6.11 Reform Movements in the Gilded Age

Reform Movements in the Gilded Age

Industrial Capitalism

  • Refers to the massive change in the way America produced goods.
  • Shift from artisans/skilled laborers making goods by hand to factories mass-producing goods with unskilled labor.
  • Factories sprang up rapidly, employing tens of thousands and selling goods nationally and internationally.
  • Laissez-faire capitalism allowed businesses to flourish with minimal government intervention.
  • Wealth concentrated in the hands of the elite upper class.
  • Factory workers faced low wages, dangerous conditions, and long hours (12-14 hour days). This often resulted in a miserable existence for a large sector of society.

Responses to Industrial Capitalism

  • Artists and critics, including agrarians, utopians, socialists, and advocates of the social gospel, called for reform.
Henry George
  • Politician and economist.
  • Believed it was foolish for a nation to generate so much wealth while many citizens lived in poverty.
  • Proposed a "single tax on land" to address this inequality.
  • Argued that landowners gained disproportionate wealth from the increasing value of their land and should be taxed more to level the playing field.
Utopians
  • Edward Bellamy: An artist who challenged industrial capitalism through utopian art. Written in 1888, "Looking Backward" envisions America transformed into a socialist utopia where capitalism is crushed and everyone's needs are met.
Socialism
  • Gained traction during this period as a challenge to capitalism.
  • Advocates for community ownership and regulation of the means of production to benefit everyone equally.
  • Some believed capitalism had failed in the late 19th century.
  • Eugene V. Debs: Head of a significant union, founded the Socialist Party of America in 1901.
  • Debs ran for president on the Socialist Party ticket, but the party eventually declined.
Social Gospel
  • Advocates believed Christian principles should be applied to cure societal ills, not just individual souls.
  • Protestant preachers crusaded for social justice for the urban poor during the last 20 years of the 19th century.
  • Urged the middle class to address urban poverty as a Christian duty.

Women and Reform

  • Women took up various causes of reform during this period.
  • Jane Addams established settlement houses to help immigrants assimilate.
Women's Suffrage
  • Movement for women's right to vote.
  • 1890: Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony founded the National American Woman Suffrage Association (NAWSA).
  • NAWSA worked to secure the franchise for women (though constitutional fruit won't come until 1920).
Temperance
  • Fight against alcohol consumption.
  • Drunkenness was a significant problem among urban male factory workers, contributing to impoverishment.
  • 1874: Women formed the Women's Christian Temperance Union.
  • Crusaded for total abstinence from alcohol.
  • Grew to around 500,000 members by 1898.
  • Worked through peaceful means like protest and lobbying.
Carrie Nation
  • A more radical figure in the temperance movement.
  • Known for hacking at liquor barrels in saloons with a hatchet.
  • Saw herself as doing the Lord's work, destroying alcohol because the lord didn't like alcohol.