youtube video 6.3
Context of the Clinical Encounter
Midwife/nurse conducting an INITIAL ANTENATAL ASSESSMENT.
Routine practice: all women are screened for family & domestic violence (FDV) during pregnancy because:
Violence can begin or escalate in pregnancy.
Protects both mother & fetus.
Emphasis on confidentiality:
Information recorded in Katie’s personal medical record.
Duty to breach confidentiality only if safety of Katie or baby is at risk.
External services may be contacted in that circumstance.
Screening Process & Questions Used
Permission sought: “Are you okay if I ask you some of these questions?” (patient-centred, trauma-informed approach).
Core questions asked:
Has anyone ever put you down, humiliated, embarrassed, or tried to control what you say/do?
Has partner ever hurt or threatened to hurt you?
Follow-up probing for specific examples when red flags appear: “What do you mean by ‘gets a bit rough’?”
Katie’s Disclosures (Verbatim Content + Clinical Interpretation)
Controlling behaviours disclosed:
Mark “likes to know where I am all the time.”
Must ask permission to go to shops/appointments; described as “normal” & “protective.”
He checks phone & email; accuses her of affairs (PARANOIA ⇒ red flag for coercive control).
Emotional abuse:
Calls her “useless,” “selfish bitch.”
Repeated insults while she is fatigued from pregnancy.
Physical intimidation / violence:
Throws objects “around” and at her when angry.
Recently pushed her (physical contact ⇒ assault even if ‘not that bad’ in her words).
Gaslighting / Minimisation:
Katie repeatedly excuses behaviour: “He doesn’t do it to be mean… he just cares.”
Rationalises with Mark’s stress: police job, unplanned baby, financial pressure, has children with ex-partner.
Isolation & financial control:
She stopped working because “Mark thought it would be best.”
Creates dependence and limits her social exposure.
Midwife’s Clinical Responses & Support Offered
Normalises stress of pregnancy but names behaviour as abusive (“These behaviours don’t sound normal to me”).
Explains that abuse can be non-physical (psychological, social, financial).
Warns that abuse can escalate during pregnancy & postpartum.
Provides MULTIPLE SUPPORT OPTIONS:
Info booklet: “Finding Help.”
Social Worker referral (next visit if time constrained).
Domestic Violence phone line – available hours a day, days a week (confidential).
Safety check: “Do you think you’re SAFE to go home today?”
Encourages follow-up: “Feel free to make an antenatal appointment to see someone.”
Underlying Concepts & Significance
Coercive Control: Pattern of domination (monitoring movements, phone surveillance, financial dependence).
Cycle of Violence: Tension-building → Incident (throwing/pushing) → Reconciliation/minimisation → Calm.
Pregnancy as High-Risk Period: Hormonal changes, increased dependency, added stress can trigger or worsen abuse.
Duty of Care & Mandatory Reporting: Health professionals must balance confidentiality with obligation to act if imminent harm.
Trauma-Informed Care Principles demonstrated:
Consent before questioning.
Validation of feelings.
Offering choices & autonomy.
Ensuring privacy and safety planning.
Ethical, Philosophical & Practical Implications
Autonomy vs. Protection: Respecting Katie’s choices while safeguarding mother & fetus.
Potential impact on fetal development: Stress hormones, injury risk.
Intergenerational trauma: Children exposed to FDV may face long-term psychological effects.
Role conflict for Mark as a policeman: May deter Katie from seeking help (fear he “knows the system”).
Importance of non-judgmental language to counter self-blame.
Key Take-Home Points for Examination
Always obtain informed consent prior to FDV screening.
Red flags include: constant monitoring, name-calling, isolation from work/social roles, physical aggression (pushing/throwing objects).
Abuse ≠ only physical; emotional, psychological, financial, and social forms equally harmful.
Safety assessment must be conducted before discharge if abuse suspected.
Provide multiple discreet resources (booklet, helpline, social worker) & respect patient’s pace.
Documentation: Record disclosures factually in medical notes; may become legal evidence.
Know local referral pathways (social work, shelters, legal aid, crisis lines).
Possible Examination Questions to Anticipate
“List and explain at least FOUR non-physical signs of domestic abuse.”
“Describe the steps you would take after a patient discloses partner violence during antenatal care.”
“Explain why pregnancy is considered a high-risk period for escalation of domestic violence.”
“Outline the ethical principles involved when balancing patient confidentiality with duty to protect.”