Philosophical Definitions of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Goods
Distinction Between Intrinsic and Extrinsic Goods
Intrinsic Goods: Defined as values that are considered "good in itself." This signifies that the value is inherent to the object or concept and is not dependent on external factors.
Extrinsic/Extra Goods: These are items or concepts described as "good because of something else." - A specific term used in the discussion is "extra good good" for things that are not good inherently but derive value from their utility or output. - These goods are often described as being good "given the circumstances" or "given, like, a need."
Categorization of Specific Examples
Money: Identified as a primary example of an extrinsic good. It is not valued for its own sake but for its ability to obtain other things of value.
Virtue: Cited as an example of an intrinsic good, particularly within a "virtue of the system" or virtue ethics framework.
Pleasure: Mentioned as a candidate for an intrinsic good, depending on the philosophical theory being applied.
Utility: Discussed in the context of things that "bring utility." Whether utility is an intrinsic or extrinsic good depends entirely on the specific ethical theory in question.
Theoretical Frameworks and Categorization
Variability of Definition: The transcript emphasizes that there is significant disagreement among individuals and philosophers regarding what constitutes an intrinsic good.
Ethical Categories: An individual's answer to what is intrinsically good is the defining factor that places them into different "categories of jest of of ethics."
Theoretical Overlap: Depending on the specific philosophical theory, both acts of virtue and things that bring utility can be classified as intrinsic goods.
Questions & Discussion
Question: "So it would be, like, an act of virtue versus, like, something that gives you brings utility?"
Response: The speaker clarifies that, depending on the theory, both an act of virtue and something that brings utility could be considered intrinsic.
Question: "So what's an example example of extra good good?"
Response: "Money."
Question: "Oh, what's the example of the intrinsic good?"
Response: "Virtue," with the caveat that this applies if one is operating within a virtue-based system.
Interactive Survey: The session concludes with the instructor initiating a survey among the audience, asking for a show of hands beginning with the prompt: "Raise your hand. If ego…"