Philosophy Notes

Metaphysics, Morality, Truth, Beauty

  • Beauty is self-evident and requires no further explanation.
  • Discussion revolves around spirituality and pure ideas.
  • Pure ideas are unbiased and unfiltered thoughts.

Immanuel Kant and Deontology

  • Immanuel Kant was a deontological philosopher (Deontology: d.e.o.n.t.o.l.o.g.y.).
  • Deontology: The study of duty or obligation to do something.
  • Modern society's emphasis on not owing anything to anyone may indicate a lack of deontology.
  • The idea of not owing anything to anyone is not inherently negative, especially towards those one doesn't respect.
  • Spider-Man's sense of responsibility to help everyone in Queens is an example of deontology.
  • Selfishness is the opposite of deontology, where individuals don't feel obligated to help others.

Kantian Philosophy and Obligations

  • Immanuel Kant started Kantian philosophy.
  • Central idea: Obligations to be moral and just.
  • Means to an end: Treat people as ends in themselves, not as means to an end.
  • Heteronomous: Acting because of external factors or rewards (e.g., blessings from God).
  • Autonomous: Acting for the sake of it, without expecting personal benefit.
  • Heteronomous individuals treat people as a means to their own benefit.
  • Autonomous individuals treat people as ends in themselves; there is no ulterior motive.

Critique of Pure Reason

  • Kant's famous book, The Critique of Pure Reason, studies thinking itself.

  • Pure reason: Unadulterated thinking.

  • Two categories of thinking:

    • A priori: Knowledge independent of external experience (e.g., math, 1+11+1). This is intuitive.

    • A posteriori: Knowledge gained through experience.

  • Metaphysics: Thoughts independent of the physical.

  • Honesty, truth, and morality are a priori.

  • Learning through experience after the fact is a posteriori.

  • A priori is the baseline knowledge; a posteriori is how one learns about it.

  • Subdivisions of a priori and a posteriori into analytic and synthetic judgments:

    • Analytic judgments: Derived from one's own experiences.
    • Synthetic judgments: Combining two ideas.
    • Example:
      • A priori analytical: Killing is wrong.
      • Synthetic a posteriori: Killing in self-defense might be right.

Physics and Branches of Physics

  • Overview of metaphysics and physics.
Ontology
  • The study of reality.
  • Ontological assertion: Statement about how real something is.
  • Math and history provide different kinds of knowledge and truth.
  • Poetry contains truth, even if it's fiction.
  • Analysis of the existence of different beings (e.g., God, angels).
Logic
  • System of rules for deriving true inferences from premises and conclusions.
  • System of reasoning to gain a true inference.
  • Premise: A statement.
  • Syllogism: Two premises and a conclusion.
    • Example:
      • x is y.
      • y is z.
      • Therefore, x is z.
    • Another example:
      • Murder is a crime.
      • Crimes are punished.
      • Therefore, murder should be punished.
Epistemology
  • The study of knowledge.
  • From Greek: Episteme (knowledge) and logi (study of).
  • Study of knowledge, where we get our knowledge, is the knowledge valuable, is it worthy, is it true?
  • Thinking about thinking.
  • Theory of knowledge.
Theory of the Knower
  • Focuses on who is doing the thinking.
  • Connects to psychology and the philosophy of mind.
Aesthetics
  • Theory of beauty.
  • Role of beauty in society.
  • Subjective vs. objective beauty (e.g., Da Vinci paintings).
Ethics
  • Judgments of what is right and wrong.
  • Morality.
  • Obligations.

Plato: What Is?

  • Philosophical question: What is man? What is everything?
  • Two answers in ancient Greece:
    • One world: Philosophers before Socrates (pre-Socratics) like Democritus. They viewed the world as composed of elements (fire, water, earth, wind).
    • Two worlds: Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle. Plato believed in the world of forms, where perfect examples of things exist.
  • World of forms: Metaphysical place containing perfect things (e.g., a platonic chair).
  • Platonic solids: Perfect dimensional shapes like the cube, icosahedron, and tetrahedron.
  • Sacred geometry and Pythagoras influenced Plato.
  • In Plato's time, math was like witchcraft.
  • Mystical and mathematical were intertwined in philosophy.
  • Plato may have been influenced by the Pythagoreans and their perfect shapes.
  • World of forms contains perfect a priori ideas like truth and beauty.

Branches of Philosophy: Ontology, Logic, Epistemology, Aesthetics, and Ethics

  • Many paths can lead to the same truth in philosophy.
  • Plato's philosophy serves as a base for Western philosophy.
  • Art flourished in caliphates during Europe's darker periods.
  • House of Wisdom in Baghdad: Rediscovered works of Euclid and Pythagoras; invented algebra.
  • Humans' ability to start from nothing and progress.

Politics

  • Socrates, Plato, and others discussed politics as Athenian citizens.
  • Athenian democracy: Citizen participation as a civil duty.
  • Ethics at an individual level translates to politics at a societal level.

Mythos and Logos

  • Logos: Logic, freedom to think rationally as secular citizens in Athens.
  • Mythos: Myths, stories, heroes, and gods.
  • Division between following the gods (mythos) and rational thought (logos).
  • Ring Cycle: Hagen represents the desire to destroy the gods for power.
  • Myths of Greece and Rome.

Athens and Jerusalem

  • Two influential cities in Western civilization.
  • Athens (Plato, Socrates): Democracy and secularism.
  • Jerusalem: The Bible and religious thought.
  • Logos meant human rationale in Athens but the rationality of God in Jerusalem.
  • The Bible starts with the word, emphasizing its importance in Jerusalem.
  • Athens was about freedom and rationality, while Jerusalem focused on reverence and faith.
  • The Western world has a religious base towards God, while the Eastern world emphasizes family obligations.
  • New Testament (Gospel of John): "In the beginning was the word, and the word was with God, and the word was God."
  • Athens (democracy, politics) contrasts with Jerusalem (the word, scripture).