youtube video 6.3

Context of the Clinical Encounter

  • Midwife/nurse conducting an INITIAL ANTENATAL ASSESSMENT.

  • Routine practice: all women are screened for family & domestic violence (FDV) during pregnancy because:

    • Violence can begin or escalate in pregnancy.

    • Protects both mother & fetus.

  • Emphasis on confidentiality:

    • Information recorded in Katie’s personal medical record.

    • Duty to breach confidentiality only if safety of Katie or baby is at risk.

    • External services may be contacted in that circumstance.

Screening Process & Questions Used

  • Permission sought: “Are you okay if I ask you some of these questions?” (patient-centred, trauma-informed approach).

  • Core questions asked:

    • Has anyone ever put you down, humiliated, embarrassed, or tried to control what you say/do?

    • Has partner ever hurt or threatened to hurt you?

  • Follow-up probing for specific examples when red flags appear: “What do you mean by ‘gets a bit rough’?”

Katie’s Disclosures (Verbatim Content + Clinical Interpretation)

  • Controlling behaviours disclosed:

    • Mark “likes to know where I am all the time.”

    • Must ask permission to go to shops/appointments; described as “normal” & “protective.”

    • He checks phone & email; accuses her of affairs (PARANOIA ⇒ red flag for coercive control).

  • Emotional abuse:

    • Calls her “useless,” “selfish bitch.”

    • Repeated insults while she is fatigued from pregnancy.

  • Physical intimidation / violence:

    • Throws objects “around” and at her when angry.

    • Recently pushed her (physical contact ⇒ assault even if ‘not that bad’ in her words).

  • Gaslighting / Minimisation:

    • Katie repeatedly excuses behaviour: “He doesn’t do it to be mean… he just cares.”

    • Rationalises with Mark’s stress: police job, unplanned baby, financial pressure, has 22 children with ex-partner.

  • Isolation & financial control:

    • She stopped working because “Mark thought it would be best.”

    • Creates dependence and limits her social exposure.

Midwife’s Clinical Responses & Support Offered

  • Normalises stress of pregnancy but names behaviour as abusive (“These behaviours don’t sound normal to me”).

  • Explains that abuse can be non-physical (psychological, social, financial).

  • Warns that abuse can escalate during pregnancy & postpartum.

  • Provides MULTIPLE SUPPORT OPTIONS:

    • Info booklet: “Finding Help.”

    • Social Worker referral (next visit if time constrained).

    • Domestic Violence phone line – available 2424 hours a day, 77 days a week (confidential).

  • Safety check: “Do you think you’re SAFE to go home today?”

  • Encourages follow-up: “Feel free to make an antenatal appointment to see someone.”

Underlying Concepts & Significance

  • Coercive Control: Pattern of domination (monitoring movements, phone surveillance, financial dependence).

  • Cycle of Violence: Tension-building → Incident (throwing/pushing) → Reconciliation/minimisation → Calm.

  • Pregnancy as High-Risk Period: Hormonal changes, increased dependency, added stress can trigger or worsen abuse.

  • Duty of Care & Mandatory Reporting: Health professionals must balance confidentiality with obligation to act if imminent harm.

  • Trauma-Informed Care Principles demonstrated:

    • Consent before questioning.

    • Validation of feelings.

    • Offering choices & autonomy.

    • Ensuring privacy and safety planning.

Ethical, Philosophical & Practical Implications

  • Autonomy vs. Protection: Respecting Katie’s choices while safeguarding mother & fetus.

  • Potential impact on fetal development: Stress hormones, injury risk.

  • Intergenerational trauma: Children exposed to FDV may face long-term psychological effects.

  • Role conflict for Mark as a policeman: May deter Katie from seeking help (fear he “knows the system”).

  • Importance of non-judgmental language to counter self-blame.

Key Take-Home Points for Examination

  • Always obtain informed consent prior to FDV screening.

  • Red flags include: constant monitoring, name-calling, isolation from work/social roles, physical aggression (pushing/throwing objects).

  • Abuse ≠ only physical; emotional, psychological, financial, and social forms equally harmful.

  • Safety assessment must be conducted before discharge if abuse suspected.

  • Provide multiple discreet resources (booklet, helpline, social worker) & respect patient’s pace.

  • Documentation: Record disclosures factually in medical notes; may become legal evidence.

  • Know local referral pathways (social work, shelters, legal aid, crisis lines).

Possible Examination Questions to Anticipate

  • “List and explain at least FOUR non-physical signs of domestic abuse.”

  • “Describe the steps you would take after a patient discloses partner violence during antenatal care.”

  • “Explain why pregnancy is considered a high-risk period for escalation of domestic violence.”

  • “Outline the ethical principles involved when balancing patient confidentiality with duty to protect.”