Stress/adaptation: Humans adapt to threats to maintain function; requires nursing interventions to support coping.

  • Developmental: Humans have common patterns of growth and development; guides understanding of life-span changes.

Overview of Select Grand and Middle-Range Nursing Theories
  • Henderson's theory (Grand): Nurses assist patients with 14 basic activities (e.g., breathing, eating, hygiene) until they can meet these needs themselves.

  • Johnson's Behavioral System (Grand): Nurses assist patients (perceived as whole, more important than disease) to restore balance and meet needs in their behavioral system.