Bordwell and Thompson - Film History - An Introduction (4th Edition) - Chapter 4

Chapter 4: The French Film Industry After World War I

Film Production Decline Post-War

  • French film production experienced a drastic decline during WWI due to resource allocation for the war effort.

  • Post-war, only 20-30% of films screened in France were French; American films dominated the market.

  • French companies struggled to produce films, releasing fewer than 100 features annually, while the U.S. produced 500+.

Competition from Imported Films

  • The influx of imported films (primarily American) was a major issue.

  • Despite a decline in American films in the mid-to-late 1920s, other countries like Germany and Great Britain gained market share at a faster pace.

  • The domestic market in France was too small for films to recuperate production costs without exportation.

  • Very few French films found success abroad, and the American market was largely closed to them.

  • French filmmakers relied on exchanges with culturally similar areas like Belgium and French colonies.

Disunity Within the Film Industry

  • The lack of an oligopoly led to conflicts between production firms, exhibitors, and distributors.

  • Major firms like Pathé and Gaumont owned only 10-15% of French cinemas.

  • Independent theater owners favored cheaper American films which reduced the demand for domestic productions.

  • Efforts by producers for governmental intervention to limit imports were largely unsuccessful.

  • High ticket taxes (6-40%) further hindered all levels of the industry, hampering earnings and production opportunities.

Outdated Production Facilities

  • French producers relied on pre-war glass studios, lacking investment to update facilities.

  • Absence of capital investment hindered technological advancements in lighting compared to American studios.

  • French filmmakers traditionally used sunlight for lighting; American filmmakers utilized artificial lighting for effects, creating a stark difference in production quality.

Major Postwar Genres and Filmmakers

  • Though experiencing crises, the French industry produced a variety of films: serials, historical epics, fantasy films, and comedies.

  • Popular serials returned themes of crime but shifted towards sentimental narratives.

  • Prominent figures included Louis Feuillade (Tih Minh), Henri Diamant-Berger, and filmmakers focusing on historical epics and fantasies.

  • René Clair was a key figure in fantasy films, with innovative techniques like freeze frames and unmoving actors.

The French Impressionist Movement

  • Between 1918 and 1929, a new wave of filmmakers sought to establish cinema as a legitimate art form, leading to the Impressionist movement.

  • Impressionism aimed for pictorial beauty and psychological depth in films.

  • Directors like Abel Gance, Germaine Dulac, and Jean Epstein explored personal expressions through film.

  • The movement faced challenges due to industrial crises but thrived on innovation and experimentation.

Key Directors and Their Contributions

  • Abel Gance: Gained prominence with La Dixième symphonie (1918), blending music and visual expression.

  • Marcel L’Herbier and Jean Epstein produced significant works that highlighted symbolic and revolutionary narratives.

  • Directors balanced avant-garde projects with commercially viable films to maintain their artistic pursuits.

Impressionist Techniques and Theories

  • The Impressionists diverged from traditional narratives, focusing on emotions and psychological motivations.

  • Use of visual rhythm became a hallmark, emphasizing the subjective experience of characters.

  • Emphasized techniques such as superimpositions, POV shots, and a focus on character subjectivity rather than mere action.

Decline of Impressionism

  • By the mid-1920s, new filmmakers adopted Impressionist techniques, diffusing their uniqueness.

  • Financial pressures and the industry’s consolidation contributed to a decline.

  • The arrival of sound cinema presented additional challenges, making it harder for Impressionist filmmakers to compete and maintain independent productions.

Conclusion

  • The Impressionist movement had a lasting impact on cinema, influencing international filmmakers and reshaping narrative and visual storytelling.

  • Despite the challenges faced within the filmmaking industry, the innovations and artistic expressions of the Impressionist movement provided a significant contribution to film as an art form.