Personality Stability and Change

Distinguish rank-order from mean-level stability, and explain how a trait can show one without the other

  • Rank-order stability: Whether individuals maintain their relative standing compared to others in a group over time

    • If you are more conscientious than your peers at age 20, and you are still more conscientious than them at age 40, then you still rank the same

    • Measured via test-retest correlations

  • Mean-level stability: Whether the average of a trait across an entire population stays the same or shifts (increases/decreases) with age or time

  • How a trait can show one without the other

    • High rank-order stability + changing mean-level (normative shift)

      • The group average goes up or down, yet every individual moves up or down by roughly the same amount, preserving their exact relative order

      • E.g. Conscientiousness and emotional stability: Across young adulthood, everyone tends to become more conscientious and mature which means there is a mean-level change, however the person that was most conscientious at 18 is most likely to be the most conscientious at 30 (the relative hierarchy hasn't shuffled even though the entire group shifted)

    • Low rank-order stability + high mean-level stability

      • The group's average score at Time 2 is the same as Time 1 (mean-level stability) but individuals positions have completely scrambled

      • E.g. A group of people have the same mean anxiety score from one year to another but individual circumstances have caused some individuals to become highly anxious, and others to become calm, because individual increases offset individual decreases, the mean stays the same while the individuals completely reshuffle

 

Describe normative age trajectories in Big Five traits, and compare intrinsic maturation and social investment as competing explanations


  • Conscientiousness: Most consistent upward trajectory

  • Agreeableness: Increases significantly during young adulthood and increase slowly through middle age

  • Neuroticism: Typically peaks in young adulthood and steadily decreases throughout adulthood

  • Openness to experience: Usually increases in young adulthood, peaks in 20s and remains relatively stable, then in older adults it declines

  • Extraversion:

    • Social vitality (gregariousness, positive affect): Tends to decrease slightly in old age

    • Social dominance (assertiveness, independence): Increases in young adulthood and stabilises in middle age

  • Intrinsic maturation theory: Personality maturation is genetically determined and serves to prepare for reproductive changes (e.g. parenthood requires emotional stability)

  • Social investment theory: The psychological investment in normative roles underlies the changes in trait levels (e.g. because you have a child and are invested in giving them a good up brining your emotional stability increases)

    • Significant life events

  • It is safe to assume personality changes have contribution from the intrinsic maturation theory and the social investment theory as genetics and environmental factors play a role in maturation

 

Explain how person x environment transactions and life events contribute to individual differences in personality change

  • Fraley & Roberts (2005): Model of personality-environment transaction

    • Transactions between:

      • Constant factors (e.g. genes)

      • Personality factors

      • Environmental factors (e.g. life events)

  • Lucas & Donnellan (2011): Age dependency

    • Changes in cognitive and physical performance, disease

    • Serious environmental events (e.g. death of a partner or friend)

  • Protective factors:

    • People can actively avoid new roles or experiences

    • Certain personality traits (e.g. rigidity) could buffer against change and prevent it

 

Critically evaluate evidence that personality traits change through intervention and volitional effort, with reference to measurement confounds such as demoralisation

  • Intervention:

    • Roberts et al. (2017): Meta-analysis of 207 studies demonstrated that psychological interventions are associated with marked, enduring change in personality trait measures

    • Demoralisation: measurement conflation between stable traits and transient states

      • Majority of these studies use self-report questionnaires which means that mood states have a substantial impact on the responses to personality assessment

        • When a patient begins therapy their demoralisation is exceptionally high as they capture their acute stress rather than their baseline personality

        • The supportive environment and therapeutic alliance alleviates their state of demoralisation (e.g. their neuroticism scores plumet dramatically)

    • Neuroticism and low extraversion can be might be amendable to change through therapeutic interventions

  • Volitional change:

    • The role of action over desire: Research has shown that simply desiring or intending to change a trait does not predict actual trait change, and can occasionally result on the opposite as wanting to be more conscientious but failing to execute it can lead someone to feel worse and less motivated

    • True volitional change depends on consistent enactment of trait-congruent behaviours (e.g. doing specific tasks that the more conscientious you would do)

      • The repeated faked behavioural states can solidify into enduring habitual traits