Chapter 1 - Obedience

Origins of Social Psychology

Social psychology → the study of how people's thoughts, feelings and behaviour are influenced by the presence of others.

  • Social psychology developed in Europe during the mid-19th century.

  • Early social psychologists were interested in the collective/group mind.

  • Gustave Le Bon (1895) observed that crowds could display mob-like behaviour because individuals changed their behaviour when they became part of a group.

  • The idea that an individual's behaviour can be changed by the presence of others is central to social psychology.

  • Floyd Allport (1924) helped establish experimental social psychology.

    • His book argued that social psychology should use an experimental approach.

    • This led to laboratory investigations of social behaviour.

Today, social psychology investigates:

  • Persuasion and attitude formation

  • Social influence

  • Aggression

  • Group behaviour

  • Obedience

  • Conformity

  • Minority influence

Key Term

Definition

Conformity

a form of social influence where our behaviour are influenced by a majority

Minority influence

a form of social influence where the opinions, beliefs and/or behaviour of the majority are influenced by a minority (individual or small group)

Obedience

complying to the orders of an authority figure

Social influence

how behaviour are influenced by the real or imagined pressure of an individual or group






1. Obedience - Stanley Milgram

Definition

Obedience: compliance with the demands of a real or imagined authority figure.

  • Following authority's demands = obedience

  • Rejecting authority's demands = dissent/resistance

Obedience is usually important for social order and safety, but unquestioning obedience can have harmful consequences.

Why is obedience necessary?

Obedience is an important part of everyday life. We follow instructions from:

  • Teachers

  • Employers

  • Police officers

  • Rules/laws of society

Obedience can:

  • Prevent accidents

  • Maintain social order and stability

  • Allow organisations and society to function.

However, unquestioning obedience can also have serious negative consequences.

Example: During WWII, the Nazi regime ordered the systematic killing of millions of Jewish people. This required collective obedience from many German soldiers.

Milgram investigated obedience partly to understand how ordinary people could carry out destructive orders.

Key term

Definition / meaning

Social influence

The process by which opinions, beliefs and/or behaviour are influenced by other people.

Obedience

Compliance with the demands of a real or imagined authority figure.

Authority figure

A person who is perceived to have the right or power to give orders or demands.

Dissent / resistance

Rejecting or refusing the demands of an authority figure.






1.1 Socialisation of Obedience

Socialisation → the process through which we learn the norms, values and behaviours expected by society.

Milgram argued that human society is hierarchical:

  • A few people occupy positions of authority.

  • Others are expected to follow their instructions.

Why is obedience necessary?

  • Organisations need people to follow instructions.

  • Obedience helps maintain social order and stability.

  • Without obedience, there could be challenges to authority, resulting in chaos and social breakdown.

How do we learn obedience?

We are exposed to authority figures from a young age.

Parents and teachers are important socialising agents.

They encourage obedience through:

  • Rewards for obedient behaviour

  • Punishments/sanctions for disobedience

Obedience is also reinforced through:

  • The education system

  • The legal system

  • Other social institutions

Therefore, obedience becomes an ingrained behaviour through socialisation.

Key term

Definition / meaning

Socialisation

The process through which people learn the behaviours and expectations of their society.

Socialising agents

People/institutions that teach individuals how to behave within society, e.g. parents and teachers.

Rewards

Positive consequences used to encourage obedience.

Punishments

Negative consequences used to discourage disobedience/dissent.

Sanctions

Rewards or punishments used to encourage socially acceptable behaviour and discourage unacceptable behaviour.

Hierarchy

A system in which people or groups are ranked, with some having greater authority or power than others.






1.2 Agency Theory

Stanley Milgram proposed that humans can exist in two psychological states:

Autonomous state:

Autonomy → acting according to your own free will and exercising self-determination.

In an autonomous state:

  • You see yourself as responsible for your own actions.

  • You make your own decisions.

  • Your behaviour is guided by your moral conscience.


Agentic state:

Agentic state → a psychological state in which a person sees themselves as an agent acting on behalf of an authority figure.

When given an instruction by an authority figure:

Autonomous state → authority gives order → agentic state

In the agentic state:

  • The individual sees the authority figure as responsible for their actions.

  • They may obey demands that they would normally reject.

  • They displace responsibility for their behaviour onto the authority figure.


Displacement of responsibility

Displacement of responsibility → when an individual sees the authority figure, rather than themselves, as responsible for their actions.

This can explain why people may carry out actions that conflict with their moral conscience.



1.3 Moral Strain

Moral strain → the discomfort experienced when someone in an agentic state is ordered to do something that conflicts with their moral judgement.

Milgram observed signs of moral strain in participants who were ordered to harm another person.

Signs included:

  • Nervous laughter

  • Sweating

  • Trembling

  • Anxiety

  • Distress

Despite experiencing moral strain, many participants continued to obey.

Key idea

The person may not want to carry out the behaviour, but they continue because they believe that the authority figure is responsible.

This is central to Milgram's agency theory.


Key Term

Definition

Agency

when we act as an agent for another, e.g. obey orders

Autonomy

acting on one's self determination

Confederate

a researcher/actor who pretends to be a participant of a study

Hierarchical

a system of there are leaders and those who follow

Moral strain

experiencing anxiety because you are asked to do something that goes against your moral judgement

Socialisation

the process by which we learn the rules and norms of society through socialising agents, such as parents and teachers







1.4 Evaluation of Agency Theory

I. Strength: Supported by Milgram's research

In Milgram's first obedience experiment:

  • 65% of participants continued to the maximum shock level.

  • Participants showed clear signs of moral strain, such as anxiety and distress.

  • Despite this, they continued obeying the experimenter.

This supports agency theory because participants appeared to be acting as agents of the authority figure rather than acting according to their own moral judgement.

After the experiment, many participants said that the experimenter was responsible for their behaviour.

This supports:

  • Agentic state

  • Displacement of responsibility


II. Strength: Real-life application — My Lai

During the Vietnam War, American soldiers entered the village of My Lai after being ordered to shoot its inhabitants, who were suspected of being Vietcong.

  • Lieutenant Calley ordered his soldiers to shoot.

  • The soldiers killed men, women and children despite receiving no return fire.

  • During his court martial, Calley claimed he was "just following orders."

Agency theory can explain this through displacement of responsibility.

The soldiers saw the authority figure as responsible for their actions rather than themselves.

Application: Understanding agency can help organisations reduce destructive obedience, for example by:

  • Training people to recognise malevolent authority

  • Encouraging people to question harmful orders

  • Creating whistleblower policies that allow harmful behaviour to be reported anonymously


III. Strength: Supporting research — Hofling et al. (1966)

Hofling et al. (1966) conducted a study in a hospital.

Procedure:

  • A confederate pretending to be a doctor telephoned nurses.

  • The "doctor" instructed them to give a patient twice the daily dose of a drug.

  • The drug was actually harmless.

  • The order went against hospital policy.

  • The fake doctor said that he would sign the prescription later.

Findings:

  • 21 out of 22 nurses obeyed the doctor's instructions.

  • Several nurses justified their behaviour by referring to the hospital hierarchy.

Conclusion:
The findings support agency theory because nurses:

  • Accepted the authority of the doctor.

  • Displaced responsibility onto him.

  • Obeyed even though they could not verify his identity and the order broke hospital rules.


I. Weakness: Does not explain individual differences

Agency theory cannot fully explain why some people obey while others resist.

Obedience and dissent may be influenced by:

  • Personality

  • Gender

  • Culture

  • Past experiences

Therefore, agency theory may be too simplistic.


II. Weakness: Does not explain situational factors

Latané (1961) argued that social influence depends on:

  • Proximity → how close the authority figure is

  • Strength → the perceived importance/status of the authority

  • Number → how many sources of authority are present

Therefore, obedience depends on the situation and context, not simply whether someone enters an agentic state.

This makes agency theory potentially reductionist because it does not consider enough situational factors.


III. Weakness: Past experience can affect obedience

An individual's previous experiences with authority can influence whether they obey.

Gretchen Brandt was one of Milgram's participants who resisted the experimenter's orders.

  • She had emigrated to America from Germany.

  • She had grown up during Hitler's rule.

  • Her previous experiences with authoritarianism may have influenced her resistance to authority.

This demonstrates that individual differences and past experiences can affect obedience.

Key Term

Definition

Individual differences

natural variation in human characteristics that may exist between groups when using an independent groups design

Malevolent authority figure

someone who uses their authority for harmful purposes

Reductionist

theory that explains a complex behaviour by isolated factors or a single cause, which ignores other important factors. The theory can be argued to be simplistc

Whistle Blower policy

an organizational procedure that allows individuals to report harmful or unethical behavior anonymously.

→ Its purpose is to encourage people to question harmful orders and reduce destructive obedience.






1.5 Social Power Theory

An alternative explanation of obedience was proposed by French and Raven (1959).

They identified five bases of social power.

Social power → the ability of an individual to influence or control another person because of the type of power they possess.


Five Types/Bases of Social Power:

Type of power

Definition

Example

Coercive power

Ability to punish someone

Teacher giving detention

Reward power

Ability to provide rewards/incentives

Parent giving pocket money

Legitimate power

Power from an official/recognised position

Police officer

Expert power

Power from superior knowledge or expertise

Doctor or specialist

Referent power

Power based on respect or admiration

Celebrity or charismatic leader

Important

A person can influence others when they possess or are perceived to possess one of these forms of power.

However, the effectiveness of power depends on context.

For example:

  • A football referee has legitimate power during a match.

  • That same referee does not have legitimate power over players once they are off the pitch.

  • Reward power only works if the target actually wants the reward.






Evaluation of Social Power Theory

I. Strength: Explains obedience in organisations

Social power theory can explain how organisations create hierarchies of obedience.

For example, in the military:

  • Senior officers have legitimate power over lower-ranking soldiers.

  • They may also have reward power because they can provide incentives.

  • They have coercive power because they can punish/sanction soldiers.

This can help explain why malevolent authority has been involved in war crimes.

Application

The theory can also be used to:

  • Train people to recognise harmful authority.

  • Encourage resistance to destructive orders.

  • Introduce whistleblowing policies.


I. Strength: Can explain Milgram's findings

Social power theory can provide an alternative explanation for why Milgram's participants obeyed.

The experimenter had several possible sources of perceived power:

Legitimate power

  • The experiment took place at Yale University, a highly respected institution.

  • Participants may therefore have seen the experimenter as a legitimate authority.

Expert power

  • The experimenter was presented as a researcher.

  • His lab coat and university setting may have made him appear knowledgeable and trustworthy.

  • Participants may therefore have believed that he knew what he was doing and understood the effects of the shocks.

This perceived power may have encouraged participants to continue obeying.


I. Weakness: Does not explain situational factors

Like agency theory, social power theory does not fully account for context.

Latané (1961) suggested that:

  • Proximity

  • Strength

  • Number

can influence the impact of social influence.

Therefore, simply knowing the authority figure's source of power does not explain the whole process of obedience.


II. Weakness: Does not explain individual differences

Social power theory focuses mainly on the power of the authority figure.

It does not adequately explain differences between the people being influenced.

Obedience/dissent may also depend on:

  • Personality

  • Gender

  • Culture

  • Previous experiences

Therefore, it can also be considered a reductionist explanation of obedience.






1.6 Wider Issues & Debates

I. Nature vs Nurture

Milgram's explanation suggests that obedience is largely a product of nurture.

  • Obedience is learned through socialisation.

  • Parents, teachers and institutions teach us to respect and obey authority.

  • Social situations can trigger and amplify obedient behaviour.

Therefore:

Socialisation + environmental influences → development of obedient behaviour

This supports the nurture side of the nature–nurture debate.


II. Social Control

Social power and obedience can be used as a form of social control.

Positive side:

  • Authority can maintain order and safety.

  • Obedience allows organisations and societies to function effectively.

Negative side:

  • Authority can be abused.

  • People may obey malevolent authority figures.

  • This can lead to destructive behaviour and atrocities.

Key overall idea

Obedience is necessary for society to function, but unquestioning obedience to harmful authority can have extremely serious consequences.










2. Milgram (1963) — Obedience

1. Background & Context

  • Psychologists wanted to understand how the Holocaust was possible.

  • Hannah Arendt described Adolf Eichmann's behaviour as the “banality of evil”:

    • Eichmann appeared to be an ordinary man rather than a “monster”.

    • He claimed he was simply following orders and advancing his career.

  • This raised the question:

    Can ordinary people commit harmful acts simply because they are obeying an authority figure?

  • Milgram designed his study to investigate this.




2.2 Aim

To investigate how obedient people are to an authority figure asking them to administer what they believe are painful electric shocks to another person.




2.3 Methodology

Type of study

  • Controlled observation conducted in a laboratory at Yale University.

  • All 40 participants experienced the same conditions.

  • There was no independent variable, so it was not a true experiment.

  • Covert observation → participants did not know the true aim.

  • Non-participant observation → Milgram observed from behind a one-way mirror and did not take part in the interaction.


Data collected

  • Quantitative: maximum voltage each participant was willing to administer.

  • Qualitative: observations of participants' distress and behaviour.

  • Interview: participants were interviewed afterwards during the debrief.




2.4 Sample

  • Volunteer/self-selected sampling

  • Recruited through a newspaper advertisement in New Haven.

  • 40 American men

  • Aged 20–50

  • Variety of occupations and socioeconomic backgrounds.

    • e.g. postman, nurse

Population

American men living in New Haven, aged 20–50, who read newspapers and came from a range of occupations.




2.5 Procedure

I. Cover story

  • Participants were told the study investigated the effects of punishment on learning and memory.

  • They were told little research existed on the topic.

  • This deception was intended to prevent participants from guessing the true aim and changing their behaviour.


Teacher and learner

  • Participant met a confederate → someone working with the researchers but pretending to be a participant.

  • A rigged draw supposedly decided who was:

    • Teacher

    • Learner

  • In reality, both slips said “teacher”, so the real participant was always the teacher.

  • The learner was always the confederate:

    • 47-year-old Irish-American man

    • Mild-mannered and likeable.



II. Sample shock

  • Teacher received a genuine 45V shock to the wrist before the experiment.

  • This made the shock generator appear authentic.



III. Shock generator

  • Voltage ranged from 15V → 450V.

  • Labels ranged from:

    • “Slight shock”

    • → “Severe shock”

    • → XXX at 450V.

  • The learner's shocks were actually not real.


Standardised verbal prods

If the participant hesitated, the experimenter used these in order:

  1. “Please continue” / “Please go on.”

  2. “The experiment requires that you continue.”

  3. “It is absolutely essential that you continue.”

  4. “You have no other choice, you must go on.”

  • If the participant refused after Prod 4 → experiment ended.

  • If asked about physical damage:

    • Told shocks may be painful but cause no permanent tissue damage.

  • If asked whether the learner wanted to stop:

    • Told the experiment had to continue.



IV. Learner's responses

  • As voltage increased, the learner showed increasing signs of distress.

  • At 300V, the learner:

    • Banged on the wall

    • Then became silent.

  • Despite this, participants were instructed to continue.



V. Observation

  • Milgram observed through a one-way mirror.

  • Some sessions were recorded/photographed.

  • This was a non-participant observation because Milgram was not part of the teacher–learner interaction.



VI. Debrief

Participants were told:

  • The true aim of the study.

  • Why deception had been necessary.

  • That the learner was not actually harmed.

84% later reported that they were glad to have participated.



Observation Type

Non-participant observation

  • Milgram observed from behind a one-way mirror.

  • He was not part of the interaction between teacher and learner.




2.6 Key Results

  • 65% shocked the learner to the maximum 450V.

  • 100% continued to at least 300V.

  • Psychologists had predicted only about 1% would go to the maximum.

  • Participants showed considerable distress:

    • Sweating

    • Groaning

    • Trembling

    • Nervous laughter

    • Digging nails into their skin

  • 3 participants experienced full-blown uncontrollable seizures.

What do the results show?

People can show very high levels of obedience to authority, even when they believe their behaviour is harming another person.




2.7 Conclusion

  • Ordinary people show a strong tendency to obey authority.

  • They may obey even when:

    • It conflicts with their moral values.

    • It appears to cause harm to another person.

  • However, obedience came at a considerable emotional cost, shown by participants' distress.




Factors Increasing Obedience

Milgram identified several situational factors that encouraged obedience:

  • Prestige of Yale University

    • Obedience decreased when the study was moved to a run-down office building.

  • Payment

    • Participants may have felt a sense of obligation because they had been paid.

  • Physical presence of the authority figure

    • The experimenter was directly present.

  • Authority taking responsibility

    • The experimenter stated that he would take responsibility, rather than the participant.




2.8 Evaluation

Strengths

Weaknesses

Standardisation: Environment, prods and learner's responses were tightly controlled → easy to replicate and check reliability.

→ standardization: procedure is same for all studies, so the test should be the same therefore standardized for each participant. (supports reliability)

Demand characteristics: Some participants may have suspected the shocks were not real, reducing validity.

Reduced demand characteristics: Cover story and covert observation meant participants generally believed the study was genuinely about learning and memory → more valid obedience behaviour.

Mundane realism: Shocking someone over an incorrect word-pair answer is not a realistic everyday task.

Qualitative data: Recordings captured participants' comments and visible distress → gives insight into their internal conflict.

Generalisability: Sample consisted only of American men → findings may not apply to women or other cultures.

Objectivity: Voltage was a quantitative measure that did not require researcher interpretation → reduced researcher bias.

Ecological validity: Laboratory setting and cover story do not closely resemble real-life obedience situations, such as the Holocaust.

→ Ecological Validity: The extent to which the findings of a study can be generalised to other settings and situations.

→ Mundane Realism: The extent to which the tasks and procedures used in a study reflect real-life situations.




2.9 Ethical Issues

Arguments that the study was more ethical

  • Milgram was a pioneer of debriefing.

  • He arranged a reconciliation between the participant and learner.

  • The learner acted in a friendly way and reassured participants that no harm had occurred.

  • This aimed to leave participants in a state of wellbeing.

Arguments that the study was less ethical

Protection from harm

  • Participants experienced considerable psychological distress.

  • 3 had full seizures.

  • Some may have experienced longer-term psychological harm after realising they were capable of acting against their own morals.

Deception

  • Participants were deceived about:

    • The true aim → told it was about learning/memory.

    • The shocks → believed they were real.

  • Discovering the deception could potentially reduce trust in psychologists or authority figures.




2.10 Application to Everyday Life

Training and education

  • Findings have been used to teach people how to resist harmful obedience.

  • Shows how difficult it can be to resist orders from an authority figure.

  • Some armed forces have incorporated research like this into training to emphasise resisting orders that conflict with moral/ethical principles.




2.11 Issues & Debates — Individual vs Situational Explanations

Individual explanation

  • 35% refused to continue to the maximum voltage.

  • This suggests individual differences can affect obedience.

  • Personal factors, such as empathy for the learner, may override obedience.

Situational explanation

Milgram emphasised the importance of situational factors:

  • Paid participants → possible sense of obligation.

  • Prestigious Yale University.

  • Visible authority figure, e.g. grey lab coat.

  • Participants believed they were contributing to valuable scientific research.

  • Under these conditions, 100% obeyed to at least 300V.

Overall: The study supports the idea that both individual and situational factors can influence obedience, although Milgram particularly emphasised the situation.





Key Numbers ⭐

Number

What it represents

40

Participants

40/40

All participants were male

20–50

Age range

450V

Maximum shock

65%

Shocked to 450V

100%

Shocked to at least 300V

~1%

Psychologists' predicted maximum obedience

84%

Later said they were glad to participate

3

Participants who had full-blown seizures

45V

Genuine sample shock

300V

Learner banged on wall and then became silent

35%

Did not continue to maximum voltage













3. Milgram’s Variation Studies

Milgram conducted variations of his original study to investigate why obedience was so high and which situational factors increased obedience.

Baseline condition

  • Learner gave increasingly strong verbal protests from 75V, including complaints about his heart condition.

  • This was used as the baseline for later variations.



3.1 Telephonic Instructions — Experiment 7

What changed?

  • Experimenter initially gave instructions face-to-face, then left the room.

  • Further instructions were given over the telephone.


Result

  • Obedience to the maximum 450V fell from 65% → 22.5%.

  • Some participants:

    • Administered lower shocks instead.

    • Lied to the experimenter about increasing the voltage.


Conclusion

  • Proximity of the authority figure is an important situational factor.

  • Greater distance from the authority → more dissent and less obedience.

  • When the experimenter returned and gave instructions face-to-face, obedience increased again.


Supporting evidence

  • Sedikides & Jackson (1990): People were more likely to follow a zookeeper's instruction when he was physically present than when visitors had left the room.




3.2 Rundown Office Block — Experiment 10

What changed?

  • Study moved from prestigious Yale University to a rundown office building in Bridgeport.

  • Participants were told it was conducted by a private company called Research Associates of Bridgeport, rather than Yale.


Result

  • Obedience fell to 47.5%.


Conclusion

  • The legitimacy/status of the authority affects obedience.

  • Prestigious institutions such as Yale make the authority appear more legitimate → greater obedience.

  • Less prestigious setting → more dissent.


Evaluation

  • The office setting may have had greater ecological validity because it was more like a natural environment.

  • However, the task itself remained unrealistic, so ecological validity was still limited.




3.3 Ordinary Man Gives Orders — Experiment 13

What changed?

  • The usual experimenter/authority figure left the room.

  • An ordinary man/confederate remained and instructed the participant to increase the shock level after mistakes.

  • This tested the importance of authority and status.


Result

  • 80% (16/20) stopped before the maximum shock.

  • Only 20% obeyed to the maximum.


Conclusion

  • The presence and legitimacy of an authority figure strongly influences obedience.

  • Removing the recognised authority → considerable dissent.


Limitation

  • Some authority still remained because the original experimenter had already given the participant instructions before leaving.




Overall Conclusion from the Variations

Milgram's variations show that situational factors influence obedience, particularly:

Situational factor

Effect on obedience

Authority is physically close

↑ Obedience

Authority is physically distant

↓ Obedience

Authority has high status/legitimacy

↑ Obedience

Authority has low status / is absent

↓ Obedience

🔑 Key results to remember

  • Original: 65% → maximum 450V

  • Telephone: 22.5% → maximum 450V

  • Rundown office: 47.5% → maximum

  • Ordinary man: 20% → maximum

Overall: The variations provide strong support for a situational explanation of obedience: changing the authority's proximity and legitimacy substantially changes how willing people are to obey.














4. Factors Affecting Obedience and Dissent/ Resistance to Obedience

4.1 Individual Differences — Personality

Authoritarian Personality

An authoritarian personality is someone (an agent) with a strong obedience to authority, complies and follows established rules and has the tendency to submit to people perceived as superior.

→ A personality type in which a person strongly follows rules, obeys authority and tends to submit to people seen as superior.


Adorno et al. (1950) developed the F-Scale to measure authoritarian personality.

  • Authoritarian people tend to be submissive to authority and strongly support social rules and order.

  • Milgram & Elms (1966):

    • Compared 20 obedient and 20 dissenting participants.

    • Obedient participants had higher F-Scale scores → more authoritarian.

  • Dambrun & Vatiné (2010):

    • Found that people with higher authoritarian scores were more likely to obey in a virtual Milgram-type study.

  • Evaluation: F-Scale findings show a correlation, so authoritarian personality cannot be said to directly cause obedience.




4.2 Locus of Control

Rotter (1966) proposed two types:

Internal locus of control

External locus of control

Believe they are responsible for their own actions.

Believe behaviour is influenced by external factors.

More independent/resistant to outside influence.

More likely to be influenced by others.

More likely to dissent.

→ connects to agency theory

More likely to obey authority.

Milgram's findings

  • 118 participants from Experiments 1–4 were asked who was responsible for the shocks.

  • Dissenters: blamed themselves more (48%) and the experimenter (39%).

  • Obedient participants: were more likely to blame the learner (25%) than dissenters (12%).

  • This suggests obedient people are more likely to displace responsibility, consistent with an external locus of control.


Blass (1991)

  • People with an external locus of control were more likely to:

    • Obey the experimenter.

    • Blame the experimenter.

  • However, Blass argued obedience is an interaction between personality and situation.




4.3 Individual Differences — Gender

Milgram's Experiment 8

  • Tested 40 women.

  • Women showed almost the same obedience as men: 65% reached maximum shock.

  • 27.5% stopped at 300V.

  • Women showed higher anxiety than men despite similar obedience levels.


Other research

  • Sheridan & King (1972):

    • Used a live puppy receiving genuine shocks.

    • All 13 women reached maximum shock compared with about half of men.

  • Blass (1999):

    • Reviewed 10 obedience studies.

    • Found similar obedience levels for men and women in 9/10 studies.

  • Kilham & Mann (1974):

    • Australia: women were less obedient (16%) than men (40%).

Conclusion

  • Evidence for gender differences is inconsistent.

  • Overall, there appears to be little reliable difference in obedience between men and women.





4.4 Cultural Factors

Culture can influence how people respond to authority.

Individualistic cultures

  • Emphasise independence and individual freedom.

  • More likely to tolerate dissent.


Collectivistic cultures

  • Emphasise group cooperation and interdependence.

  • Compliance may be more important for group stability.

  • Could therefore produce greater obedience.


Blass (1999)

  • Reviewed obedience research from different cultures.

  • Differences in obedience percentages may appear to suggest cultural differences.


However...

Differences may actually be caused by methodological differences, rather than culture.

For example:

  • Ancona & Pareyson (1968), Italy: 85% obedience.

    • Maximum shock was only 330V, compared with Milgram's 450V.

    • Milgram's own proximity condition produced 73%, making the results more comparable.

  • Other studies used different samples and shock levels.


Frey (2020)

  • Analysed COVID-19 contact-tracing/mobility data.

  • Individualistic countries showed more movement during lockdown than collectivistic countries despite similar restrictions.

  • Suggests collectivistic cultures may show greater compliance.


Conclusion

The effect of culture on obedience is complex and unclear, partly because studies use different procedures and there is limited comparable research across cultures.





4.5 Situational Factors — Social Impact Theory

Latané (1981) proposed that the influence of an authority figure depends on three factors:

Factor

Meaning

Effect

Strength

Status/power of authority

Greater strength → ↑ influence

Immediacy

Physical closeness

Greater proximity → ↑ influence

Number

Number of authority figures

More authority figures → ↑ influence

Link to Milgram

  • Original obedience = 65%.

  • Obedience changed depending on:

    • Proximity of experimenter.

    • Legitimacy/status of authority.

  • Telephone variation → obedience fell to 22.5%.

  • Rundown office → 47.5%.

  • Ordinary man → 20%.

Conclusion: Situational factors can strongly influence whether people obey or dissent.


Supporting research — Meeus & Raaijmakers (1986)

  • Participants were ordered to be psychologically cruel to a job applicant.

  • Experimenter present: >90% obeyed.

  • Experimenter left: ~36% obeyed.

  • Supports the importance of proximity.