Article on Translating Symptoms to Neurobiological Targets

Concept of Basic Symptoms (BSs)

  • Integrated findings on the early symptomatic course of schizophrenia and in vivo evidence of brain aberrations.

  • BSs viewed as subtle, subclinical disturbances in mental processes, expressing the underlying neurobiological abnormalities.

  • Other symptoms like delusions and hallucinations considered secondary, resulting from dysfunctional beliefs and coping styles related to BSs.

Characteristics of Basic Symptoms

  • Can occur in various mental disorders, particularly affective disorders.

  • A subset of cognitive and perceptual BSs specific to psychosis is used in risk criteria for psychosis.

  • Recognized for early detection of psychosis, yet neurobiological research linking BSs to brain function is still emerging.

Table 1: CHR Criteria According to the BSs Concept

Cognitive Disturbances (COGDIS)

  • At least 2 of the following 9 BSs occurring at least weekly (SPI-A/SPI-CY score of ≥3) in the last 3 months:

    • Inability to divide attention (B1a): Difficulty focusing on multiple tasks (e.g., making a sandwich while conversing).

    • Thought interference (C2): Random, irrelevant thoughts intrude.

    • Thought blockages (C3): Mental trailing off leading to a loss of intended thoughts.

    • Disturbance of receptive speech (C4): Difficulty in understanding verbal stimuli.

    • Disturbance of expressive speech (C5): Hardship in accessing the correct words despite clear ideas.

    • Thought pressure (D3): Succession of irrelevant thoughts.

    • Unstable ideas of reference (D4): Immediate insight into reference instability.

    • Disturbances of abstract thinking (O3): Initial literal understanding of metaphors.

    • Captivation of attention by details (O7): Focus on random, irrelevant visual details.

Cognitive-Perceptive Basic Symptoms (COPER)

  • At least 1 of the following 10 BSs occurring at least weekly with the first occurrence at least 12 months ago:

    • Thought interference (C2)

    • Thought blockages (C3)

    • Disturbance of receptive speech (C4)

    • Thought pressure (D3)

    • Unstable ideas of reference (D4)

    • Thought perseveration (O1): Recurrent irrelevant thoughts.

    • Decreased ability to discriminate (O2): Confusion between ideas/perception and true memories.

    • Derealization (O8): Reduction to 2D vision, heightened emotional involvement in surroundings.

    • Visual perception disturbances (D5): Distortions immediately recognized own misperceptions.

    • Acoustic perception disturbances (F5): Similar distortions as visual ones.

Definition of Basic Symptoms

  • Basic symptoms are self-experienced disturbances in:

    • Stress tolerance

    • Drive

    • Affect

    • Thinking

    • Speech

    • Body perception

    • Motor action

    • Central-vegetative functions.

  • Experienced with full insight, rendering them distinct from observable negative symptoms and positive symptoms, which are seen as normal by the individual.

  • Integral to psychosis and appear at various disorder stages, conceptualized as “self-disorders” in combination with selected attenuated psychotic symptoms (APS).

Basic Symptoms: Early Neurobiological Research

  • Huber’s studies linked BSs to brain function through observable abnormalities in areas like the basal ganglia and limbic system, suggesting BSs reflect direct symptomatic expressions of cerebral dysfunction.

  • Abnormal EEG rhythms were hypothesized as transient and only present in early psychotic stages.

Basic Symptoms and Risk for Psychosis

  • Research indicates that although most BSs are not solely specific to psychosis, certain BSs are critical for developing first-episode schizophrenia. 14 BSs identified as indicative.

  • A meta-analysis reported conversion rates of up to 54.9% within 4 years in COGDIS samples, significantly higher than those meeting UHR criteria.

  • COGDIS remains one of the three recommended criteria for CHR assessment by the European Psychiatric Association.

Neurocognition and Basic Symptoms

  • Neurocognitive deficits are prevalent in schizophrenia, also observable in CHR samples.

  • Studies suggested inconsistent findings concerning BS samples mainly affecting executive control and verbal memory.

  • Patients qualifying solely under BS criteria showed fewer cognitive deficits than those with APS or brief limited intermittent psychotic symptoms (BLIPS). This indicates a potential precedence of BSs over neurocognitive impairments.

Basic Symptoms and Current Neurobiological Research

Neurochemistry & Basic Symptoms

  • Neurochemical findings highlight roles for various neurotransmitters (dopaminergic, glutamatergic, serotonergic, GABAergic) in schizophrenia.

  • Current studies focused on dopamine, glutamate, and GABA, revealing significant evidence for presynaptic dopamine synthesis increase in APS patients, although research on BS samples is needed.

Pharmacological Models

  • Ketamine and endocannabinoid systems have been linked with BSs, suggesting that cannabis and ketamine use may relate to cognitive and perceptive BSs.

  • Cannabis-using CHR patients exhibit more BSs than non-users.

Electrophysiology and Basic Symptoms

  • EEG and magnetoencephalographic studies reveal significant changes in neural activity correlating with BS manifestations.

  • Event-related potentials showed reduced emotion recognition abilities in CHR groups, along with indications of disturbances in information processing across neurocognitive measures.

Studies Summary on Neurobiological Mechanisms of Basic Symptoms

  • Overview of various neurobiological studies exploring potential relationships between basic symptoms, neurocognitive function, and disease vulnerability.

  • Notable correlations between BSs, neurocognitive functioning, and structural/functional abnormalities in brain regions indicative of psychosis.

Imaging Studies: Structural and Functional

Structural Findings

  • Five MRI studies show relationships between BSs and morphological changes in brain structures, focusing on groups with different risk levels for psychosis.

  • Findings indicate gray matter reductions in specific cortices among individuals with BSs.

Functional Imaging Findings

  • fMRI studies examining BSs show altered activation patterns in first-episode schizophrenia patients, revealing significant associations between BS severity and connectivity within brain regions related to self-other distinctions.

Discussion and Perspectives on Basic Symptoms

  • Emphasizes the need for further exploration into neurobiological origins of BSs to create effective early detection tools and interventions for psychosis.

  • Highlights the importance of understanding BSs as potential early indicators of psychosis and their implications for therapeutic approaches.

Conclusion

  • Basic symptoms reflect subtle and heterogeneous manifestations of neurobiological abnormalities in schizophrenia.

  • The CHR paradigm shows promise in linking subjective cognitive alterations and neurobiological dysfunctions, essential for improving diagnosis and treatment strategies for psychosis.