Ethnicity in Aging

Introduction

  • Bart Hircus runs exercise classes for older people at housing complexes and recreation centres for seniors.

  • A few years ago, an Indigenous senior centre invited him to hold fitness classes.

    • He was assigned a room and informed in advance about the class.

    • Upon arrival, about 10 people, men and women, attended his session.

  • Hircus began with warm-up stretches and continued with his routine using upbeat music.

  • During the session, participants started drifting to a nearby patio to smoke and chat.

    • They would intermittently wander in and out to observe the class.

  • After about 30 minutes, Bart gave up trying to get them to exercise and initiated conversation with the members.

  • He learned that the seniors associated exercise with hard work and could not comprehend exercising without compensation.

    • They had previously worked hard as trappers and hunters, linking exercise with labour.

  • Bart enjoyed the experience and learned from listening to the participants.

  • Current practices:

    • Bart now tailors programs for ethnic seniors by understanding their culture and background.

    • He explains the purpose and benefits before commencing classes.

    • Adjusts programs to fit participants' backgrounds and experiences.

Insights on Culture and Aging

  • Gerontologists' Understanding: Culture and life events shape an older person's worldview.

    • Diverse senior experiences based on cultural backgrounds and economic challenges.

  • Definitions of Ethnicity:

    • Ethnicity refers to a person’s or their ancestors’ place of birth.

    • Citizenship, religious affiliations, values, and beliefs are also defining factors.

  • Variations among Ethnic Seniors:

    • Some have been in Canada for generations, while others may just arrive.

    • Differences exist in expectations for family support, community roles, and religious practices.

  • Barriers:

    • Cultural and economic barriers can inhibit satisfying lives in old age.

  • Service Recommendations:

    • Providing services in ethnic seniors' first language.

    • Hiring staff who share the same ethnic background.

    • Locating services in ethnic-friendly settings.

  • Study of Ethnicity and Aging:

    • Expands understanding of aging and offers pathways to improve lives of ethnic seniors.

Exploring Ethnicity

  • Shifting Ethnic Identity:

    • A person’s ethnicity might change over time (e.g., Métis in youth, French Canadian in adulthood).

  • Self-Identification:

    • Individuals can choose their ethnic identity, which can shift based on circumstances.

    • External perceptions can impose identities (e.g., identifying as Canadian vs. being identified as Asian).

Hypothetical Example of Ethnic Identity

  • Case Study of Sophie:

    • Third-generation Canadian with diverse ancestry from Canada, Britain, Senegal, etc.

    • Practices various cultural celebrations: Eid, Christmas, etc.

    • Multilingual upbringing in English and French, self-identifying across cultures.

  • Cultural and Citizenship Dynamics:

    • Citizenships: British, Canadian, Senegalese.

Theoretical Perspectives on Ethnicity and Aging

Multiple Jeopardy Theory

  • Concept: Individuals facing multiple disadvantages (e.g., non-white, female, elderly) experience greater disadvantage than those facing one.

    • Example: A visible minority older woman vs. a middle-aged white man.

  • Significance: Provides insight into various layers of discrimination, poverty, and health risks.

  • Research Focus: Since the theory is difficult to measure, multiple jeopardy studies often rely on cross-sectional designs.

    • Longitudinal studies are advocated to truly capture conditions of disadvantage over time.

  • Indigenous Seniors: Their experiences reflect the intersecting effects of age, gender, and socio-economic status, revealing unique challenges compared to the general population.

Intersectionality Theory

  • Origin: Roots in feminism and critical race theory.

  • Focus: The interplay of socio-economic and identity factors (ethnicity, class, immigrant status) influencing seniors’ experiences.

  • Government Programs: Recognition of the absence of public pensions for specific vulnerable groups like immigrant older women.

  • Research Findings: Emphasizes community engagement themes like support, trauma, and resilience among the older immigrant population.

Life Course Perspective

  • Overview: Analyzes life from birth to death, considering social, cultural, and historical contexts that influence seniors.

  • Implications: Different life experiences (immigration, cohabitation, etc.) shape attitudes and behaviours in old age.

  • Biographical Importance: Two contrasting Chinese Canadian seniors exemplify diversity in aging experiences based on backgrounds and historical contexts.

  • Cumulative Disadvantages: Recognizes how disadvantages accumulate, especially among visible minorities, leading to issues in retirement, poverty, and health.

Seniors' Experiences of Ethnicity

influences on Ethnic Seniors' Experiences

  1. Immigration:

    • Canada is highly multicultural, home to various ethnic and religious groups.

  2. Acculturation:

    • Ethnic seniors are influenced by their heritage and mainstream Canadian culture, impacting behaviours and experiences over generations.

  • Factors impacting experiences:

    1. Adherence to heritage culture values.

    2. Age at immigration.

    3. Duration of residence in Canada.

  • Access to Benefits: Recently immigrated seniors may lack access to essential programs due to language barriers and unfamiliarity with Canadian systems.

  • Discrimination: Racial biases persist even among those well-integrated into society, illustrating systemic challenges faced by ethnic seniors.

Profile of Canadian Seniors

  • Demographics:

    • In 2016, 69% of seniors were born in Canada; of the remaining, 31% were immigrants.

    • Immigration trends: Majority from Asia in recent decades.

  • Visible Minority Seniors:

    • Approximately 11% of seniors identify as belonging to a visible minority group.

    • The largest groups: South Asians, Chinese, Black Canadians, and more.

  • Urban Concentration: Immigrant seniors tend to cluster in big cities with different needs from their Canadian-born counterparts, affecting service provision and scalability.