Untitled
The post-economic liberalisation era witnessed scams with cyclical regularity in the Indian capital market. The series of scams in the capital market may lead someone to believe that scams and liberalisation are correlated phenomena.
The most infamous scam, known as the 1992 securities scam, was masterminded by Harshad Mehta and other bull operators, not without the connivance and collusion of banks. The consequences were so serious that the BSE remained closed for a month. This was followed by scams by unscrupulous promoters, mostly of finance companies, who exploited free pricing to raise money through price rigging.
Price rigging and grey market activities were common, where share prices were quoted at a premium before listing on exchanges. For example, a Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund unit worth Rs. 10 was quoted at Rs. 28 during the subscription period. In 1995, the M. S. Shoes scam, led by Pavan Sachdeva, rigged prices, leading to a crash and a three-day market closure. In December 1995, the Reliance share issue—share-switching scam involved Fair Growth Financial Services, Reliance Industries, and the stock exchange, resulting in a three-day suspension of trading in RIL scrip.
C. R. Bhansali, a chartered accountant, in 1997 identified weaknesses in the regulatory framework of the financial system and manipulated CRB capital markets to attract unlimited deposits. Price rigging became a recurring problem in the Indian capital market. In 1998, various scrips, including BPL, Videocon, and Sterlite, experienced price rigging, causing a payment crisis. This led to the sacking of key BSE board members by SEBI for insider trading.
The history of insider trading repeated in March 2001 when Anand Rathi of the BSE was caught and sacked alongside other directors. Ketan Parekh exploited loopholes, leading to market turmoil. Common practices among scamsters included price manipulation and collusion among bankers, brokers, and promoters, often during public issues or mergers.
The 1991–92 Securities Scam (Harshad Mehta Scam)
In 1991, changes in government policy initiated a market-oriented economy. Economic liberalisation required banks to improve profitability, leading to the free interest rate regime and trading in government securities. This resulted in a spike in interest rates and capital losses for banks, compelling them to trade new financial instruments like repos. Illegitimate ready forward deals emerged, often based on inside information, which were confirmed by the RBI's interim report. Misuse of bank receipts and overvaluation of transactions added to this financial fraud.
Harshad Mehta injected bank funds into share trading, skyrocketing prices of selected scrips. The BSE Sensex peaked dramatically before crashing, with the monetary size of the fraud estimated at Rs. 3,542 crore. Regulatory responses evolved as the Reserve Bank banned inter-bank repos after the scam surfaced.
The 2001 Scam (Ketan Parekh Scam)
As global investment gravitated towards ICE (Information Technology, Communication, and Entertainment) shares, Ketan Parekh manipulated new economy stocks, raising their prices. He operated through several brokers and had substantial financial backing, pushing prices to unsustainable levels. The Sensex peaked at 6,100 before crashing due to a global economic downturn, leading to a financial crisis for many operators.
Parekh defrauded banks, most notably Madhavpura Mercantile Cooperative Bank, by receiving pay orders without sufficient collateral. His arrests came after substantial stock price declines, and the SEBI banned several products following the crisis.
Comparison of the Harshad Mehta Scam and Ketan Parekh Scam
Both scams used price rigging and involved collusion with banks and mutual funds. However, their mechanics differed, with Mehta exploiting old economy stocks while Parekh manipulated new economy stocks. The underlying financial system flaws led to each crisis, which ultimately drove reform attempts post-scam.
Conclusion
The cyclical nature of scams in capital markets demands proactive regulatory measures. Regulators must create systems for early detection and impose strict penalties to ensure market integrity. The health of the capital market depends on a robust banking system, requiring both sectors to exercise self-discipline for sustainable growth.
After India opened its economy, there were many scams in the capital market. One of the biggest was the 1992 securities scam, led by Harshad Mehta with help from banks. This caused the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) to shut down for a month. Other scams involved promoters of finance companies taking advantage of free pricing and manipulating stock prices. For instance, a mutual fund unit worth Rs. 10 was sold for Rs. 28 at one point. In 1995, the M. S. Shoes scam led to another market crash and closure for three days. Later, in December 1995, a scam involving Reliance shares resulted in a similar trading suspension. There were also issues in 1997 when C. R. Bhansali pointed out weaknesses in regulations and took deposits illegally. Price manipulation became a regular problem, with stocks like BPL and Videocon getting rigged in 1998, leading to a financial crisis and the dismissal of some BSE board members due to insider trading. The pattern repeated in 2001 when Anand Rathi was caught for insider trading. Ketan Parekh took advantage of loopholes in the system as well, causing market chaos. Common tricks among fraudsters included manipulating stock prices and colluding with bankers and brokers, especially during public offerings. In 1991, government policy changes aimed to create a market-friendly economy but also led to many financial scams.
The 2001 scam, known as the Ketan Parekh scam, involved manipulating technology stocks as they became popular. His actions resulted in unsustainable price inflation, and when the market crashed, he defrauded banks, leading to his eventual arrest. Comparing the scams, both used price rigging and manipulation but targeted different sectors: Mehta focused on traditional companies, while Parekh targeted newer technology firms. These crises highlighted flaws in the financial system and drove changes in regulatory measures to prevent future issues.
In conclusion, scams around the capital market happen repeatedly, emphasizing the need for better regulations to catch them early and to ensure that both banks and stock markets operate responsibly for lasting growth.