Behaviourism and Language Acquisition
Classifications of Behaviourism
- Methodological Behaviourism: Focuses on observable and measurable behavior and physical causes rather than private introspection.
- Psychological Behaviourism: Attributes behavior to physical forces in the body and environment instead of mental activity.
- Radical Behaviourism: Reduces the mind to the body, viewing thoughts and feelings as physical processes.
- Roots: Originates from British Empiricism (Locke, Hume), focusing on physical stimuli and responses.
Conditioning and the Concept of Free Will
- Reflexes: Pavlov demonstrated that while some reflexes are natural, others can be conditioned and contingent.
- Skinner's View: Influenced by the idea that human behavior is reducible to stimuli-response patterns, suggesting free will is an illusion.
- Counter-evidence: Recent EEG studies indicate that individuals can voluntarily control brain states.
Timeline of Language Acquisition
- Womb to 6 Months: The "sensitive period" where children differentiate sounds of any language.
- 6 Months: Babbling begins with the opening of the vocal tract.
- 1 Year: Typically produces 1 or 2 words.
- 2 Years: Vocabulary of at least 50 words and simple word combinations.
- 3 Years: Rapid vocabulary expansion and understanding of abstract concepts like "now" or "sad."
- Age 7: The "critical period" ends, after which language acquisition capacity is significantly reduced.
Skinner’s Behaviourist Model
- Nurture-based: View that language is acquired entirely through environment and reinforcement.
- Mechanism: Children learn through imitation and positive and negative reinforcement (reward and punishment).
- Tabula Rasa: The brain is considered a blank slate shaped by linguistic stimuli.
Chomsky’s Nativist Criticism
- Poverty of Stimulus Argument: Refutes Skinner by noting children learn complex structures from limited or imperfect examples faster than reinforcement allows.
- Active Learning: Children apply grammatical rules to new words (e.g., "gived") rather than just imitating.
- Language-Acquisition Device (LAD): An innate neural faculty evolved specifically for applying linguistic rules.
- Creole Evidence: The development of Creole from ungrammatical pidgin over generations supports the existence of innate grammar structures.
Universal Grammar and Recursion
- Universal Features: Chomsky argues all languages share basic rules, such as the distinction between nouns and verbs.
- Recursion: The ability to repeat structures indefinitely (e.g., "I know that you know that I know"), which Chomsky considered a universal feature.
- Challenges: The Piranha language is cited as a counter-example because it does not allow recursion, questioning the universality of Chomsky's theories.